Park ShinHye? Demoness? Yaaassss!
The story is overall quite simple with a demon coming to earth to punish sinners aka murderers by using her powers, because she punished the wrong person in hell. Objectively stating, the thing that really attracted me to this show was how it avoided all the story cliches. Generally, the role of a mythical being is played by the ML but here it is our FL and I also liked that instead of a lawyer it is a judge. Pretty great and unique.The story started out great with a lot of devil and blood, the romance is also very well developed. Instead of them just finding heavenly love at first sight I loved how they let there love blossom slowly. Believe it or not this show has only 1 proper kiss scene and that is at the end. And I am not complaining it was awesome. It had its own beauty. While we are on the topic. I loved the ML too. He was a sweetheart instead of the normal stoic ones we get. Now that I think of it no one was stoic in this series. Is it what I think it is? A breath of fresh air.
The story was rather short with only 14 episodes, but I still thing it could’ve done better. Till the time the story reached the end it had quite a few strands loose. Like the angel went to hell to save a ‘good’ demon. Or that the one will die curse was a lie. The writers dug the hole so deep that they themselves didn’t know how to get out. But that is just my opinion.
Even with a few strands loose this story was awesome. It was engaging, charming, a little bit confusing but it had kept me on my toes till the end.I admire them for it. I do wish the ending episode would’ve more couple moments but we all wish for things. Tbh my main issue was only with the somewhat childish ending but at least they didn’t use the cliche where the dead ML comes back to life at the last 0.25 millisecond of the last episode.
I still think adding the one will die curse was unnecessary, they could’ve just made it simpler, but come on you have to agree nothing was more satisfying then watch Bitna beating everything out of those monsters. I do think she was not portrayed to be demonic enough, she had more of a vigilante vibes then a devil from hell vibes but I digress.
Oh and one last thing I must appreciate. The AD PLACEMENT! Future dramas take inspiration! that is how you place ads in between. You put them subtly instead of pushing it in our faces!
In the end. Yes I loved it, you willl too. Yes, I will forever love this ship. Yes, I didn’t appreciate the ML enough in this summary. I hate Bael too.
Will watch it again
Cet avis était-il utile?
Exploring Moral Dilemmas and Supernatural Justice: A Review of The Judge From Hell
The Judge From Hell is a captivating fantasy thriller that hooks viewers with its unique blend of supernatural elements and moral dilemmas. The premise, which cleverly incorporates law and justice within the realm of demons, adds a compelling complexity that keeps the story engaging. Bitna's character exemplifies this contradiction; she initially appears as an unstoppable force, executing judgments with precision, but her growing emotional attachment to Daon creates an inner conflict that adds depth, even if it sometimes slows the plot's momentum.The trials Bitna administers reflect the moral principle of “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you,” and I found her brutal yet fitting approach to justice both intriguing and thought-provoking. While these sequences carried emotional weight and were integral to the narrative, some felt drawn out, affecting the overall pacing. Additionally, the haunting soundtrack enhanced the dark atmosphere, adapting beautifully to the show’s emotional range and elevating the viewing experience.
Despite some pacing issues, the performances were strong, particularly Park Shin-hye as Bitna, who brought fierce energy to her role. However, I found Kim Jae-young’s character to be a bit divisive; his rapid discovery of Bitna’s secrets diminished some tension. The cliffhanger ending leaves the future of the story open, which could either be a clever setup for a second season or a frustrating conclusion if unresolved. Overall, I would rate the series 4 out of 5 stars, as it successfully weaves a strong premise with engaging characters and a compelling mix of moral dilemmas and supernatural elements.
READ MY FULL REVIEW HERE: https://diyarisks.blogspot.com/2024/11/the-judge-from-hell-2024-series-review.html
Cet avis était-il utile?
JUST A SCI- FI THRILLER KINDA DRAMA !
At first, I started watching this for just some time. I guess it was worth my time. This drama had a different storyline from other cliche dramas. It started off with a good storyline. As a sci-fi drama, I can say it was good, but it could be much better. I didn't like the ending. There wasn't that much romance, but they added it still a bit. I liked the ML there. I saw him for the first time here in this drama; his acting was good. Park Shin Hye acted good too. loved to see her in a quircky character other than an obedient, crying poor girl. I enjoyed every story though; those cases were amusing to watch. If you love thrillers and sci-fi, you guys can give it a go.Cet avis était-il utile?
Satisfaction pro Max
The Judge from Hell is a wild ride—super emotional and definitely gets you thinking. The main characters have a lot of depth, and you really **feel** for them as they dive into revenge. The emotional payoff? Totally satisfying. But the plot does get kinda repetitive. Like, the revenge arc stays the same throughout, and after a while, you kinda know what’s coming next. Still, it hits that sweet spot of justice and catharsis, so it works.The big question here: is legal punishment enough, or does the cycle of violence keep going? The show does a good job of making you think about it. Also, shoutout to the male lead—he was absolutely adorable! His performance really carried the emotional weight, making the show way more impactful than it could’ve been.
Production is top-tier. The acting is solid, the visuals are great, and the soundtrack really sets the mood. It’s not the most groundbreaking show, but if you’re into intense character drama and moral dilemmas, it’s worth watching.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
A Powerful Drama of Justice & Revenge
The Judge from Hell is a solid drama blending thriller and mystery elements. The judge’s quest for vengeance was incredibly satisfying, and the overall atmosphere of the series became more compelling as the episodes progressed. However, I must admit that the moments I truly enjoyed were when the judge tracked down the criminals and delivered the justice they deserved. The acting—whether from the main or supporting cast—was fantastic. Each actor played their respective role exceptionally well, adding depth and nuance to the story.That said, I need to address the romance subplot, which I found poorly executed. Justitia’s sudden and underdeveloped feelings for Daon felt random and lacked depth. On the other hand, the storyline focusing on Daon’s feelings for Justitia was, in my opinion, handled much better at the beginning. However, this quality dropped off in the last 2–3 episodes, where his emotions felt rushed and unconvincing.
Additionally, the romance between the two characters often felt awkward. I wasn’t entirely convinced by the chemistry between the actors, and the excessive displays of affection—like the 40 hugs in a single episode—felt unnecessary and cringeworthy. These moments could have been omitted without losing anything substantial from the story. I believe this issue partly stems from the actress, Park Shin Hye. Having watched her dramas since 2011, I think she’s a talented actress overall, but romantic chemistry has never been her strong suit.
Honestly, the romance subplot could have been left out entirely. If it’s not well-executed, why include it? Either deliver a convincing, heartfelt romance, or skip it altogether and stick to the mystery, fantasy, and thriller elements that made the drama shine.
Despite these flaws, The Judge from Hell is an excellent drama. I almost binge-watched the entire series in just two days! (Though, to be fair, I skipped about three-quarters of the last episode.) Even with my earlier criticisms, Park Shin Hye delivered a strong performance, and I was especially impressed by Kim Jae Young, who surprised me with his portrayal. He’s definitely an actor I’ll keep an eye on going forward!
Cet avis était-il utile?
EymiLaritzaJorgeCastillo
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Increíble
La historia de un demonio que es juez en el infierno y es castigada por sentenciar incorrectamente a una jueza que llego al infierno siendo "Inocente" y que tendrá que matar a una cantidad e asesinos en el mundo humano para poder volver al infierno o sino morirá.La premisa me encanto desde el inicio y cada episodio me dejo mas intrigada en que pasaría, ame a ver a Park Shin Hye en este papel, fue diferente a lo que he visto de ella anteriormente y le quedo perfecto.
Aunque la historia gira entre la vida y la muerte y el infierno, hubo cavidad para el romance y en especial la actuación del beso del ultimo ep fue la mejor en ese ámbito, lo recalco, porque siempre dicen que las escenas de ella en este aspecto son fatales.
Sobre las actuaciones en general, pues fueron muy buenas y me encantaron, fueron geniales todos, y en mi opinión sentí que transmitían en cada momento.
En cuanto a la musica, uff ame este OST desde la canción principal hasta la musica de ambiente, sentí una correcta musicalización en la serie, al menos en mi opinión, no sentía forzada la musica y veía que transmitían bastante de la escena solo con ella.
Sobre el final, no dare spoilers, pero si me gusto lo ultimo del final, fue genial, sobre el rostro, si creo que si hubiera sido mensos largo mejor.
Sin duda una serie que tuvo de todo, especialmente venganza, me gusto que aunque tuvo romance, nunca fue el foco principal y tuvo la dosis perfecta en la historia, algunas cosas si puedo decir que las sentí mas simple, especialmente algunas escenas entorno al final, pero de igual manera el desarrollo en general fue divino, y la historia se sentía ligera y disfrutable desde el inicio.
Espero seguir viendo a estos actores en diferentes papeles en el futuro, realmente me creí la historia de todos!
Cet avis était-il utile?
IBLIS, MANUSIA, DAN MALAIKAT YANG BEKERJA SAMA.
Salah satu drama terbaik yang pernah di tonton. aksi hakim iblis yang kena hukum dan bersarang ditubuh manusia bernama bitna sukses mencuri perhatian karena gayanya yang nyentrik dan absurd juga caranya menghakimi tersangka sangat luar biasa. Hakim iblis ini rela tinggal di tempat sederhana dan memiliki banyak hutang karena gaya hidupnya. Paling iconic dan gak bisa dilupain adalah saat ia menghukum para tersangka dengan caranya dimana sebelum di tusuk sampai mati, bitna akan membuat tersangka merasakan kejahatan yang telah diperbuat. Aksi, thriller, fantasi ini juga dibumbui kisah romance antara iblis & manusia🫶. gak lupa juga malaikat yang rela mengorbankan diri demi iblis penegak keadilan didunia manusia. Berharap ada session 2 karena bitna belum memutuskan akan menjadi manusia atau akan tetap menjadi iblis justitia di akhir episode❤️.Cet avis était-il utile?
DRAMAAAAAAA!!!!! akting park shin hye yg udh gabisa diragukan lagi apalagi dengan masa karir nya yg udah melejit sedari kecil, dan akting kim jae young yang mengimbangin shin hye, menurutku jae young di drama ini bener bener berbeda dari drama sebelumnya, begitu juga dengan park shin hye. shin hye yg biasanya memainkan karakter dengan latar belakang yang tidak memiliki apa apa kini memainkan karakter yang tidak ber empati dan mati rasa. serta jae young di drama ini yang terlihat lebih mencolok dan menarik perhatian para penonton tjfh dengan sangat mudahnya. BEST DRAMA IN 2024!!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Korean version of The Punisher
Park Shin Hye steals the show as Kang Bitna, a judge who gets possessed by the demon judge Justicia after her death. She is a fashion star, crazy, violent and arrogant. But all of this is put together into a likeable character package, who makes you root for her brand of justice. The story revolves around her journey from being the devil who only cares about going back to hell to developing human emotions and understanding different perspectives. Bitna's lopsided smirk and crazy eyes when staring at those scummy criminals makes for the biggest highlight of the show.Kim Jae-young as Han Daon had the perfect puppy-dog eyes that brought out the human in the demon. His heartbreaking origin story aside, but loosing another family member, the kind, tough as nails boss lady, was a bit too much. He perfectly emoted his struggle of wanting to be a good police officer but also setting aside everything and getting his revenge. I found the chemistry between the main leads to be a bit lacking, though the good looks on both sides made up for it.
I absolutely loved the ensemble cast. Every single one had stories to tell, however small, and brought depth to the overall plot. I was expecting to be moved by the stories of those left behind (was a big sucker for Taxi Driver for a similar reason), but seeing the cheery, church going landlady break down really got to me. I adored the old grandmother, i am just going to stop here, but her and Bitna's back and forth was such a treat to watch, provided a little light in between the pain.
The only major issue i had was the plot towards the end. I think it would have been better to have 2 more episodes, but make the ending, less rushed and more rational. Satan just being defeated like it's no big deal sort of undermined the story they set up, and the usually smart & meticulous J having a complete breakdown once confronted with a single problem felt a bit off. The guy just straigh up confessed in court, and even if arrogant and hateful, it felt forced just to give the families closure and justify Bitna's ultimate beatdown. I understand they wanted to focus on justice within the boundaries of law and human evil but still, I hoped there was a bit more to it.
Overall, definitely worth a watch. To more dramas where evil is punished, so people can live vicariously through them.
Cet avis était-il utile?
chatterbug_butterfly
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Great story but some things could've been better.
Firstly the the drama was a great binge. I think it is one of the best kdramas in recent. Ive lost all my interest in kdramas because of the repetitive story lines. But this one caught my attention.Over all the story was great. But they could've avoided the romance track. If there was no romance track at all the story could've been actually interesting and intense. Also i felt the ending was kind of open. Viewers like me might think there will be another season with such an ending.
Park Shin Hye's character was a badass character and i think somebody else might've been a better choice like Seo Yea Ji, IU, etc., Park Shin Hye was definitely not a right choice. Some viewers say that her acting has gotten better now but i think she is still the same. Finally the male leads character was really good and the actor was a perfect fit. But at times the character was paced down because of all the romance.
Overall it was a good series but they could've avoided certain things. It can be a good one time watch during the weekends.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
เปิดมาดีมากๆ ช่วง 3 ตอนแรกชอบมาก แต่พอไปเรื่อยๆเริ่มเฉยๆ ยิ่งพอนางเอกเริ่มชอบพระเอกแล้วดรอปลงเลย ตอนแก้แค้นเหมือนจะสะใจแต่ส่วนตัวว่าเฉยๆ ดูแบบไปเรื่อยๆ นางเอกเล่นดีมากๆๆ พระเอกเล่นพอได้ไม่ถึงกับแข็งไม่ถึงกับอินแถมบทน่ารำคาญอยู่หน่อยๆ
แต่จบดี เดาไว้อยู่แล้วว่าไม่น่าจะ bad end คงสมหวังไม่ก็ปลายเปิด ก็เป็นตามนั้น
Cet avis était-il utile?
Dose certa de episódios e de mistério
Confesso que comecei a ver esse dorama julgando e pensando que logo ia dropar. Porém, foi uma surpresa pra mim.É bem o estilo do seriado “Lúcifer” e, mesmo ainda não o superando, consegue prender a atenção e nos fazer vibrar com os personagens e as histórias.
Pode se dizer que os atores trabalharam muito bem e não houveram furos de roteiro grandiosos (tirando a parte de que uma juíza com diagnóstico psicológico grave ainda conseguir trabalhar normalmente - e ainda visivelmente fazendo vários julgamentos duvidosos).
A química do casal também não foi lá essas coisas, mas não interfere tanto já que o foco do dorama não é o romance.
Enfim, apesar desses detalhes que apontei foi um dorama interessante de acompanhar, houveram poucos episódios lentos e pra quem gosta do tema, tem bastante tiro, porrada e bomba literalmente hahaha… dito isso, eu indico o dorama, foi um dos melhores k dramas do ano!
Cet avis était-il utile?