Melusinefandedrama
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Série très bien faite !
8 épisodes haletants, à couper le souffle !Cette série dévoile au fur et à mesure l'histoire des participants, pourquoi ils font cela etc.
Ce n'est pas une série pour homme-soja ou bisounours, il y des scènes assez gore mais cela reste quand même très supportable
J'ai adoré :
les acteurs : tous excellents et convaincants
les scènes de combat : très réalistes et bien filmées
Le scénario : très bien construit
Le rythme : parfait
La musique : adaptée à chaque moment
Je n'ai pas aimé :
euh non rien !
IL FAUT UNE 2e SAISON !!!!!! Je ne donne pas de spoilers, mais une deuxième saison s'impose !
Cet avis était-il utile?
An ELECTRICFYING THRILLER WITH STUNNING STYLISH ACTION ! SOLID and GRIPPING ! Need Season 2
Guns Gadgets Gangs Bombs Foes Alliance !!" A Shop for Killers" is a stylish new wave action kdrama about the survival of his nephew "Jian," who was targeted by suspicious killers after her uncle's death " Jin Man " .
This was a really excellent action thriller with amazing fight choreography, suspense, and action sequences. Each episode that is DARK, violent, psychotic, and wants to kill everyone, survival. The cast gives outstanding performances, and the plot is gripping and interesting overall. Each actor gives excellent performances as their respective characters.
LET'S SEE WHAT MADE THIS DRAMA IS AN UNIQUE ACTION DRAMA STANDOUT MODERN CLASSIC ACTION THRILLER --- 9.5/10
Modern style explosive action sequences :-
Unlike other classic K Action dramas using feasts in high-voltage action, I'm sure this drama standout as a modern classic action drama with complete new Action sequence adaptation like Modern age guns, Drones, Robots, and other modern fire arms. Kdramas are well known for best filming locations that we explore new places in S Korea through the kdramas freely, but in this drama the most important point out aspect is " Singular location story telling " this makes A Shop for Killers as an unique action thriller in classic K Actions.
Director completely adopted modern machine attacking style ( drone bombs, automatic machine guns carried by drones and ' DRONE GUN TACTICAL ' realistically advanced and exaggerated cinematic scene featuring bombs, drones, and a highly skilled Sniper attacks on Jin-man's home that whole scene is really terrific, warehouse underground technology. Close combat action scenes just wow !!
SUSPENSE DEVELOPMENT/BUILD-UP :-
the first four episodes focus on introducing the viewers to the characters, setting up bonding between uncle Jin-man and Ji-an, and establishing the relationships between other supporting characters and Ji An. This drama takes its time with its delivery of story progression, so it allows us to get to know Ji An's life with her uncle, her childhood and build the mystery surrounding Jin Man.
SINGULAR LOCATION STORY TELLING :-
It is rare to see simply because being in a singular location is not exactly a cinematic experience (to some watchers) and it can be extremely challenging to tell an entertaining story from primarily one place. But, when it is done right, and a director nails the blocking, and shot design, and there is a compelling narrative, it can create some of the best cinematic experience out there, so just trust the director work here before dropping the drama. Also for me this is the first time I'm watching a singular location story telling in K drama ( watched in movies ), For me the director and cinematographer succeeded in this aspect providing a gripping story telling with quality camera work and good colour grinding.
WRITING & DIRECTION :-
Directing writing is error-free - Though it's an eight-episode drama, some characters aren't given enough screen time. Overall, however, the drama's creators did an impressive work of presenting it, keeping the action and suspense at the same level from start to finish. In Singular location story telling Cinematography plays a crucial part ' Quality work of Cinematography and Camera work shines in every scene. And the director writer's excellent effort Brightens in every episode, amazing story telling with flashback connects to present story, outstanding screenplay that helps to understand the story progression easier.
CHARACTERS/ACTORS :-
Lee Dong-wook as Uncle Jeong Jin Man who played perfectly as an elite mercenary and an uncle who hides secrets throughout the eight episodes. Unlike the soft and witty appearance he showed in his previous works, Lee Dong-wook gave freshness with a normal but mysterious and sometimes grim face.
After watching Kingdom, Connect, it's normal to anticipate same level of quality acting from Kim Hye-joon and she delivered exactly what I expected perfectly, outstanding performance. The relationship between uncle and niece was attractive, fun and emotional. She gave an excellent performance in both action-packed scenes and deeply emotional ones.
Seo Hyun Woo ( Flower of Evil ) heated screen with his dark role, this is my first to see him in dark roles, never expected from him, i think he's perfectly fit to dark roles, i want to see him again as a Antagonist.
Such cool acting. Park Ji Bin watched his previous Drama ' Blind ', he got same type of role here but well performance by him as Jung Min.
Geum Hae-na as So Min-hye is a top-tier assassin with stunning action sequences created a great impression on her character role, she impressed me more after Jin Man.
Jo Han Sun as Bale as psychopath mercenary, He got less screen time but whenever he appears on screen it's just a firing moment, especially his eyes are really scary.
Child actor Ahn Se Bin impressed me more, she perfectly captured micro emotions of her character and same perfectly conveyed them.
FINALLY :-
As an action fanatic, I relished each and every action scene, delivering the ultimate action dramatic experience. In addition to having an action plot, it also shows a strong emotional connection between every character, which captures our interest in drama.
I enjoyed 8 eps, the plot not only focuses on the Ji-An survival and on her uncle Shop as primary story ( black market selling weapons and arms) but also drama runs with revenge plot in secondary story.
The eight episodes were masterfully directed, providing a compelling story. The plot and how it develops are what matter most, considering all the thrilling and suspenseful aspects of A Shop for Killers make you the best dramatic experience.
Just go watch and enjoy the drama.
If you are looking for fast paced action thriller you will binge to watch this drama !!
----------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------
ENDING + SEASON 2 CHANCES
Where is Jinman vs Bale story ?
In the meantime, Jeong Jin-man's biggest enemy, Bale, has yet to make any moves to carry out his threat to murder Jeong Jin-man's relatives and friends.
Yes, there is no specific ending of Bale like Seong Jo. Now everyone's question is Where is Bale? What happened to Babylon ? He's the main guy for the whole consequences, but the drama ended without his ending, so they will cover these questions in season 2 ? although ending is just perfect for every character who died and who is alive.
It's also unclear what made Jin-Man to supposedly die and then reappear, where he's hiding till to end ? So many unsolved questions left in 8 eps. These all led to the possibility of a potential season 2 with big story like Babylon, Bale and new enemies, I hope makers will plan to bring after they left us in a middle of puzzlement.
(Personal review) - Shinnosuke_Lee
Cet avis était-il utile?
If you want to watch it, do it !!!!
It was a masterpeice !!I really liked this drama and I will surely watch it again. From the music to the acting everything was a 10/10. All the characters were well played and were relevant to the story and the focus on the story of Jeong Jinman and his niece was well done and the end of each episode leaves you on your couch wanting more. The action scenes may be a little bit too violent for those who aren't at ease with this type of scene but they are very well done. This is the 1st time I watch a kdrama made by Disney + and Hulu and I think it was very well made . So, If you still haven't watched it, you should watch it and you will not regret it !
Cet avis était-il utile?
Non linear storytelling at its best (with few "flops").
Undoubtedly thrilling and unique story that does not give you a minute of a break - fast paced, well packed with both the plot and the action. Cleverly showing you just bits and pieces of a larger context, uncovering the whole story with each and every episode. While A Shop for Killers had a few issues, it’s still a title worth checking out - perfect for weekend binge watch.One could say it opens like a fish out of the water type of scenario. Not quite. From the start we can see that Jung Ji Ahn is far from being a defenseless young woman, even if she herself is not quite aware of it. Personally, I found the story of her growing up under the careful watch of Jeong Jin Man the best out of the whole show. The bizarre, but obviously strong bond they had, the silent understanding. It was amazing to watch her connect the weird training from the past with her current situation, and use said lessons to survive.
At the same time, Jeong Jin Man’s past seemed a bit messy and did not get the conclusion that fitted the initial tense atmosphere surrounding it. By the end of episode 8, I had to rewatch certain scenes just to make sure I did not miss anything. Where are the answers? Nowhere, just more piling up questions.
Another aspect that was a bit frustrating was how they at times utilized the non linear storytelling by repetitive usage of scenes. The show was short. There were some scenes that truly expanded on what was previously shown - giving us the whole context and full story. At the same time, there were some moments where the “already shown” part was simply too long. I’ve already watched these scenes one episode ago, you do not need to show it to me from start again. I could not stop myself from skipping minutes of the drama, just to get to the point where the story moves forward.
Performance wise? Amazing. Some actors were a bit typecast, which made it easier to guess the their intentions and possible actions, nonetheless - everyone delivered. Personally, I am a fan of Lee Dong Wook in dark roles, so this one hits the spot perfectly. Jung Jin Man is obviously not a good person, not a good character, but there is good in him and that’s what differentiates him from some of his, let’s say “co-workers”. Seeing these detailed differences was an interesting experience. They are both bad, but are they equally bad? How much of someone's actions is understandable, can be explained and excused, where is the line that should not be crossed?
Kim Hye Joon was amazing as Ji Ahn. Well executed character development. Loved the strong and raw emotions she was able to present when Ji Ahn was cornered and truly exhausted with the dangerous situation she got dragged into. Loved the more soft scenes of her as a carefree child and teenager. Loved how Kim Hye Joon was able to present the duality of the character in such a great manner.
Shout-out to the cute guy who helped Ji Ahn when she was a child, if you watched, you know.
Production was great - the soundtrack was full of bops, the fighting scenes had amazing choreographies, the practical effects of blood and other painful “things” were on point.
Overall, left a lot to explore, by the end felt like a borderline bait for possible second season with quite a few aspects not being fully explored. And yet, I’m not mad. It was highly entertaining, had many interesting characters on both the good and the bad side (and let me tell you, the bad side is BAD). Keeps you interested and engaged from episode one till the last scene of episode eight.
Cet avis était-il utile?
[spoilers]
i loved everything about this show except the ending..ok we all expected him to come back and not be dead but why couldnt it be 16 episodes with everything rather than probably waiting for season 2? everything else is amazing.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
One Tough Cookie Brought Up By a Mysterious Uncle: Thrilling With Suspension of Disbelief
My final review of what I believe is the first season of this thriller drama (although no announcement of a sequel at the time I was writing this review). This plot is about the survival of the Female Lead Jeong Ji An, being targeted by professional killers, taking shelter in her uncle's house. How and why it happens is slowly unraveled through past events. Warning: this is not a comedy like the parent story.STORY:
First of all, I didn't watch the parent story The Killer's Shopping List, nor read the novel under the same title "The Killer's Shopping List" (살인자의 쇼핑목록) by Kang Ji Young (강지영). Some comments said that there is no connection between this drama and the so-called parent story, only written by the same author. This is a survival story of our heroine, Jeong Ji An (Kim Hye Joon), because of what happened to her supposedly dead uncle Jeong Jin Man (Lee Dong Wook). Since little, after the deaths of her grandmother and her parents, Jeong Jin Man has been her sole guardian. He brought her up with a survivalist mind and tough love. During her grandmother's funeral, he made her watch a gruesome TV scene of a lion killed by a group of hyenas: "Only the weak bark, the strong don't. You must become strong to make your opponent bark. Don't be scared. Whatever makes you scared keep your eyes open and face it." When Jin Man took Ji An in after her parents's death and she fell on the ground, he didn't pick her up but said "Listen up, Jian. I'm not your parent and I can never be. Which means I can't do the things your parents did for you."
The fact that Jeong Jin Man prepares his niece in such a way as to be strong, independent, and capable of guarding herself makes sense later as the drama title is explained. Jeong Jin Man established an underground online business as the title says, a shop for killers. He not only sold guns but other weapons and chemicals as well. Jin Man was very secretive about himself and his customers so he gave them codes and even put himself and his niece in a special code: Code Green (I will describe the codes in the end under the spoiler).
I'm usually a generous rater, and am easily pleased, as long as a drama wowed me from the beginning till the end, I will rate it 10 (you can find out the dramas I rated 10 in my custom list). The reason I only gave this drama a 9.5 is because of the questionable details I saw along the way. If this is a fantasy genre I will ignore it, but the fact it builds upon modern survival and mercenary plots, it's dubious. I won't spoil them to you for this final review, you just watch the drama to find out. Basically, if you want to enjoy this story, you have to suspend your disbelief.
I will put the spoilers at the bottom of my review (you need to scroll down if you want to know, otherwise stop after the Visual)
CHARACTER AND ACTING:
Lee Dong Wook played the mysterious Uncle Jeong Jin Man with his usual traits: cold, aloof, but charming. We see more of Jin Man's actions in past flashbacks.
Kim Hye Joon played the survivalist niece Jeong Ji An. I stated above how her uncle brought her up, so we see the same cold and aloof trait in his niece. Some comments on the drama page stated that Ji An is too stupid when reacting to the attacks, but I have to defend her since she is not professionally trained and practically implemented for all that happened. Even all she did for survival is just based on her instinct to stay alive while remembering what her uncle and her master taught.
I won't spoil you with information on the supporting characters. The drama is too short to show much more about them. We learned about their background and how they came to know Jin Man, but the info about them is not enough to show that they are three-dimensional characters. I would love to see more (perhaps in the second season) about how Jin Man brought up Brother, Pasin's life (how a Thai man came and worked in South Korea), Min Hye's life after she was saved (her interactions with Jin Man, Honda, Brother, and Pasin) and how she got to know the villains, etc.
VISUAL (CINEMATOGRAPHY, COSTUME, MAKEUP, SET)
As usual, the Kdrama visuals for this dark thriller are amazing: the daring escapes, the gunfire and bomb explosions, the bullet movements, etc. Even the hyena CGI is acceptable. I kinda questioned Jin Man's home which seems so normal and humble but its walls, windows, and furniture are strong enough able to hold the gunfires and bombs to a certain degree. I assume Jin Man fortified his home strong enough for survival, perhaps having an underground bunker, too.
I will put spoilers down below about the Codes and the ending.
SPOILERS (Scroll down below)
CODES:
- Code Red: for killers (assassins) - they can only buy guns, weapons, bombs, and poisons.
- Code Purple: for spies (buy and sell info) - they can only buy listening devices and cameras. Also, simple weapons to be used to kill themselves when their cover is blown.
- Code Yellow: for clean-up crew - they can only buy drugs, detergents, and cleaning tools needed for body disposal and clean-up, and administrative service to evade the law.
- Code Green: for Jin Man and Ji An (though she didn't know before) - the other codes could never attack them. If they did, other Code holders have to risk their lives to protect Code Green.
ENDING:
- Ji Ahn and her uncle are alive. As I suspected, Jin Man faked his death (though are not shown what he did to 'kill' himself and why he did it if not just leave his niece to have her own show). He shows up in the end riding a taxi. He's all wound up, probably he had a duel with the top killer.
- A bunch of killers are dead. The top killer Bale and the Babylon company head are (probably) still alive if they want to make Season 2.
- Pasin and Brother are alive. Min Hye is probably alive, only shown her gun came off her hand but doesn't mean she's dead. I believe if watchers found her too attractive and charismatic to be dead, the screenwriter will revive her for Season 2.
Cet avis était-il utile?
his uncle has a brilliant minda
I am soo loving this series I demand for season 2 hehehe... This series is jam packed with action scenes I super like the fighting skills.I like the flow of the story wherein he Train his niece young to be tough and be strong I like that his training her without her realizing that she was trained by his uncle. I like that he trained her not to rely and depend on him she need to stand on her own feet.
His uncle has a brilliant mind that he does everything to protect her niece even if his not around.
Lee Dong Wook is super hot in this series.
Cet avis était-il utile?
An action packed story that keeps you interested despite its flaws
Some spoilers but no specific detailsThis started off very nice, and was still interesting till the end although I was not fully satisfied with a lot of things, the ending was a big fat useless cliffhanger with basically all the big plots still left unanswered. We basically just got rid of some "npcs" lol. And i just could not for the life of me understand how so many of these people (even the mc) survived the sht they went through: a machine gun blasting from every corner/ a shot through the eyes, stab to the throat and a burning house/ 2 freaking grenades!!!!!! and the list goes on. And STILL they all get up with a minor scar. Just very very unrealistic and a huge pet peeve for me.
a little bit of a spoiler here:
I like that the uncle wasn't invincible, like you could see him get beaten down buy a bunch of random dudes before he finally managed to take care of them and you could also see that he got scared from time to time. At first I was like mehh it takes away from the amazingly badass mysterious vibe they set him out to be in the first couple of eps... but then I thought this ACTUALLY makes him even more of a realistic character and less like the mc with the plot armor protecting her.
All in all this was a fun watch, I really wanted ALL those bad guys, especially THAT specific one to go out very, very painfully but I am at least happy Honda got avenged, he was my favorite character :'(
Edit: Oh wait I just realized something that annoyed me in the first couple of episodes and I don't think it was answered till the end. Why on earth were a bunch of killers obligated to protect the mc? like what would force them to do that, especially since some of them just took out whatever those implants were? Not mentioned, they never even showed up lmfao xD
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Unveiling Shadows: Deciphering the Intrigues of 'A Shop for Killers
A Shop for Killers," a gripping Korean drama released on Disney+ on January 17, 2024, emerges as a noteworthy addition to the platform's original content in South Korea. Adapted from Kang Ji-Young's acclaimed novel, the series is directed by Lee Kwon and No Kyu-Yeob, with a screenplay crafted by Lee Kwon and Ji Ho-Jin. At its core, the narrative revolves around college student Jeong Ji-An, portrayed by the talented Kim Hye-Jun, thrust into a perilous world of assassins and secrets following her uncle's mysterious demise.Episode 1-2: A Prelude to Intrigue
The inaugural episodes lay the groundwork for the series, introducing viewers to Jeong Ji-An's tumultuous journey. We witness her abrupt confrontation with skilled assassins, propelling her into a realm of danger and uncertainty. However, the decision to curtail action sequences raises questions, potentially hindering the immersive experience for some viewers. Moreover, the narrative's sporadic editing may disrupt the flow, necessitating further observation as the story unfolds. Despite these minor setbacks, the portrayal of advanced drone technology adds a layer of authenticity to the storyline, enhancing its allure.
Episode 3-4: Escalating Tensions
As the plot thickens, Ji-An finds herself embroiled in a labyrinth of deceit and treachery. The narrative delves deeper into her uncle's enigmatic past, unraveling layers of intrigue and suspense. However, the erratic editing persists, occasionally detracting from the episode's impact. Nevertheless, the series maintains its grip on the audience, delivering captivating performances and pulse-pounding action sequences.
Episode 5-6: The Battle Intensifies
In the midst of escalating conflict, Ji-An confronts formidable adversaries, testing her resolve and resilience. The episodes offer a glimpse into the character's growth and development, culminating in riveting showdowns and unexpected revelations. Despite occasional lapses in coherence, the series captivates with its intense narrative and compelling character dynamics.
Episode 7-8: The Final Confrontation
As the series reaches its climax, Ji-An's fate hangs in the balance, her courage tested like never before. The concluding episodes deliver a satisfying resolution to the central conflict, albeit with lingering questions and unresolved plot threads. While the series falls short of perfection, it succeeds in delivering a thrilling and emotionally resonant narrative that leaves a lasting impression on viewers.
Analyzing the Military Aspects
Throughout the series, the portrayal of military equipment and tactics adds depth to the storyline, lending an air of authenticity to the action sequences. However, certain discrepancies, such as the portrayal of drone technology and firearm handling, may raise eyebrows among more discerning viewers. Despite these minor inconsistencies, the series effectively integrates military elements into its narrative, enhancing its overall realism and impact.
Exploring Character Dynamics
Central to the series' success are its well-developed characters and their intricate relationships. Ji-An's journey of self-discovery and resilience forms the heart of the narrative, complemented by compelling supporting characters like Jeong Jin-Man and Min-Hui. Each character brings a unique perspective to the story, enriching the viewing experience and elevating the series beyond mere action-thriller tropes.
Conclusion: A Compelling Thriller
In conclusion, "A Shop for Killers" emerges as a captivating and enthralling drama that combines elements of mystery, suspense, and action with compelling character dynamics. While not without its flaws, the series succeeds in delivering a riveting narrative that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats from start to finish. As the credits roll on the first season, viewers are left eagerly anticipating what lies ahead for Ji-An and her allies in Season 2.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Pasin's Saving Grace
The series started off on a high note but quickly lost its grip, leading to a storyline that felt disjointed and lacking in coherence. Despite the narrative's decline, Kim Min's portrayal of Pasin was notably engaging, his acting skills shining brightly against the backdrop of the series' shortcomings.A special thanks to Kim Min for his exceptional performance. His dedication and talent brought a unique charm to his role, making his portrayal a memorable aspect of the series. His effort was a silver lining, deserving of recognition and appreciation.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Vale a pena cada segundo do seu tempo
Hoje, concluí a imersão no envolvente dorama estrelado pelo carismático Lee Dong Wook, conhecido como o tio mais gostoso da dramalândia. Em "A Shop for Killer's", Wook continua a surpreender ao interpretar Jeong Jin Man, um tio de natureza única que repudia injustiças. Apesar de sua profissão questionável e um shopping peculiar, ele assume a missão de treinar sua sobrinha para um futuro ataque, de maneira tão sutil que se torna imperceptível, quase militar, enquanto a jovem permanece alheia à intensidade do treinamento.O dorama é uma montanha-russa de adrenalina, prendendo o espectador do início ao fim, impossível de abandonar por um segundo sequer. As cenas são eletrizantes, por vezes brutalmente impactantes, e o suspense te deixa sem fôlego. A narrativa é intrincada, com várias camadas que se desdobram, cada uma mais fascinante do que a anterior.
O desfecho da história deixa um sabor de querer mais, e já estou ansiosa por uma segunda temporada, com minha pipoca ? pronta para a próxima sessão. A nota que atribuo é estratosférica: 1000/10. Este dorama é perfeito para assistir com um namorado, marido, filho ou sobrinho que não é aficionado por doramas, pois oferece uma experiência repleta de ação e isenta de romance; afinal, doramas vão muito além do convencional romance. Prepare-se para uma jornada cinematográfica que transcende expectativas e promete uma experiência única e envolvente.
Cet avis était-il utile?
VERY Strong start but...
Okay so going into this show I had zero expectations and hadn't heard much about it. I started watching and the pacing definitely caught me off guard at first but then it came together BEAUTIFULLY by episode 2. I loved where it was going. I love the whole concept of the show and the home invasion aspect was very intense. The throwbacks were also perfectly done (at first) and I was absolutely loving it. Episode 2 is one of the best I've seen in a while. The direction was AMAZING and so was the acting and score. Sadly things went downhill somewhere halfway. I could feel the momentum slowly fading away and it was honestly sad to see. The whole second half just felt kind of rushed like the original directors handed the project over to someone else or something. I would say episode 5 & 6 were still pretty good, but episode 7 was just very unnecessary and episode 8 was a HUGE letdown. VERY lazy writing across the board. None of the loose ends were tied together and even more questions were raised. The big bad guy didn't even show up for the fight??? Like where did he go... The ending was very anticlimactic and rushed. It was just plot hole after plot hole and I was so dumbfounded at how they completely dropped the ball. It just felt like the makers were told that they had to make another season while they were 80% done with the show...Cet avis était-il utile?