Complété
Not a Robot
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
déc. 8, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 9.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 9.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

Excellent Series & Angsty Tearjerker

Excellent series, but not perfect. Why? Because it seemed like the goal was to wring every last tear and emotion out of me, and that distracted me from noticing the subtle nuances of this series. To me, making me emotional is not what makes a great story, it's the whole package. The ending was unsatisfying, especially if I'm to believe they are meant to be together.

Story - A coming of age story. I usually love slice of life stories, but the reliance on melodrama and angst worked against it. I would have been happy if Oh-Aew chose Bas after the blessing, because the Teh x Oh-Aew's relationship was always on and off and full of drama. They were barely ever happy. At that point, I should have been solidly rooting for Teh x Oh-Aew. For me to be ready to accept Bas shows the story didn't express true love between the leads. Some positives were the expression of sexuality that is present during adolescence, and that Bas and Tarn were good people, not villains.

Acting/Cast - All of the cast did a fine job. I especially liked the two leads and Teh's older brother.

Music - Music was great, but the opening song and the score were not subtitled. The music selection was important, so they should have subtitled everything.

Rewatch Value - Probably not unless I want to cry.

Overall - An excellent series and would recommend it. The cinematography was beautiful and the locations scenes were gorgeous.


Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
iamhacchandesu
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 20, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

The BEST OF THE BEST ; ITSAY

Oh my gosh, finally i thought the wait is over....but here we go....I can't wait until March 2021
Thank you Nadao, Goy, Director, Billkin, PP and all the crews. You guys are amazing. I can not describe how thankful and how happy i am to have seen this series. these are 5 episode but the most complete and amazing BL series even best drama I have ever watch and I cry, i laugh and all the feeling i can have when i watch this series. I can not tell you how i am feeling now. I can jot just say thank you enough for all your hard work. All paid off and you set new standard for the BL series. I wish you good luck and stay better time to time. It is not easy situation right now with the world, and you just did an incredible job. i won't forget this series. keep it the best till then.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Markiepooh
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 20, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

Why it's a must watch

This drama is more than just the best BL ever.it is truly one of the best dramas I've seen.with such realistic portrayal of the human emotions it really captures ur heart.the acting in this is just unbelievable.not only the main leads but also the female lead does an incredible job .the locations and the sets and the camera work is just truly mind blowing.along with this the ost truly represents the beautiful bond of the leads.i have nothing bad to say about this drama.it was truly a breath of fresh air.if you haven't seen it already u must definitely give it a try.u will not regret it

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
ivnmcb
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 20, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

Describing the whole series as a masterpiece is an understatement

This series had set the bar high up to the heavens height for a BL drama. This series had hit me emotionally to the bones. After watching Episode 3, I decided to hold on watching the other BL series that were concurrently airing while ITSAY was also airing. I told myself that I would only continue watching the other series after ITSAY had closed all its chapters. But even until now, I still cannot make myself to resume watching the other series after I have watched ITSAY Episode 5. I know this may sound an overstatement or exaggeration to others but ITSAY has definitely gone through my system. Re-watching the episodes and listening to their OSTs repeatedly the whole day makes me feel like I am also a part of their story.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
veveve
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 20, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

BEST LGBT COMING OF AGE DRAMA I HAVE EVER WATCHED

its just the best. the way they told story of teenager. just like one of the comment, you can't judge them in adult standart, because teenager truly did stupid thing

acting : having Billkin and PP as lead are best thing ever, but this story is written for them, even the writer said they did some talking with Billkin and PP about the character. don't forget I Told Sunset About You is just another name of BKPP the Series

Music: having Billkin as the singer is best decision, esp since he is main lead. he would potray the story in the song more, made it more memorable. and Skyline chinese vers for PP, damn his voice is so smooth

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
alwennia
7 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
janv. 18, 2021
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

A wonderful moving heartfelt queer coming-of-age story <3

Do you ever watch something that moves you, that shakes you, and leaves a mark? The appropriate word is “qui vous chamboule”, but there is no English translation for the word “chambouler”. There is no translation for this feeling of being deeply touched by something that stays with you and shakes you to your core. This is the feeling that I am left with after having watched I Told Sunset About You.

We had been recommended ITSAY many times before finally taking the plunge. We had been warned of its quality, we had been warned that it would emotionally devastate us, we had been warned that it would be worth it. All three things were correct. This show stands on its own among the best shows I have ever seen. It is so far beyond the traditional clichés of BL dramas that I am not even sure it should be qualified as one.

I have rarely seen such thoughts put into the directing and the cinematography in a tv show anywhere. They make use of negative space on screen, the colour choices are always meaningful, every single shot is well made. The accompanying documentary (which I highly recommend you watch after finishing the show and which brought my appreciation for the work done by the cast and crew to a whole new level and it was already very high) shows even more the quality of the craft. Some of the scenes are highly effective because of the way they are shot, and any other filming angle would not have worked as well. The director was not afraid to make us stay in a moment with the characters way longer than was comfortable specifically because this moment was meant to be uncomfortable. The end of episode 3 is a masterful example of that. The gorgeous final scene is another example of both the talent and skills of the cast and crew and the amazing luck that they seem to have had. I am simply in awe of the work that was done and could not keep myself from marvelling out loud at the cinematography and directing even as I was watching the show.

The acting was also absolutely stunning from the youngest members of the crew (Khun who plays Bas is only 17 and I will be following his career) to the two main actors, Billkin and PP, and the other side characters. I already appreciated Nat who plays Teh’s brother’s Hoon, but watching the documentary also added him to the list of people whose career I want to follow (a trend for pretty much every actor in this show) and Smile who plays Tarn and manages to give such a depth to a character that could have easily (and often is in other dramas) been vilified. I am in awe of all of them. PP and Billkin are both absolutely amazing as Oh-aew and Teh. They ooze chemistry and they play off each other so well. The depth of character they both bring to those characters, the turmoil that is present inside of both of them constantly, the micro expressions, the looks, the way they deliver lines, the everything! I could honestly go on forever about some of the choices they all made at different points in the story, but that would be going into way too much detail and spoil the entire thing, but boy, will I be going elsewhere to read analyses of these.

And the music! The music! The Music! Three songs were recorded for this show in different versions sang by the two main actors and those were then strategically placed at different moments of the drama to add even more layers to an already layered story. Some moments which had already brought me to tears made me shed even more tears because a particular version of one of the songs started playing. Even the general OST is very well done and appropriate for the different moments. They made very good use of the music (and of the silences) in this show and the music itself was just so good. I will be listening to the OST on its own in the future because it is just that good.

And finally, the story. I left the story for last because I am not sure I have the words to talk about it. Everything I mentioned before comes together to support the story and what a scenario it has. This drama essentially gives us 5 films by the duration of each episode. They pack so many emotions. The writers said in an interview that for the emotional scenes, they purposely chose the dialogues so that they would make us cry and boy, have they succeeded. I was crying from the first episode. They managed to get me attached to those characters from the first moment. The kids we first see, best friends about to become rival, and the teenagers we then meet, the rivals to friends to lovers and so much more in between. The themes explored in this show are explored throughout the entirety of the drama from the expectations that our parents have from us (and sometimes that we think our parents have for us, but which are almost entirely our own. I know that really resonated with me and special mention to all of the parents in this show whose actors did a great job) to the discovery of our feelings for others, the confusion surrounding it, the discovery of our sexuality, the internalised homophobia we can feel, the discovery of what we want from life, from others, the pressure to succeed, the stress associated with it, the fear of what others might think about our choices, about who we are, the fear that is so present that you do not even dare to think about it for fear of making it real, the hurt we cause others because we are lost, because we do not want to face our feelings and our fears, because we act without thinking because we think it is the only way.

When I reviewed “Gaya sa Pelikula”, I said that it was making me think about issues I still had surrounding my identity and who I am and what I want today. For “I Told Sunset About You”, I see myself as a teenager in high school at 16 or 17, I see myself in Teh, in his obliviousness, in his fear, in his repression, in so much. There is something about seeing a character being terrified of what he wants and the way the story uses the device of studying for the exam to explore feelings and how characters use it as an excuse too. I will not go into too many details about moments in the story, but the choices made to tell this story, the use of gazes, of colours, of silences, of things said and unsaid (especially unsaid for Teh and his path to being able to use his voice without repressing it because of fear), I would not have enough space to tell everything I want to say. As I said, I relate a lot to Teh, but the other characters also get space to have their stories told. Oh-aew is starting from a different point to Teh, but is no less afraid and stressed about his future. We get discussions on what he wants and his slow realisation of it, like that of Teh, but with significantly more emotional maturity (they all have way more emotional maturity than Teh), the contrast of his character, way more sure of himself and observant than Teh but still so vulnerable, so young.

Both Bas, Oh-aew’s friend, and Tarn, Teh’s friend and the girl he likes at the beginning of the show, who could have got the short end of the stick (as is usually the case for this type of characters) got so much depth from the script and the actors. They got a progression in the story, they grew, they made choices, they were not simply just tools for the main two characters (and it is even addressed in the show, we love to see it). They deserve the world and I sincerely hope they will get it. Hoon, Teh’s brother gets to play in several key scenes, but there is one scene in particular in the last episode that is one of my favourite scenes in the whole show that moved this character from one I quite liked to one I loved. They really exploited both brothers’ relationship and how it affected Teh throughout the show and it is refreshing to see such a well-done relationship.

I am in awe of so many things, of the dialogues, of the moments without dialogues when they let the actors use their eyes and their body to convey emotions and messages, the use of Chinese, of props, the reminders, the objects used once in one way and then reused in completely different way to geta completely different emotions out of us (something that the crew said they did on purpose). Special mention for the use of Instagram in the show which I never seen used so effectively and in a way that made sense for the characters and the stories, but also managed to tell us so much about them (episode 4, if you know, you know).

I could continue for pages and pages, but this has already started to become too long. I am honestly in awe of everything in this show. The actors are fantastic (and did I mention PP and Billkin’s chemistry because it is off the charts!). The story is so well crafted, making us laugh and cry, smile and scream, wonder and worry. The directing is stunning. The job by the crew is wonderful (I once again cannot recommend you enough to watch the documentary that accompanies the series (that underwater scene!!)). The music will make you cry and you will start listening to it on repeat. Everything in this show was wonderfully made. Everyone involved gave their best and it really, really shows! I want this show to make a mark. I want everyone to watch this show. I want it to win awards and be shared abroad. I want to buy posters to put on my wall and DVD to put on my shelf. I want to rewatch it again and again to see all of the things I have missed, all of the symbolism that is peppered throughout the show. I am not sure I would be able to do it straight away because this show is so much and some of the story arcs and scenes left me emotionally devastated, but oh how worth it it was. I cannot recommend you enough this show. Please watch and support it!

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
jon conn
8 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
oct. 16, 2021
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 6.5
Histoire 6.5
Acting/Cast 6.0
Musique 9.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 5.0

Odd man out

I missed this when it 1st aired. Then I missed the second season. I decided to watch the second season 1st. I stopped after a few episodes when I realized I was not enjoying it....so I decided to watch the 1st season. I thought it was ok at 1st then I was like I'm liking this one either. I foreced myself to watch this to the end to try and see what everyone else saw. The cinematography was great and the music was great (overpowering sometime) . I didn't get what the fuse was about. I didn't like either characters. They cried way too much to be reasonable even in a drama series. It was even in the script when the brother called Teh a cry baby. Oh-aew was of course worse with the crying and totally not likeable in my opinion. The couple never seemed to have fun or enjoy each other. The actors were mediocre at best. The idea that they were rivals was just dropped. Never resolved they never displayed any real tension between them that I saw. Even love or sex tension. I didn't see it. The only likeable charter was Bas. Of course it goes that I will say he didn't have enough scenes or lines. Honorable mention goes to the brother Hoon again should have had more lines and scenes. As usually females were all annoying and not likeable. In my opinion there are many other low budget BL's that were more enjoyable and more likeable.
PS What's the lesson learned for this BL. Don't give up your college scholarship for a cry baby who doesn't study well?

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
En cours 4/5
greyishk12
12 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 14, 2020
4 épisodes vus sur 5
En cours 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

Truly Masterpiece!

"I Told Sunset About You" is a masterpiece. It's just too beautifully heart-wrenching, yet the most realistic approach to the LGBTQ+ issues we have in society. The thought of the heteronormative standard is the 'normal' standard of society. The idea of "It would be easier if I were straight." The constant pressure and need to prove our worth in exchange for acceptance and validation was executed way too beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time.

The cast, the script, the production, and the director behind this beautifully made series deserve an award. The message that it brings to the people around us and us who are part of the community is so powerful that it can change lives and perspectives. Indeed it is an eye-opener.

The last episode would be next week, and we hope Nadao Bangkok can give us a happy ending. Just hoping 🥺

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
En cours 4/5
MansiV
12 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 13, 2020
4 épisodes vus sur 5
En cours 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

A must watch coming of age drama "Masterpiece "

It's not a drama it's a real life story with real emotions, confusion and love. The series is soo realistic and soo good. It's soo different than the drama that we usually see. It's beautiful. The acting of the main leads is top notch like who will not love them. They are soo real. The spark between them is soo breath taking. The scenes where Teh smells the coconut is soo good like it bring out each and every emotion. Everybody could relate to one time or the other to the story like when Teh wants to message him but don't. The feelings of Teh are totally understandable. Special credit to the music it beautifuly blends with the scenes. I don't understand the lyrics but the music is so good I am thinking of making it my ringtone. I just made this account to give 10 rating to the series I hope these series gets as much popularity as it deserves. Beautiful story, awesome acting, beautiful cinematography . In all a masterpiece.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
En cours 4/5
Mary Krystine Afable Mac
14 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 17, 2020
4 épisodes vus sur 5
En cours 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

THIS SERIES IS FREAKNG AMAZINGGGG!

Everything about this series is perfect and I couldn't ask for more except *ehem* a happy ending. BKPP did a really great portrayal emotions, body language, and details are on point. The production, staffs and actors really did put EFFORTS making this series and giving us a quality series. OSTs are freaking amazing, I'm in love with the color grading, settings, details, actors, and the series itself. IF THIS COMING OF AGE SERIES DIDN'T WIN ANYTHING IMMA FIGHT THEM ALL. THIS SERIES SHOULD BE SHOWN ALL OVER THE WORLD , THEY NEED TO SEE WHAT A QUALITY SERIES SHOULD BE. IF BILLKIN OR PP DON'T GET ANY AWARD FOR THEIR ACTING THEN I'LL SLAP THE JURYS FIGHT MEEE! GOD TIER SERIES INDEED.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
itsay
5 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
déc. 13, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

wow...

just finished this and wow. really hope bas and tan get to find love in season 2 because they absolutely deserve the world. anyways this is definitely the best BL i’ve ever watched. i’m a new BL fan and i still have a lot more to watch, but coming from the corny (no offense,) yet still enjoyable GMMTV BLs i have to say this is most definitely a step up. also props for finally a BL not surrounding being located in Bangkok, even though they’re going their next season. would definitely recommend watching again or if you haven’t watched yet, WATCH IT!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
PsychoBunny
5 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
déc. 27, 2020
5 épisodes vus sur 5
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 8.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

I've been detoxed from all other terrible BL!

Finally, a masterpiece film! Now I have the strength to plow through another dozens of BL vomit. Thai BL is not dead!

Director's portrayal of youth and passion was told like a classic music: with stimulating taste, visually captivating, and steadily paced like ocean tide on a sunny day. I just wish they kept the same director for the sequel...

Main leads' portrayal of overwhelming teenage emotions through simple gestures and micro-expressions were refreshing and impressive than any veteran Thai actors. Oh (PP) silently seducing and teasing Teh (Billkin) or when Teh unknowingly followed Oh's every movement like a man possessed was like Siren drawing a sailor with their songs.

A must watch, and will be following the actor's future prospects with enthusiasm. Billkin's musical talent is also something to look forward to. Beautiful OST.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
I Told Sunset About You (2020) poster

Renseignements

Statistiques

  • Score: 8.2 (marqué par 26,960 utilisateurs)
  • Classé: #1657
  • Popularité: #222
  • Téléspectateurs: 49,931

Top Contributeurs

52 éditions
52 éditions
45 éditions
42 éditions

Listes populaires

Listes apparentées d'autres utilisateurs
BL / Gay (*Rated Order*)
653 titles 2826 loves 46
Thai BL Master List
687 titles 1501 loves 11

Récemment vu par