Very Interesting!!
Might watch it a 1000 times without getting tired. The plot is very interesting. But Satan's scene could have been a little more twisted ....to blow our minds. the ending was great and I love it. Park Shin Hye ate and left no crumbs in this drama. Couldn't get enough of it tho ....wished there were more episodes to binge on...And the chemistry between the FL and ML was really amazing. And love the fact that it was not focused solely on the love aspect of the story.Worth watching. 100 percent
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
An Unexpected Favorite: Park Shin-hye’s Fierce Transformation
Just when I thought the last half of 2024 dramas would let me down, Judge From Hell enters the chat!Usually, dramas like this start strong but tend to drag toward the end. Surprisingly, though, this one just keeps getting better with each episode! The suspense builds, the stakes get higher, and it keeps you hooked right until the very end.
Never did I think a role played by Park Shin-hye would make it to my list of favorite female characters, but Kang Bitna has proven me wrong! She’s everything we need in a strong, compelling lead—resilient, intelligent, and fiercely driven. Park Shin-hye brings such depth to Bitna’s character, This role has truly redefined what I expect from female leads, and I’m here for every moment of it
About Kim Jae Young, I wasn’t familiar with his game.he’s got undeniable charm! He looks incredibly attractive, and that rugged hairstyle suits him so much better than the polished CEO look I’d seen him in before. Plus, he nailed his character—it’s a role that truly lets his talent shine.
The actors playing the side characters in Judge from Hell showcase stellar performances that elevate the entire show. Each actor brilliantly embodies their character’s quirks and eccentricities.
The cases in this drama are genuinely intriguing, each one leaving you hooked and eager for the next. And the background music? It just amps up the cool factor, adding intensity to every scene. Altogether, it makes for an unforgettable watch.
I think Judge from Hell is perfect as a one-season drama. The ending was both happy and open, but I felt it didn’t need another season because it showed that she loved being a judge more than being with him. So the ending was just right.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Hellfire & Heart: A Judge's Tale!!!⚖️
The Perfect Leading DuoLet me gush about Park Shin Hye as Kang Bit Na because OH. MY. GOSH! She absolutely demolished this role! The way she transformed into this fierce, uncompromising judge who earned the name "Judge from Hell" – it's unlike anything I've seen from her before. Gone is the sweet, gentle image from her previous roles; instead, we get this absolute badass who commands the courtroom with an iron fist while carrying deep emotional wounds.
And can we talk about Kim Jae Young as Detective Han Da On? His portrayal of this brilliant detective is everything! The way he brings both sharp investigative skills and this adorable warmth to the character is just chef's kiss . What makes his character so special is how he approaches cases with both intelligence and heart – he's not just solving crimes, he's seeking justice in his own way, which creates this fascinating dynamic with Bit Na
Kim Jae Young deserves all the praise for making Han Da On so much more than just a love interest. His character brings this beautiful balance to the show – when things get dark (and boy, do they get dark!), his optimism and unwavering belief in justice shines through like a beacon. Plus, his puppy-like devotion to Bit Na? ADORABLE!
Chemistry That Lights Up The Screen
The dynamic between Park Shin Hye and Kim Jae Young is ELECTRIC! Every scene they share has this incredible tension – whether they're butting heads over how to handle a case or slowly developing understanding for each other's methods. Da On's more empathetic approach to justice gradually influencing Bit Na's rigid stance makes for some incredibly compelling character development.
Kang Bitna interact with our warm-hearted detective? Those moments where his genuine care for justice and people starts to crack her icy exterior? PURE GOLD!
The Supporting Cast That Brought Their A-Game
What Makes It Special
The show's strength lies in its perfect balance of:
*Character development that feels earned and authentic
*Heart-fluttering moments between Bit Na and Da On that provide perfect emotional breaks
*Complex cases that challenge both the characters and viewers morally
*Outstanding performances that make every scene compelling
*Park Shin Hye shows us a completely new side as the stern, uncompromising Judge Kang Bit Na
*Kim Jae Young perfectly embodies Detective Han Da On's mix of sharp intelligence and warm humanity
*Even minor characters leave lasting impressions with their powerful performances
Final Verdict
This show is an absolute MUST-WATCH! Park Shin Hye and Kim Jae Young's amazing performances, creates something truly special.
Rating: 9/10 gavels!
Cet avis était-il utile?
When Demons Judge
What would a demon judge be like? Picture a mischievous whirlwind—wicked, cheeky, and delightfully chaotic—spreading confusion while serving up hellish punishments to those who truly deserve it. Enter Justitia/ Kang Bit Na, played brilliantly by Park Shin Hye, who nails this wild spirit!What really sets this drama apart is its bold and entertaining take on demon characters and their antics. Each emotional storyline packs a punch, diving into their darker, more violent sides without any apologies. Yet, it maintains a perfect balance with a light-heartedness that keeps things fun and engaging. Even as Justitia navigates human emotions and falls for the male lead, Han Da On, she never loses that badass edge.
I've struggled to connect with Park Shin Hye in her previous roles, but her portrayal as Justitia/ Kang Bit Na is truly impressive. It's refreshing to see her break free from typecasting! She’s a powerhouse of strength wrapped in vulnerability, sprinkled with love, and her performance genuinely stands out. I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed her emotional scenes!
The strong supporting cast, featuring Kim In Kwon, Yang Kyung Won, Kim Jae Hwa (alongside her real-life sisters) and many more, adds even more depth to the story. My only complaint? Lee Kyu Han's acting. His character, Jung Tae Gyu, comes off a bit one-dimensional, almost as if there's glue stuck on his face. He doesn't quite capture the insane, evil, or unhinged vibe that his character is supposed to embody.
Overall, this drama is a wild ride with plenty of twists and engaging moments!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Favourite of 2024!
The Judge From Hell not only lived up to my expectations but clearly surpassed it. I absolutely loved Park ShinHye as Kang Bitna. Even when they show her personality transformation, it is actually believable. Contrast that to the human Kang Bitna who died in episode 1 and how differently she was portrayed. You can see a real difference between the two personalities. That was just one of the beauties of this show.The other aspect I loved is the punishments dealt by Bitna. The concept was simple yet ingenious. The CGI are beautiful. And if you love strong female characters as much as I do, you will especially love this one. It would have been so easy to mess this up because of some of the twists in the series and especially with the ending. But the series maintained it's strength and doubled down on it's portrayal of Kang Bitna as the judge from hell. Strength doesn't always have to mean physical. It can also come from within and that's what we get in those moments.
Han DaOn was also a nice character. A bit too nice and emotional to be a cop yet you want to root for him even when he is opposed to Bitna. He certainly doesn't take the attention away from her. Bitna is the shining star and the show never loses its focus! Credit to the writers and directors on that.
There are quite a few secondary characters that are enjoyable and the true villain was not easy to guess as there were many inaccurate theories by fans. That also made it more enjoyable guessing what the true nature of people was.
The only other supernatural justice plot I can think of is the Thai drama Girl From Nowhere which is more gruesome and serious. In contrast, The Judge From Hell keeps a balance between the seriousness of the cases and the punishments being entertaining due to the way they are recreated. Besides that TJFH has lighter moments and comedy that makes it a fun watch versus GFN is heavy. I loved both shows and there are aspects that are comparable so I would definitely recommend both.
The OST Boomerang, Crossroad and Gehenna are worth listening to.
Cet avis était-il utile?
SunshineOnaWinterMorning
19 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Slightly overrated if you ask me
So there are many reviews gushing about this drama. I feel a little meh about it.The drama delivers what the summary/introduction promises. Just that its almost only that much nothing more. plot-wise.
The world building in this drama was really lacking and left my head scratching.
It seemed really christian cosmos inspired, and what bothered me that they seemed to be using legit demon/-ve christian cosmos characters (idk really cause im not christian). I feal that they couldve made the names up for the 'aesthetic' that they clearly wanted instead of using actual ones- cause names carry power. And on the other hand they used only one +ve one.
Putting that point aside, many major plot points where left unanswered.
The show really showcases vigilante justice - tit for tat instead of reform. Large parts of screentime is given to FL just beating up various villains. The gore and blood are supposed to probably elicit a feel good response from the viewer. That made me a uncomfortable- especially since the pain of the survivors ('victims') isnt really the concern- their closure isnt really the concern, but just 'u did wrong so u'll pay for it' is. There arent many emotions involved. Its all very cold. And in this regard- there is a story arc, a character arc. We witness her becoming a feeling demon judge from a cold unfeeling judge from hell. She acknowledges that just beating criminals up and punishing them in the shadows of the night isnt enough to provide justice - closure to grieving families.
The romance in the show gets very little screentime, and is more present just to be a driving force behind her character arc. Her forbidden 'human feelings' for the ML become the reason she starts feeling empathy for aggrieving families and the people around her. All other side characters (including ML) are just present and doing their thing. There isnt much focus on them at all.
You should watch this show if-
1. You like vigilante justice, are ok with skipping forward or watching scenes of criminals just being beaten up, tortured and killed for their crimes.
2. Like wacky FL
3. ML is very smart and persistent. He is so secure that hes fine with dating a demon who's actions are quite often in direct conflict with his job. He's very clear with himself about his ethics system and boundaries.
4. Want to watch a mock- mystery thriller. the only thrilling part was the score. No need to apply brains. Infact it is better if u dont apply brains, otherwise u will notice too many plotholes.
5. The 'action' genre mention refers to the torture scenes ig.
6. Openish HE
Special mention to FL's character- why i watched the show-
I was obviously very unimpressed by the show. It also got really boring past few episodes. But what kept me from dropping it was Kang Bitna's sass. It was very fun and almost inspirational (minus the vigilante justice part). Especially the way PSH smiles/smirks with the score playing in the background, or her boredom and straightforward mannerisms of dealing with everyday boring situations was very endearing and refreshing. Kang Bitna is a 'psycho' , is a little socially challenged, but she is smart, not dull. There is also some comedic effect in the show with its various side characters, mostly in the scenes outside the courtroom and torture.
Special mention regarding 'vigilante justice'-
TBH what's shown in the show isnt really what comes to my mind when i think of vigilante justice - like robin hood. They mostly try to pass on torture as VJ. Criminals who are unrepentant, dont have ability to feel empathy or even comprehend why what they did was wrong, just torturing and morbidly killing them isnt going do anything. I wasnt going to type this out since this is just a show, but unfortunately this is the axial of the show which is baffling. Major screentime is given to these scenes. There remain lot of actual real world questions regarding this particular form of VJ, but be warned that it takes center stage in this show.
Cet avis était-il utile?
The best realistic fantasy kdrama of all time
OMG, i have finay finish this drama after watching everytime of it release.Firstly, this drama is by far my favourite drama of 2024 as even the anticipation of this drama before its release was already spectacular.
The main leads our queen Park Shinye was born for this role, she shut all haters up for her exceptional role in this drama, no one is like the queen, I fear and then our handsome cute sexy Kim Jae Young, god Damn he is so perfect, honestly i have seen him in a few dramas but this drama made me love him more, the character of Han Deon was perfectly executed by him, He is just the man he thinks he is ❤❤
Othet supoorting actors and actresses like Kim In Kwon, Kim Ah Young who played character Koo Man Do and Lee A Rong/ Gremory both had their dynamic humourous sided and made the show fun too.
Kudos to other supoorting characterd too.
Everyone did so well and by far amazingly well.
To conclude, if you are looking for action, thriller, romance, mystery, fantasy,law, all of these eleme elements you will therefore enjoy this amazing drama.
Thanks for taking your amazing time to read my view and hope you have a nice day.
Peace
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Vengeance, Demons, and Humanity’s Darkness
A satisfying open-ended conclusion; I think this is Park Shin Hye’s best K-drama. This kind of role suits her much better than something like Doctor Slump. Excellent production overall, with a solid script, impressive special effects—congratulations to SBS for this great drama!The scenes of revenge and Kang Bit Na’s execution were really gratifying. The actors playing the villains nailed their roles as despicable characters. The entire cast was strong; there wasn’t a weak performance, even in the smaller roles, like the journalist or all the victims appearing throughout the drama.
Someone pointed this out, and I completely agree—it really shows that humans can be far more cruel and malevolent than the demons, who just want to feel love, sadness, and all the range of human emotions.
The atmosphere shifts dramatically after Kim So Yeong’s death and the hunt for both J and Satan. Kim Jae Young also played his role as Han Da On incredibly well. You can really sense a shift in his character when he’s ready to kill J and collaborate with Bit Na.
A solid 9/10—a perfect K-drama for Halloween!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
It’s not a masterpiece
The production felt underwhelming despite SBS’s efforts, with a script that struggled to stay engaging and special effects that fell short of impressive.The revenge scenes and Kang Bit Na’s so-called “execution” lacked real impact and felt hollow. While the villains tried to appear despicable, they came off as one-dimensional, and the actors’ performances didn’t bring much depth. Even the smaller roles, like the journalist and the victims, were forgettable and didn’t add much to the story.
One aspect some viewers might appreciate—though I found it overly simplified—is the message that humans can be more cruel than demons. However, this concept felt forced and didn’t resonate emotionally. The dramatic shift in atmosphere after Kim So Yeong’s death and the hunt for J and Satan seemed disconnected and didn’t add much suspense. Kim Jae Young’s portrayal of Han Da On was unconvincing, and the supposed transformation in his character lacked any real intensity or depth.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
A demon can never be So Lovable and Bloodshed was never this satisfying!
"The Judge from Hell" is probably the best K Drama of 2024.Park shin Hye as Kang Bit Na AKA Justitia just Stole the show, the entire credit for the hit goes to her alone. Woah! what a bad ass acting she did. I have never seen a FL who is this much Cool in K drama. She ate it. From being a Bad ass demon to a lover girl she gave it all from Ep 1 - ep 12 never missed to amuse me with her acting. This drama is just made for her. The rest of the actors though can never be even with PSH, they did a great job on their part, even a little support role was played to the point.
Mando, Gremory Duo was hilarious at times. I loved their duo
The fight scenes was mind blowing and it's really beyond words which was mad more beautiful by wonderful cinematography. The humour was on point, and was needed where it was in need. The overall story kept me engaged all the time, not even a second I was bored of this plot. Each and every story that comes in this drama is too unique and just perfectly directed. Hats off to the team of " The Judge From Hell". They really deserve all the awards.
"You are the only Blemish on my life, My only weakness. I Loved you a Lot Han Da On". when Bit Na said this to Han Da On while saying her final goodbye, tears kept rolling from my eyes non-stop and I repeated that scene so many times and watched it again and again. That was the best romantic part of this drama. ahh! those kisses at the end. Kisses was never this romantic. That one long Kiss plus OST by Sunmi just caught me off guard and that particular scene was so soothing and heavenly. The way FL pampered ML saying he is Cute all the time was really cute, "An eye Treat" for me.
Forgot to mention the costumes, every costumes stood out separately and was designed so well that it fits every actors and theme.
Changing into so many roles PSH never came out of any character. "Apologizing is an obligation But forgiveness is not" as she kills the final Killer this drama's Killing streak ends and now I really miss this series.
No one should miss this series. It's absolutely 10 on 10 for me. This drama just ended at a right time without dragging. The best
I really thank the team for giving out this masterpiece.....
Cet avis était-il utile?
calmdownhaeyojaebal
5 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Literally COULD NOT STOP watching this!!
Very few dramas have the ability to make a viewer check the calendar repeatedly to see how long before a new episode drops - this was one of mine.An absolute roller-coaster ride from start to end. This drama had all the necessary things to make it so hard to stop watching. I know there are a lot of comments out there that might be saying the CGI is bad, or the fantasy element is too much to digest, or that the ML is running too much of an interference, etc. Honestly, to each their own. Not every drama out there is for every viewer. But if you enjoy any of the following genres - action, crime, revenge, fantasy, thriller - then you NEED to watch this atleast once. Personally, it's one of the better written and executed K-dramas that offers a diverse viewing experience.
Going to highlight points separately, to make it easier to go through:
*Park Shin-Hye aka Justitia/Kang Bitna*
For someone who couldn't bear to watch Park Shin-hye EVER (trust me, I really tried), picking up this drama in the first place was already a task. The storyline + teasers always had me intrigued and since I wasn't expecting much of a romance anyway, I decided to power through and start the show. THANK THE GOOD LORD, because if not for that I would've missed out on a seriously iconic character. Justitia/Kang Bitna was such a treat to watch - she has a very ambiguous moral compass, she screams personality, she's also a sassy-as-hell demon judge from, well, Hell, and she retains that personality during her time on Earth. Her character arc was extremely well executed, and felt very natural. Despite changes in her environment, emotions, etc. the one thing that stayed constant was her hardcore and badass nature. Also, plus points for PSH doing action, she's one of the best actresses in this genre. I would love to see her do more roles in this zone, basically where she isn't stuck in the same old rut of "poor girl, sad life, cry". I feel like she has so much more potential and this show truly proved it.
*Kim Jae-Young aka Han DaOn*
Umm well, first of all - I need to seriously go touch some grass after the amount of giggling and blushing this man has made me do. The number of times I have rewatched his profile scenes is unhealthy, to say the least (I'm just a girl, cut me some slack). LOVE LOVE LOVE this man and his acting. His character might seem frustrating at first because of his constant need to "do the right thing" and "follow the rules" and "obey the laws" blah blah blah. ANNOYING i know - but you need to understand that there's a whole backstory there. You cannot discredit the circumstances or the events that brought him to that point and made him who he is. Unlearning takes time; unlearning and then adapting to a new outlook takes even longer. I do think some grace period is deserved. I also feel that quite a few viewers these days don't seem to appreciate complex characters because they don't change quickly. Be realistic, who does?
*THE CHEMISTRY!!!!*
The chemistry between Han DaOn and Kang Bitna was finger-licking good. ngl I'm a big fan of slow burn, banter/bickering and angst - so this was literally perfect for me. They gave me crumbs and had me begging for more at the end of literally every episode and that made it so much more exciting to watch. The fact that romance was not centre-stage, but still such an integral driving force for the plot was what made it an interesting watch.
*The Story*
My absolute FAVOURITE part of every case was the final verdict - Justitia's final verdict not Kang Bitna's. In order to not spoil anything major, all I'll say is that I felt gratified and vindicated (and a little sadistic, since I lacked empathy for them) at the end of every case. The fantasy element of the story was quite interesting and the way everything was tied together seemed satisfactory. The ending, I will say, was a tad bit disappointing since I was expecting it to end on a high - which is why it was not a 10/10 rating. But the fact that this show had me on the edge - watching every single episode as soon as it came out - was enough for me to give it a high rating.
Hope you decide to give this one a watch! And if you do, let me know what you think :)
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
THE WRITER NEEDS AWARDS!!
This drama totally nails it, thanks to a amazing script and brilliant directing. It’s almost unreal that it’s the writer’s first script! The plot was set from the beginning, no weekly changes based on audience reactions, and you can tell—it’s packed with tiny details that make you go “wow.” The team deserves all the awards, and it’s a shame people are missing out just because it’s not a typical rom-com.Park Shin Hye as Justitia was amazing! She’s fierce, stylish, and brings out this refreshing personality with incredible action scenes. Kim Jaeyoung also shines as Han Daon, finally getting a lead role that feels perfect for him. Their chemistry was really good. Initially you wonder how they will tease each other and then you just start waiting for their cute moments. The “enemies to lovers” trope hits hard—she even kills him in their third meeting!
SBS has to give them Daesangs!!
Story Breakdown (Some spoilers):
- Fantasy:7/10
- Crime:8/10
- Romance:5/10
- Subtle Romance:10/10
The romance is more about cute, awkward moments rather than intense scenes, which actually makes it more touching. They’re both total beginners at love, so hugs even catch them off guard. In the final episode, there’s a well-done time skip that makes their relationship growth feel natural instead of forced.
Justitia is focused on her dark mission, acting as a judge who secretly puts criminals on her own “death trial” to send them to hell. But here’s the twist—her decisions don’t always bring justice to the victims’ families, which adds a lot of depth to her character. By the end, she’s starting to question her ruthless approach.
Han Daon, meanwhile, is the detective working on Justitia’s cases, frustrated as she releases the very criminals he’s spent ages catching. He discovers the truth about her pretty early on, and just when it feels like he might expose her, he starts to adopt her harsh methods, while Justitia becomes more compassionate. Their role reversal is a brilliant twist.
Execution:
- Each episode kept fans guessing with theories, but the show constantly surprised us. The trailers even threw us off!
- There was one plot hole: what happened to Bitna’s soul? Since she was wrongly sent to hell, it would’ve been nice to see that resolved. But it’s left open for interpretation.
In conclusion, don’t skip this just because it’s not a rom-com! The story’s engaging, with great humor and fantastic chemistry between the leads. You’ll want to rewatch this one for sure!
Cet avis était-il utile?