Story: 10/10 because what can I say? This is my first j-drama after all. My first gender bender story-I think so. The plot was well-written in my personal opinion.
Acting: 10/10 because it was very comedic & I thought they got into their roles well. I've read the manga, & I like this version very much so. I couldn't choose between Sano & Nakatsu to be with Mizuki.
Music: 7/10 some of the BGMs are memorable to be like "be silent", and some were catchy theme songs, but not as memorable.
Rewatch value: 10/10 this was an amazing story. I would rewatch this drama over & over when I have time. I've watched this 3-4 times already.
If you like gender-bender stories, frienship, romantic-comedies, or plain old comedy, then you'll like this drama for sure.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
The story isn't original, but the way it's executed is what hooks you. This drama is definitely more of a comedy than anything else, and I was grinning throughout most of it. They focused even less of the sports than in TTBY, but the dorm competitions were absolutely entertaining and I was glad to see them prevalent.
The romance was cute, though I hoped the side romance with Nakatsu would have been more prominent than it was. There was less head banging and "oh my god Jae Hee" than in TTBY, however.
The actors I enjoyed watching, and all of the relationships seemed very real and believable. I definitely was crying at the end. A lot.
Personally, I liked this Mizuki much more than TTBY's Mizuki--Goo Jae Hee--perhaps because she seemed more convincing as a boy. Nakatsu's Korean counterpart, Cha Eun Gyeol, seemed more involved than Nakatsu.
All of the characters were great nevertheless. Kind of disappointed that Gilbert wasn't involved though.
This one had a faster pace though, probably because the episodes are shorter, and there are only twelve. It did pretty well with keeping consistent though.
The music I liked--especially the opening. Wasn't a big factor though.
I would definitely rewatch it, probably because of how lighthearted it is. It's more comedic than TTBY, which definitely would make it more fun to rewatch.
I loved it, honestly. Both versions I've seen were great, but this one wins, perhaps because of the humor. Definitely would say this is a must watch.
Now off to the Taiwanese version, and the remake. ;)
Cet avis était-il utile?
i love the manga too its more romantic
the drama isn't as romantic as the manga and the manga isn't as funny as the drama
i love them anyway i love the actors and everything! i fell in love with oscar himejima lol!! i love all the silliness. i always re watch it because i love it very much! I wish there were a second season because in the manga it has more so that would be cool. the new version is awesome but nobody can replace nakatsu he was the best
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
It has mostly light moments and some of them really make you laugh. While I am not happy with the romance in this, it still gives some very unforgettable scenes between Nakatsu and Ashiya. While gender bender scenario was funny here too, in spite of that almost all the characters fell flat. Sano had no character development at all except for one point which was that he started doing what he used to before. Other than getting inspired and jumping, he really provided with no entertainment at all. I wasn't that big a fan of Ashiya, but her strong determination wins her points. My favorite character was of course- Nakatsu. He is colorful, loving and funny at the same time. He is probably going to remain one of my favorites from jdramas forever. Almost all memorable scenes I recall from this show have Nakatsu in them. His unconditional love for Ashiya till the end really moved me because it was so sweet. He was always there for her no matter what.
However, if you would want to watch this show- only watch it for the comedy. The romance was disappointing. Maybe if I had liked Sano I would have loved his relationship with Ashiya too but as I said- I like Nakatsu all the way. And I don't know what to rate the soundtrack because I cannot recall any tunes from the show.
Anyway, the rewatch value is still intact because of my favorite Nakatsu and Ashiya moments.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
"I'd still love her even if she was a guy"- Nakatsu
This drama was not that much of a reality but I love how they portrayed friendship and harmony in hereThe school is so beautiful and love that nostalgic feeling. The dorms and the landscape was so beautiful. The rain which was there at the scene ML's father got into the taxi after being discharged from the hospital was beautiful. The different personalities among the students are wonderful.
Like the way the school principal does events to make students compete as a team. The last episode broke my heart when all the students bid farewell to the FL. The doc is quite a funny, weird guy and the hole show was hilarious
I loved Nakatsu's character (2ML) and always wanted him to be paired up with Mizuki (FL)
He was very gentle with her and was there beside her when she needs moral support. In my opinion, Nakatsu stole the show with his energetic personality and the way he tries to hide his feelings after being dumped by FL made me really sad
A beautiful J drama I watched recently even though it's 2007, I enjoyed every bit of this
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
Now,if I enjoyed this drama as much I claim, why did I end up rating it a rather mediocre 7 you may ask? It's simple. Oguri Shun. As the main male character, I felt his acting was extremely weak. In fact, at no point in the whole drama did I actually feel he was conveying any semblance of a personality whatsoever. He seemed bored and uninterested in being there the whole time. Some may argue that is just the character of Sano, but I disagree. It never changes, even after the point where Sano is supposed to start feeling and expressing more interest. There is also no chemistry between he and the lead actress at all, either romantically or friendly. There's just no chemistry on screen at all when he is in the scene, no matter what kind of scene it is, period.
Would I recommend this drama this drama to others? Yes, but with the strong warning about how terrible Oguri Shun's acting is. Everything else is actually really good, but one will have to be willing to overlook the lead male's shortcomings I think.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?