To The Beautiful You (2012)

I didn't watched the other versions and I didn't read the manga.

English isn't my first language.

-

I was thinking I'm gonna like because I am a Shawol, Minho is my bias and I love Sulli, but...



Story: Wasn't original, but that's not the point.

Jae Hee reasons to move to South Korea are vague, flat and childish. "He made me believe", "I wanna see him jump again", "He gave me force". Just no.

The side stories are kinda off, the interesting ones received a bad development and a rushed solution.


Acting/Cast: I was expecting more from Minho. In my opinion, he wasn't able to transit in the character. Wasn't a good transition between angry, sad or happy Tae Joon. Was just too abrupt.

Sulli was avarage, I don't know...

Gyeol's actor was amazing, outstanding, I love him.

There is no chemistry between the main couple. I feel bad for it.



Music: I love SM music, but was just too much for me this time.

Lire davantage

I felt like I had go give a review after watching the pilot, I was looking forward to the show because I am a die hard fan of the 2006 Jdrama of Hana Kimi. But after sitting down and watching the first episode...I don't think I've been so disappointed in a Korean drama in my whole life. It was just ridiculous, people made such a big deal over the actors, and I don't even know why. I didn't think their acting was any special, in fact, I wanted to give them a couple (dozen) pointers. The background music was ridiculous and over the top, there were parts in the episode that I found completely unnecessary. I was completely turned off, and I don't believe that it's worth it to watch more.

Lire davantage

I've seen the Japanese Drama version (Hana Kimi) and I can say that I liked this one better. Though Sulli is a bit too feminine to pass as a man to me, I think that the rest of the casting was perfect.

The flop between tough and soft was sort of lost because Minho seems soft but he held the part well for the most part.

I preferred this version better to the Japanese version because the pacing was easier to follow and there were a lot less subplots going on. With the main plot and maybe one or two others, it was easy to follow and tied in together nicely. In the Japanese version each episode was like watching a different spin-off of the original series.

Both are very good though, I just preferred this one.

Lire davantage

i watched this show wayy back and it was like the only "sports" kdrama i watched but ... it was interesting i mean it did stress me out at some point. the female lead disguises as a guy to go to an all boys university to convince her idol (who is a professional athlete and is planning on quitting long jumping) to continue his passion or whatever. its kinda crazy cuz when she gets there shes super clingy and she wears this chest compressor and basically causes problems like she passes out and stuff and the entire time ur gonna think shes gonna get caught LMFAOOO its literally like mulan. but 10x worse because the male leads best friend starts thinking hes gay and literally tells the female lead (who he thinks is a guy) that he likes her ...... and then he finds out shes a girl and hes like wtf i was questioning my sexuality for reason i rlly am just straight !!!! it was an okay tv show but i think the 2nd female interest is like a professional ballerina and she was lowkey annoying cuz she thought the female lead (who is supposed to be acting as a guy) was way too close to the male lead like girl .... can u just gtfo !!!! she was one of those obsessed freaks or whatever but anyway it was an okay show the ending wasnt memorable but im pretty sure she gets kicked out of the school and she gets with the male lead or its implied idfk lowkey enjoyable just stressful

Lire davantage

I just finished watching this drama. At first, I wasn't sure if I was going to like it since the first few episodes didn't really seem to hook me in. However, I kept watching and it did pick up, especially in the later episodes. The only complaint I have with it is that the storyline isn't original at all. I know it was based on a Japanese show, which itself was based on a manga, but I haven't seen or read those versions. To me, there was A LOT of recycled plot points from You're Beautiful. In fact, I noticed quite a few lines you could compare word for word with YB. I am not sure if You're Beautiful was based on the original version of this or not, but I haven't heard of anything like that. I know the plots are extremely similar anyway, but still feel this one could have come across as more original had it not copied so much from You're Beautiful.

All in all, though, it wasn't bad. It was cute and funny, but I just can't help but compare it to You're Beautiful, and in so doing, it just ends up as lacking.

Lire davantage

The biggest problem with To The Beautiful You is that it is less funny than the other versions.
It is impossible not to compare the different versions (I read the manga and seen both Japanese and Taiwan Drama)

There's no character completely crazy like Oscar (who became Charles obscure reason).There's no figure of Kayashima TT_TT
Looks like the Korean Nakao (sorry I do not even remember the name of Korean characters) are not in love with the Namba Korean but of Korean Nakatsu. This is nonsense!
And I hope that the Korean Umeda (the nurse) is gay. (as he has not yet said when he could already do, it worries me a little)
And there are too many girls in the school (see the end of episode 2)

But there are also good things :
Sulli is so cute!
I want to dorm! (rooms are the size of a room!)

I liked it anyway but you really have to think they did the Korean Hana Kimi. So the most important it will be the story of love and family stories while in the Japanese version that is most important is friendship. Which is quite a shame.

Despite all that, I look forward to see the next episodes. This drama puts me in all my states XD
I like but I'm frustrated ^^

Lire davantage