Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I would say I liked the second season a little bit better than the first one. Really really love the casting. I don't know why but every time I see Lee Sungkyung, I always imagine her perfect role as a rich snobbish girl or a doctor. Those roles really suit her. She and Ahn Hyo Seob have really good chemistry!!! However, I might say that the romance side of this drama was weaker than the first season. I was hoping it would've been highlighted a bit more.
The only thing I think was a problem for this season was they were trying to fit a lot of stories and plots into one season: The trauma of Cha Eun Jae, Back story of Seo Woojin, Park Gyumin's backstory, the illness of Master Kim, the evil plots of Chairman Do - to name a few. I think if they could've extended it to at least 2 more episodes almost everything, if not everything, would've been addressed better. The phasing was a bit too fast for the important parts. Especially the last episode, it seems like they just tried to put as much as they can to close the book.
Also, I wished they could've done more crossovers with the characters from the first season.
But still, really interesting and worth the watch!!!
Cet avis était-il utile?
So here I am, to give a thumbs up perfect rating for RDTK season 1 and 2. The visual effects, medical terms and on hand acting of the actors and actresses were so good to be true that at times you tend to forget they are not even real doctors. Additional contribution to the production was the on screen love chemistry between main leads, I am selective when it comes to being fanatic but this one nailed it. Not just in love but all casts were in good harmony.
Another catch, is the philosophies in life of Kim Sabu, he is an eccentric doctor but when it comes to humanism he is very deep.Kim Sabu can be mind blowing with his lessons in all walks of life. That's why it captured and won the hearts of the viewers.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Repetição do mesmo plot da temporada anterior
Na minha honesta opinião, com a mudança dos protagonistas, a roteirista não quis avançar para a segunda fase do Hospital Doldam e regrediu contando a mesma história de ameaça de fechamento e escreveu um pano de fundo muito semelhante para os novos protagonistas (quase um remake): uma médica brilhante mas psicologicamente instável, um médico que vem de uma origem humilde tentando provar seu lugar naquele campo de trabalho, um médico com problemas com um pai narcisista, uma residente inexperiente e bobinha. Todos amadurecem ao longo da temporada com a ajuda do Dr. Kim.Tudo o que foi muito bacana na primeira temporada, nesta segunda temporada pareceu sem graça porque não passa de uma repetição do mesmo plot da temporada anterior. Além de que os vilões são extremamente irritantes e birrentos (o que foi aquela cena do Do Yoon Wan quebrando tudo porque não conseguiu o "brinquedo"? Ridículo!).
Os episódios onde o foco eram as histórias dos pacientes e sua relação com os cuidados médicos eram BEM mais interessantes de acompanhar. Por exemplo, o melhor episódio na minha opinião foi aquele da paciente que doou os órgão. Dramático e emocionante como se espera de um drama médico e a altura dos episódios da primeira temporada.
Cet avis était-il utile?
And the LEGACY continues with new lead faces
Well !! After finishing Season 1, it was hard not to miss the original cast...like seriously ... While Ahn Hyo Seop and Lee Sung Kyung are my absolute favourites , it was natural to feel nostalgic for the previous crew. However, if you watch Season 2 with some time gap between, you’ll love this season just as much as the first.The side cast largely remains the same providing continuity and despite the change in leads, the team dynamic is still strong. The interactions and relationships among the characters remain compelling, with Teacher Kim once again at the center, mentoring and guiding the new doctors with his usual brilliance.
Just like in the first season, the medical cases are accurate and informative. The terminology and procedures are correct, which adds authenticity to the show. However, I felt like there were fewer medical cases this time around compared to Seas
The chemistry between the new leads is wonderful And Their shared history as classmates gave their love story a cutesy feel to it . The male lead though talented has a troubled past involving his family and a senior doctor who lost his license over illegal surgeries. While our the female lead struggles with OR phobia and can't perform surgeries.
Teacher Kim’s role as a wise mentor is still intact he helps both leads with their respective issues thus nurturing them into brilliant medical practitioners
What sets this season apart:
1. The previous season was more or less about cases involving common people but this time it was given A political edge, particularly with a major case involving the Minister of Defense.
2. The number of medical cases is lower with the focus gradually shifting towards a trauma center setup from the previous hospital setup.
3. The leads have more complex and morally grey backstories compared to the previous ones.
Definitely worth watching 💕💕
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
This series is so good!!!
First I would like to clarify I got into season 2 without watching s1 and because ahn hyo seop was playing….I was hooked from episode 1 and invested throughout the series, the end even left me wanting for more which I can’t believe my luck since s3 just started airing (As of writing this)
The writing was surprisingly better than I expected, the drama aspect outside of one/two moments was well balanced, which was also surprising~ I expected it as a medical drama to be even more over the top.
Characters were definitely the highlight of the series for me
Woojin (Ahn Hyo seop‘s character) I instantly liked from minute one and Eunjae was also likeable.
((Insert rant here: I saw way too many comments about her being annoying which I honestly do not understand??? I feel like there are way more actual annoying main female characters out there but of course hating on the female character for being weak or having a mental problem is quite common.))
Moving on Master Kim was also good! Loved him as the mentor character especially with woojin.
The other side characters were also good and I did not find boring for once, from the main nurse and manager to the other doctors and the cute side couple.
The bad characters although extremely annoying didn’t seem unreasonable or too cartoonish (at least to me). Some even had their development by the end like park for example.
I understand if romance was the only reason someone watched the series they could come out disappointed as it was not that much the focus. Personally I did not feel the series missed anything in the romance department and that is because I liked the mains dynamic and found their interactions enjoyable. Sometimes a simple romance works better than a drama filled and complicated one which was the case here!!
Overall this is definitely worth a watch!!
I also recommend starting with season 2 and if you are invested enough go back for season 1 as I did myself,,, since in my opinion s2 is much better than s1
Cet avis était-il utile?
Not quite my cup of tea
There’s nothing inherently bad with this drama that I can point out to be quite honest, I think somewhere along the way it just stopped being my cup of tea. I never enjoyed office/corporate politics and it was rare that I ever got into them, and Dr. Romantic 2 was full of office politics. Naturally, I ended up watching this drama at 2 times speed for the second half and I have to say the season finale was quite heartwarming and I do love all the characters. I think there’s just something about the pacing or directing or the office politics storyline that didn’t quite click with me and that is a-o-kay. I can absolutely see how this can be someone’s favorite, it’s just not mine!Cet avis était-il utile?
My lifetime drama
You don't know how many times I've rewatched this drama. I LOOOOVE IT SO MUCH!Looking at the reviews from others are quite diverse. Some are loving the first season, the others love the second season. These kinds of different opinions indicate that this series did it right. I think it depends on each preference and that's totally okay. I loved the second season more.
The reasons why I loved the second season sooo much, even declaring it as my lifetime drama are because of these reasons:
1. It's really beautifully written. The story flows really well. Every episode leaves you on the edge of your seat. Nobody is perfect (except Kim Sabu ofc). They have their own struggles like everyone else in real life and the character development makes us rooted for them. I bawled my eyes out for some episodes and I'm someone who rarely cries while watching a drama. It's very inspiring and makes me look back on how I am as a person. I want my own Kim Sabu too...
2. It focuses more on the hospital and medical aspects than the romance part. Many medical dramas are just romance drama with a hospital as a background or doctor as an occupation. I found the first season focus on romance more too. Here, they prioritize their job as a doctor first, to save life first. But they also showcased how doctors are human too. The cases are very very interesting. I even rewatched the surgery scenes only just because I admire them sooo much.
3. The acting. Gosh. At first, I found Cha Eunjae character annoying and started to doubt Lee Sungkyung acting. But as the episode goes, she got better. I understand her better. I sympathized with her character. I think it's a success for Lee Sungkyung. No words are needed for Han Suk-kyu, he deserves all daesangs in the world. Ahn Hyoseop, God... How come he's very good at acting yet SO HANDSOME?!?! In fact, I became his fan and watched almost all his filmography after watching this drama. And other casts too. I really could believe that they are real people, not an actor. They did such a fantastic job.
4. THE CHEMISTRY! I loveee all the Doldam Squad. They are really like a family. I also love how the mentor relationship between Kim Sabu-Woojin and Kim Sabu-Eunjae unfolds. I think their chemistry is better than S1. Well again, Kim Sabu became much softer in S2. And for Woojin-Eunjae, wow. How come they have such overflowing chemistry by only exchanging gaze??? They speak with their eyes... They have a very minimal romance scene, but it's very beautiful. The best slow-burn romance story for me. It's frustrating but understandable? Like I totally understand why Woojin hesitates a lot and Eunjae needs time. Anyway, it's really rare even in real life to fall in love quickly with someone right?
5. The cinematography and the OST are gorgeous. I could feel that the director, writer, and production team really love and have pride in their works. I applaud them soo much for making such a difficult work beautifully. Excellently executed.
6. I am obsessed with their epilogue with the college story of Woojin-Eunjae. I really wished they made a prequel or special episode for their college days only :((
I dislike any slander for my lifetime drama. But again, everyone has their own opinion. Hope you give it a try, and I hope you like it as much as I do.
Cet avis était-il utile?
AMÉ
la empecé con muy poca fé y la verdad es que la terminé amando. hay episodios que me llegaron al alma y me emocionaron bastante. todavía me da un poquito de impresión cada cirugía porque se siente muy real.el cast es excelente, la recomiendo mucho.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Round 2
Edit: April 19, 2023Rewatching Dr. Romantic Kim 2 again just after hearing the release of season 3 makes me so happy.
Anyhow, this show is still my favourite medical drama of all time!!!
May 4, 2020
I LOVE DOCTOR ROMANTIC KIM 2, I love the slow burn development of Eun Jae and Woo Jin. It literally took them 16 episodes to be official again. As much, I love them I also love Nurse Park and Dr Yun. These two are such a good second lead couple. Dr. Yun has such a sweet sunshine character and Nurse Park, I want to know more about his past since I didn’t watch season 1. So this makes me want to watch season 1 now. As for Master Kim, I hope that he finds his love and Dr. Bae too. Moreover, I really love this series. I wish Dr. Shim had more screen time since her character development is great.
FURTHERMORE, I FEEL LIKE THERE WILL A SEASON 3 SINCE THERES THE ODD BALL PROJECT THAT MASTER KIM IS PLANNING. I WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT IT HELLO!!! PLEASE GIVE US A SEASON 3. I AM MORE THAN WILLING TO WATCH IT. GIVR IT TO US PLEASE!!!
Also, CAN PEOPLE STOP COMPARING SEASON 1 TO SEASON 2. THEY BOTH ARE GREAT AND THAT THEY SHOULD NOT COMPARED SINCE THEY HAVE THEIR OW STORYLINE WITH GREAT CHARACTERS!
Lastly, I LOVE THIS SERIES, one of my favourite kdrama for this year!!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Musim 2 sama bagusnya dengan Musim 1
Saya telah membaca beberapa review dan saya cukup terkejut bahwa beberapa dari mereka memberi drama ini review/rate yang buruk padahal sebenarnya itu adalah drama yang bagus. Pertama, saya adalah penggemar Romantic Doctor yang sering saya tonton musim pertama itu, dan saya pikir menontonnya lagi sebelum memulai musim kedua ini bukanlah langkah yang buruk karena pesona drama medis masih ada, serta, ketegangan, dan romansa. Saya masih takjub dengan kasus-kasus yang mereka bawa setiap minggu dan bagaimana Dr. Kim (bersama dengan Dr. Woo Jin dan Dr. Eun Jae dengan bantuan staf Doldam) mengatasinya. Itu juga bagus bahwa mereka masih menyebutkan karakter Dr. Kang Dong Joo dan Dr. Yoon Seo Jung di beberapa adegan dan bahkan Dr. Do In Bum cameo yang benar-benar menghebohkan episode terakhir itu.Kedua, saya juga ingin memuji karakter baru karena memberikan bumbu baru dalam drama saat mereka memperkenalkan cerita dan latar belakang mereka kepada pemirsa. Terakhir, saya juga ingin memuji OST karena memberikan kehidupan pada adegan-adegan yang membuatnya lebih menarik dan mengasyikkan untuk ditonton.
Secara keseluruhan, memang benar bahwa entah bagaimana berbeda dengan musim pertama yang sebagian dari kita mengatakan bahwa itu sudah kehilangan pesona ketika mereka memulai musim baru dengan lead yang berbeda. Tapi bagi saya, saya pikir drama ini memiliki karisma yang berbeda yang memikat pemirsa untuk menontonnya setiap minggu yang jelas benar karena melewati 20 persen rating pemirsa pada penayangan pertama dan memecahkan rekor sebagai episode baru datang. Namun, saya dapat mengatakan bahwa dalam hal drama medis-romantis, serial "Romantic Doctor" akan menjadi nomor satu dalam daftar saya.
SAYA BERHARAP AKAN ADA SEASON KE 3 DIMANA DOKTER DARI MUSIM 1 & 2 BERKUMPUL PASTI ITU AKAN MENGGEMPARKAN RUMAH SAKIT DOLDAM HUFT! SANGAT SANGAT BERHARAP ^_^
Cet avis était-il utile?
DR. ROMANTIC 2, EQUALLY AS GOOD AS SEASON 1, DR. ROMANTIC! DO NOT MISS THIS!
I watched Dr. Romantic 2 almost immediately after the first season and found it as entertaining and as captivating. Teacher Kim (Han Seok Kyu) continues with his mentoring of a new set of doctors whom he hires from a top medical hospital in Seoul. His first set of mentees Dr. Yoon went to continue her studies in USA, Dr. Kang volunteered to work on an Island hospital and Dr. Do returned to Geosan Hospital in Seoul.As the countryside Doldam Hospital is not exactly on the top of first year medical doctors list to apply, Teacher Kim managed to scout three doctors, one eager to learn from him and two who have personal issues to deal with. Not only does Teacher Kim have to deal with these doctors, but he also continue to face the Dr. Do Yoon Wan (Geosan Hospital Director) who is determined to destroy him and his career. Every episode is so fast paced and good to watch. The new couple of Dr. Seo (Ahn Hyo Seop) and Dr. Cha (Lee Sung Kyung) subtle love story is also well placed in this season. Dr. Do Im Bum's (Yang Se Jong) guest appearances on Episodes 10, 14 and 15 added a lot of fondness, respect and nostalgia between his relationship with Teacher Kim which is settling to watch. It truly connected the first and second season beautifully.
I must say that the Dr. Romantic series has gone way beyond my expectation of a medical drama. Not only was it a good watch for me in Season 1, but to also enjoy Season 2 is truly a first for me.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Better than the first season..
When I managed to finish season 1, despite all faults, I got attached with Doldam Hospital and it's medical staff.Then I was curious with the young female doctor who faints or fall asleep everytime she had to go to the O.R. I thought it was absurd really, a surgeon who had panic attacks at the surgery room..
I still think, Doctor John is way better than this one. But I think this is better than the first season. It's just that its too tiresome to have the same antagonist all throughout these two seasons.
I think this is more emotionally charged than the first season. Would I rewatch it? Maybe not. But I don't regret watching it either.
Cet avis était-il utile?