Reviews

I finished watching this brilliant story about a week ago and debated writing a review. But I loved this story so much I decided to give my opinion (:



The story is great! It's original, funny, sweet, sad. There were parts that made me laugh so much, parts that made me cry. I loved almost all of the characters - and it's always nice to see a main girl who knows how to defend herself. I think this is one of the few dramas I've watched where I've even found myself liking the second main lead girl. I knew I would love this drama by the end of episode 1 and I wasn't wrong. It's hard to choose a favorite among the characters, because they were all great! Including Secretary Kim and Ah Young.



The acting is amazing! Hyun Bin and Ha Ji Won did a terrific job - especially during the parts when they switched. They really acted each other out well! And the other actors did great, too (You really get a feel for the characters).



The music is great! I love the soundtrack! My favorite song was "Scar," but I loved "That Man" and "Appear" as well as the other songs.



I will definitely watch this drama again, I've just seen it and I've thought about rewatching it again sometime soon.



Overall - it really is a great drama to watch (as I keep mentioning, haha). If you're the type who enjoys romantic comedies with a twist, this one is great (: I agree with all of the other reviewers who have rated this drama well, it really is a wonderful story - so... watch it! (:

Lire davantage

To start off with - I don't know why this drama is categorized as a Romance drama on DramaWiki - there's very little to none in this drama. That aside, the drama was good without it. From the beginning I wasn't sure how I was going to like this drama, it's not that the story was boring, but it is a little slow in the beginning. What kept me going farther on is the mystery. This drama was more of a mystery/suspense/drama. It had me wondering what was going to happen next. Almost all of the characters gave me mixed feelings, at times I wasn't sure how I should feel about them. Especially Kim In Sook. As a main lead she's hard to understand and it's hard to like her because of that. Each episode made me wonder who exactly she was, what had happened to her to make her the person she became. Ji Hoon's character was one of the few characters I found myself liking from the beginning.



The acting was great! It was really good! I started watching this drama because Ji Sung is one of the main actors (Ji Hoon). After seeing him act in Protect The Boss I wanted to try another one of his dramas. To see him go from a more comedic role to something serious just proves he's a great actor. If you're a fan of his, this drama won't disappoint you when it comes to him. The main girl, Yum Jung Ah, did a really good job with her character. The other actors were great, as well.



The music fit the drama. There were a few songs, none of which stood out to me though. The instrumental part was good, the ending of each episode when the song plays made it out to be even more intense - and to see what happens next.



My rewatch value is low because although I found this to be a good drama, it's not something that became a favorite or something I'd want to rewatch more than once.



Overall - I think this drama is worth watching. If you're in the mood for something at a different pace aside from romantic comedies and such, this is a good drama to watch.

Lire davantage

This drama isn't as spectacular as I thought it was going to be. The episodes were only 36 min. but they felt longer just because the story was a little slow at times. I was disappointed, that although the leads were suppose to have this great romance, they only dated briefly before breaking up. Then they spent the rest of the drama a part. So it was kind of hard to feel for them and want them together in the end. I actually liked the stories of the supporting cast much more than the actual romance. The ending could have been done better as well. Still, this is just a great drama to watch when you've seen the better J romance dramas.

Lire davantage

I've wanted to see Secret Garden for a few months, because I had heard that the drama had been a weird hit in Korea. Finally, I've watched at all.

The all story is unlikely, but I admit I watched it with pleasure. Ra Im and her sweet-sharp style were wonderful. Ju Won the same. The guy has got very difficult character, but he is male too. Appreciation for the actors! The body confusion, changing gestures.. great! Oska... I like him! a little arrogant, but he had to survive somehow. I though he wanted to steal the brother's girlfriend for a moment, but no... fidelity won.

I always know that love is the best in dramas!

Lire davantage

My Girlfriend is a Gumiho tells very original story about tragic love. Now, I know that I am a big fan of Hong sisters' productions. Every thier drama is hit! We see, that authors have own favourites characters, which are matched to plot.

Gu Mi Ho is so cute... I like when Dae Woong tames her slowly. I wish there was more fantasy elements. There were showed only light or bad shots...Hmm.. maybe too smal budget? It's a pity! It was the most interesting part of drama. Except for the main characters I've become interested in misterious Park Dong Ju. I would like to know his past better, because the secrets are still puzzle for me.

Hmm.. I mentioned it is the tragic story, but unfortunately.. they demaged the end. I think the ideal end was on th gym, when Mi Ho disappears... Awww... it is only my script version.

Lire davantage

My Girl is pretty good drama, though I definately prefer comedy scenes, where miss Yu Rin is in the spothlight. Then the stroy turns into a melodrama and unfortunately, there is sometimes boring too.

Dong Uk or Jun Gi.. I don't kno who is better here..

I wonder what the infatuation could be between Jin Gyu and the assistant. Mandarin sewing was glorious! xD

The love story between In Seon and Il Do needs a special episode... and this french background music from old film..

There was the only one thing, which I can't understand, why they havn't wanted to show the cousin's true face for long time. These shots were really strange...

Lire davantage

Seriously, I've just seen a lot of people saying that this drama was boring. Actually, as for me, it wasn't.

Well the story was not that much deep, but it was actually why I liked it. Because it was totally refreshing. It was pleasant. No story of revenge, not that much conspiracy... Actually, it felt light, and I liked it because it didn't was heavy and annoying.

Well, as for the casting. Jung Yonghwa and Park Shin Hye assured it. It wasn't perfect, but it went well. I think it was even rather good. And Kang Minhyuk did a very good job, and you can't hate his character. The cast was good, according to me.

The music was pleasant too, and really present in all the drama. That was nice, even though I'm not a really great fan of Park Shin Hye's voice.

I think that this drama was really refreshing and nice.

Lire davantage

Ok first of all i have to sadly admit that even though i like Wu Chun a lot, through this hole drama i`ve felt that this role was meant for Mike He, the hair style too of course.



First i`ll say what i didn`t like about this drama and then what i like. Beside the main role that i mentioned i don`t think the title fits the story and that it has no relation at all with the tragedy Romeo & Juliet. I don`t really see any reasonable reason why they can`t be together till Sui`s competition against Chu Xing in the last episodes. And the thing i personally felt that was exaggerated was that almost all the guys around Sui fell for her and tried to break her and Liang apart same goes for the girls who fell for Liang (wouldn`t have been enough 1 or 2). This is all :P



Now for what i liked goes like this. The story is unique and out of the usual story line. It`s the first drama that made me anxious in watching the next ep but still impatient for watching it. This was what makes it special. The cast acted great and Ariel and Wu Chun had good chemistry going on there (and i`m not contradicting myself what i said first is true even though Wu Chun played well his role, i had the feeling Mike He would fit better). The side characters where good too and i liked them they where all funny. The music was really good too, especially the op song was really good.



It`s a shame i didn`t watch it earlier (because of the title i thought it`s going to be more like a tragedy and tearjerker so it was hard to bring myself to watch it). Don`t make the same mistake as i did. Just watch it, you won`t regret. Even if it`s an old drama it sure doen`t feel like it! Enjoy!

Lire davantage