Le problème dramatique et malheureusement si véridique du harcèlement scolaire...
Beaucoup aimé, vraiment très bon drama !L’histoire part d’un fait-divers trop banal, le suicide éventuel d’un adolescent. Puis le drama se déroule sur deux lignes entrecroisées : le séisme qu’un tel évènement provoque dans la famille et l’entourage, et la recherche acharnée de la vérité par les parents du jeune garçon.
Ceux-ci refusent absolument la thèse du suicide causé par le stress des notes, mais cette thèse arrange beaucoup de monde : l’école qui ne cherche qu’une seule chose : pas de vague ! (on connaît tous bien ce phénomène ! ) et les autres parents qui trouvent cela plus simple que de courir le risque d’impliquer leurs propres enfants.
La peinture du désespoir indicible de la famille est profondément juste, la sidération, les larmes, et le refus, la colère… La lâcheté de l’organisation de l’école et des autres parents, l’impuissance du professeur principal, les mains liées de la police, tout cela est parfaitement mis en scène. C’est la volonté acharnée des parents de vouloir comprendre qui sera la plus forte.
Au fur et à mesure de l’avancée de l’enquête des voiles se déchirent, des vérités affreuses sont révélées. Cet évènement va obliger certains à revoir leur vie, d’autres à remettre en question leur profession d’enseignants, et va amener à des prises de conscience : « il voulait me parler, je ne l’ai pas rappelé..; » « Il allait mal et ne m’a rien dit, et je croyais qu’il me faisait confiance… » « je n’ai rien su voir… » Pourtant on aimerait tous avoir (ou avoir été) des parents comme ceux de Seon Ho !
En face, le Directeur, sa femme et son fils opposent la vision d’une famille où seuls comptent les notes, la réussite, le rang social. Les deux mères se trouvent toutes deux en face d’un drame impliquant leur fils, toutes les deux prêtes tout pour le sauver, mais la différence réside en la façon d’appréhender le problème. Comme le dit le père de Seon Ho à un de ses élèves « nous faisons tous des bêtises, ce qui compte c’est ce qui se passe après, et comment on y fait face » . Le drama fait la démonstration de ce que la peur et les préjugés peuvent entraîner comme terribles évènements, sans vrai manichéisme, pourtant, on n’oublie pas qu’on a affaire à de simples humains…
La réalisation est très soignée et étudiée : la maison qui sert de décor à la famille du directeur est très vastes, sur plusieurs niveaux, avec beaucoup de cloisons percées de verrières de différentes formes. Les personnages évoluent dans cet aquarium toujours derrière des vitres biseautées qui dédoublent l’image, ou derrières des encadrements de vitres qui les mettent constamment comme en prison derrière des barreaux… Très souvent les acteurs se trouvent dans des pièces très vastes, au plafond bas, avec une profondeur de champ qui les écrase… Les personnages sont souvent filmés de loin… Cette mise en scène accentue la sensation de prise dans un labyrinthe . Il y a peu d’extérieurs, ou ce sont des scènes de rues avec beaucoup de monde, ou enfermés dans une voiture qui roule vite…
La fin, on ne l’aurait pas voulue autre, même si, à strictement parler, elle n’est pas très vraisemblable… l’évolution est trop rapide… mais je veux pas la spoiler !
Au total j’ai été passionnée par ce drama, que je n’ai pas lâché. Les acteurs sont très bons, particulièrement le père (Park Hee Soon)et la mère de Seon Ho(Choo Ja Hyung), et aussi sa sœur (j’avais remarquée la jeune actrice Kim Hwan Hee dans « when the weather is fine » !) Nam Da reum, déjà une longue filmographie pour son jeune âge, est excellent, comme toujours ! Les parents adverses (si je puis dire !) sont aussi parfaits. On reconnaîtra l’épouse bourgeoise de « Parasite » Cho Yeo Jeong, et Oh Man Seok est glaçant de certitudes d’impunité et de supériorité sociale.
Un mot pour la très belle OST, un peu répétitive, mais on est en Corée ! La belle chanson revient souvent, mais rarement en entier, juste une bout de mélodie, et comme il n’y a pas les paroles sur mon téléchargement, c’est parfait !
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Good starts promise a good watch, and this enraptured me from the get-go. I am not big on watching or reading things surrounding school; however, what captured my attention was the highlighting of adults’ struggles when it comes to school violence. This was not about students alone, but teachers and parents too, and I appreciate those shifts in perspective. Furthermore, it did not brush over any harsh details while discussing bullying; neither was it afraid to delve into the cruelty of children, because, let’s face it, some children ARE cruel. But it also prevented painting every occurrence in a black and white stroke.The life of this drama lay within the situation it had created that allowed the writer to explore the helplessness that is integral to human nature. It discussed how environments shape people, how parents shape children, and how the basic instinct to protect your offspring can have far-reaching consequences. It did not limit itself to calling bullies the scum of the earth, and unfolded their domestic situations and personalities. It depicted many kinds of bullies: one doing it for pleasure, one doing it under pressure, one attacking what they cannot have, and one acting as a bystander. There were also those who redeemed themselves and those that went on with life. Moreover, the relationships the writer had drawn were really heartfelt. My favourite was Moo Jin and his student Dong Soo's consideration for each other. The side stories and characters had a purpose, either acting as an insight into the characters or served to help them grow. Not to mention, I became attached to them, and so will any viewer, I am sure, especially to Dong Hee and Dong Soo.
This drama happens to be one of the rare cases where flashbacks did not become an intrusion because the transitions from present to past and back again were edited nicely. The imagery was great as well, for example: Joon Seok lived in a glass-like house, very telling of the prison-like environment imposed upon him 24/7, and then there was the warmth of Seon Ho’s home. The reference to The Catcher in the Rye was befitting to the topic at hand.
The pacing could be painstakingly slow at times, but it’s a melodrama, so it is a given. I think the writer could have stretched the show to two more episodes to cover the aftermath in a better way, or the given time should have been used more efficiently by cutting out repeated moments and adding in those worthy of being shown. I think Joon Seok’s redemption and new-found friendship with Dong Soo had great power and should have been explored further. Had Seon Ho gained consciousness earlier, the writer could have effectively handled this and could have made it a better story. Aside from that, there were a few questions they never answered, like Seon Ho’s password. I also noticed how the police felt a tad unprofessional with the way they treated the case earlier on.
Joon Seok was one of the most complex characters in the whole show, and I applaud the actor for bringing him to life; I went from hating him to feeling sorry for him till finally wanting a better life for him. The child actors did a brilliant job at their roles, and so did the adults.
The OSTs were soft and very pleasant to the ears, despite the tears they resulted in. I think they will go to my playlist. One of them, however, was a hip-hop sound and would have felt out of place had they used it as BGM, which they thankfully did not. Overall, a sensible choice of background score.
I don’t think this will be one in my rewatch list, mostly because it is a melo and I get impatient easily. However, a few moments tugged at my heartstrings and had great power in their subtlety so I might return to them.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Keeping this the main theme, which I suppose the writer got inspired from the book Catcher in the Rye by J. D. Salinger, the dramatization took place with some usual dramatic formula. Although it ended with a little unexpected twist but still it maintained to retain its main essence till the end. As the very name of this drama, the makers also ended it in a positive note rather than making it into a heart wrenching one, signaled from the first episode. The story dynamics and the pace of progress per episode was interesting all through.
Also liked the little optimistic message it delivered in the end – to always keep our hopes up and only move forward in order to make everything beautiful around us.
Bullying is a sensitive topic and is a wide social problem in South Korea. No wonder they always try to highlight this issue through visual media to indirectly create awareness. The mood of this drama and story writing is commendable by Kim Ji Woo. She has a certain style of writing which I really love. It exudes somewhat similar feel like the drama Memory and later found out she is the screenwriter of both of them. I just did not like the camera work - the peeping style camera angle or the extreme close shot of every face - which actually gave me a headache. Directions, OSTs, acting by the ensembles all were praiseworthy. All the child actors were excellent, mainly Nam Da Reum and Seo Dong Hyun. Seo Dong Hyun was remarkable in playing the negative role. Unimaginable, how he could manage to pull the skill so maturely at such a young age. He was phenomenal in portraying the evil expressions. Nam Da Reum is always exceptional. They both have the brightest future ahead. The actors in their parents’ role all gave their best performance.
All in all it’s a well - written, directed and acted- drama no one should miss.
Cet avis était-il utile?
100% Recommend
This drama is hands down one of my all time favorites. Everything about it is so good. The acting, the storyline, the OSTs, etc. I recommend this drama to anyone that is looking for something new to watch. I’m a sucker for dramas that can make me bawl my eyes out and this is one of them. If I had a list of top dramas, this one would fall in seconds place; right after Just Between Lovers.Of course everyone may not have the same option as me but I wholeheartedly believe that this is one of the best kdramas out there.
Cet avis était-il utile?
The series overall was dark, packed with emotions and followed a thrilling mystery. The pace, actually, of the story was managed pretty well and that helped the story a lot. The characters and the performances by all actors and actresses were brilliant and added a lot to the whole drama.
One thing that I, however, didn't really like about this drama were the final episodes. The cases were almost solved and the drama didn't really have much to offer. Therefor those episodes lacked intensity.
So, eight out of ten.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
This is the first drama Nam Da Reum was place as main role and I was so excited and everything but his acting was so limited in here. I wish they had him wake up earlier than he did because it ended up rushing the last episode. Nam Da Reum Is my favorite child actor I watched almost all the dramas he’s been in and his acting in one point everywhere. I just wish he has woken up earlier than the had him wake up :( but in my opinion this drama is a 10/10 to me so many emotions, I cried every episode and the acting was one point for everyone ❤️Rewatch value: The reason why I rated it so low is because it too emotional to watch the whole drama again, but I will go back to some scene to rewatch. This is the first time I won’t be able to rewatch a whole drama that I really liked :( can’t really afford to cry so much again.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
A not so beautiful world....
What are my thoughts about this drama... hmm.... honestly I am conflicted with myself as the story was pretty good, most of the acting was on spot and the drama did keep me on my toes wanting to see what would happen next. At times making it a clear candidate for a 9, 9,5 but at some point the twists became just a little bit too predictable. The mother a.k. main leads acting and dialog became cringe and annoying, and they kept giving the suspects a heads up so they could collude and destroy evidence to the point of just too much...The main family here is just a little bit to good, you know the type to be to kind, to perfect, to loving.. Though they do try to seem human they still end up a bit too much... However the friendship and the found family bits here are really good,. Again making me conflicted within myself since on the one hand I loved to see them develop and care for each other almost forgetting that even these so called overly perfect loving humans actually slapped kids out of frustration...
People do not slap kids, especially if you are teachers!
There are some good lines here and there, as well as thought provoking scenes, where they actually put the responsabilaty for the kids actions where it belongs! Not bad! There is also quite a bit of absurd humour done right but most of all a lot evil corruption etc done well.. yes I am a sucker for evil , I really am.. However once people start to repent here and there the plot loses its foremost charm as the good vs evil is kind of meeh... While the pure evil here is just gold!
The villain played by Oh Man Suk is so perfect! With flawless acting from his part leaving me 0 room to feel for him as he was truly as evil as evil gets. Making me appreciate him even more and though I can not put him on my crush list I feel I need to give him some love and maybe make a great villain actors list where he would be on top, yes that is how good he is at being evil.
The kids acting here was also really good and each role was well balanced, well written and entertaining to watch!
Bingabilaty: High
Annoying characters: the female lead
A decent drama, but could have been bette and not without tis problems...
Cet avis était-il utile?
This isn't a romance or a thriller or a comedy. It is a drama about family and corruption and crime. The characters are incredible every single one of them has an important role to play from the main family to the driver of the rich no one is a spare part. The way it is filmed also adds to it, the house that is designed to feel like a prison is the best.
This drama will make you cry and smile and seek justice throughout, the ending without spoiling is very well done, I bumped up the rating because of its incredible ending. It is a heavy drama that deals with many issues including suicide, bullying, sexual assault and more so do be wary.
I have to say my favourite character is the daughter she is so strong and mature her personality and the way she deals with things is incredible.
Please give this a try it deserves so much love for such a well made drama, everything is so well done.
Cet avis était-il utile?
One of the best of this year and I'm not exagerate.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Beautiful gem of a drama
This drama wasn't even on my radar to watch. But browsing through netflix, it popped out and I browsed through the reviews on mydramalist. It helped that it was rated an 8+.While bullying isn't something new in Kdramas, this drama actually went beyond the bullying issue. At first, you would think that this was where the story would revolve. But then, the last few episodes start to hint at something more.
I would recommend this drama if you want something more than rom coms and love stories. It is a family drama with depth. The characters are well-portrayed that you feel as if they truly are family.
As I do not wish to give out any spoilers or give anything away, I just want to say that I truly enjoyed and loved this drama. It may not have gained as much buzz as others but it is a worthy watch.
Cet avis était-il utile?
I think the drama did well with the topic of bullying and how distressing it can be for the victim and their loved ones. On the negative side, this did not have to be 16 episodes long with a one-hour format. In the middle the story started to circle and got a bit tiring. The use of the main theme sound was too repetitive, I would have preferred an instrumental one.
This doesn't have a good rewatch value. For a 2nd time, you'll have to skip around to enjoy the gripping bits of the story again.
Cet avis était-il utile?