Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I've never wanted amnesia until this bl
I want to address the fact that some reviews are saying "it depends on what genre you like" how does that make any sense? The genre has nothing to do with how most of us feel negatively about this drama right? So, I'm going to be blunt about how much I hate this series. Also, at episode 10 I couldn't take how slow this show was going so I watched it in 1.75 speed.STORY- TW: Pedophilia/Grooming, Non-consensual Sex
The story is dry, and the script is so shit. The same problems were repeated over and over again where the characters keep lying to one another. They put in some sex scenes so we can ignore the fact that they're in a toxic relationship of lying, abuse of power, pedophilia/grooming, etc. However, the sex scenes still fall flat cause there was no build up and it's just Lian forcing Kuea to have sex with him. This drama is a BL it's not a porno, so a sex scene was so unexpected. Also, the people who were praising this show for "consent" are absolutely wrong because after halfway through the show they throw consent out the window because whenever Kuea kept telling Lian to "stop it" he never stopped and just kept going. This is also true for Hia Yi, and Diao cause their sex scene was so out of the blue and came just after Hia Yi confessed to him and there was no verbal communication, just did it without even saying anything.
About the pedophilia/grooming part, Lian was 7-12 when Kuea was born so there is a big age gap. If I can re-call I think Lian said something about loving him since the day he was born which I find really weird because I assume the type of love he is talking about is romantic and not platonic. The abuse of power comes from how Lian forces Kuea to live with him and doesn't take no for an answer. They're lying to each other because they can't trust the other. Trust is an important factor of a relationship, so this just further shows how they don't have a healthy one.
At the beginning of the show, they made it seem like Diao also had a fiancé but that wasn't even close to what was going on between him and Yi because they weren't even in a relationship. The plot was dragged on and on and didn't develop till the last 2 episodes either.
The arranged marriage part wasn't necessary since there was no reason for the adults to arrange one in the first place. Also, the way Kuea's father just arranges a marriage for them even though Kuea is just an infant is so odd and gross to me.
Diao interfered in Kuea and Lian's relationship after being told he shouldn't which is so childish. Diao and Hia Yi have a major plot hole in their relationship because their past relationship and how they met and what happened to Diao wasn't cleared up.
Lian says to Kuea "I don't think it is love yet" so Lian didn't love him but after Kuea says he's going to call off the engagement he suddenly loves him? They also didn't explain how Lian and Kuea's family became friends. It's also just insane how they make Lian hide the fact that he bought the Keerati family's property from Kuea because something as important as that I think Kuea should definitely know. Honestly, this show is just absurd.
CHARACTERS-
Kuea:
Lian proposed to Kuea, but Kuea rejects him and even after all the "misunderstandings" are cleared he still won't accept his proposal because he wanted to propose to him instead which shows how selfish Kuea is. Kuea is also one who doesn't clear things up and just makes assumptions like, "they didn't tell me because they think I'm a kid". Kuea assumes that Lian doesn't love him despite Lian CLEARLY repeating that he loves him over and over again. He also overreacts and cries way too much. A good example of a character crying a lot is in Theory of Love where they made me actually feel the pain the character is going through and for good reason too. Also, Kuea's real character wasn't elaborated on enough cause the only things we know is that he's a biker, a singer, wears cool clothes, and an engineer student. And once Kuea revealed his true self to Lian he hasn't changed at all and still acts somewhat like a doll.
Lian:
He thinks that Kuea is a "bad boy", who needs to be forced into an environment where he has no choice but confess who he really is. Lian has a small set of facial expressions and is supposed to appear as a cold boss of a big company but clearly doesn't seem to appear that way. Lian at the start of the drama payed little to no attention to Kuea and was cold to him. At the end he has completely fallen for him and acts like a puppy desperate for the other's affection. Lian also is someone who does things behind his lover's back like stalking and getting information on him from people he knows which is really weird.
Diao:
Making it seem like he is a kid who needs to have someone look after him and keep him in check. Diao acts like a kid and still does things like interfering in someone else's relationship. Making NC scenes between him and Yi uncomfortable.
Yi:
A man who pities a guy he loves. Hia Yi got in an accident with Diao at some point and pitied him for what he had done so he gave him a house to stay in. Hia Yi is possessive and controlling to the point where he wants to know where Diao is almost 24/7. Hia Yi and Diao can't properly communicate (which is really bad for a relationship) so Yi buys Diao a dog instead hoping to make up with him.
University friends:
Kuea is a university student and studies engineering. seem familiar? bet it does. Well although his university life doesn't appear a lot in the show there is a side couple of Syn and Nuer. Syn and Nuer had chemistry but barely any screen time at all. The show showed one scene of Kuea's university friend Nuchy where she stood up for how when a woman is mad it doesn't mean they're on their period. This drama has made 1-3 attempts to show how they "care" about lgbtq+ people and women. However, I don't see it as how they care they're just trying to gain likeability.
ACTORS/CAST-
The actors are all good looking and some have great acting experience. I like the cast but their acting in this show wasn't their best. NuNew's acting was.. it was good enough, but he doesn't have any other experience in acting and also the only times he didn't seem cringe to me was when he's at university and when he's on stage.
CHEMISTRY-
Lian and Kuea:
Their chemistry was practically non-existent for me. Only during NC scenes did I feel like they had some tiny bit of chemistry.
Yi and Diao:
Not a lot of chemistry.
Syn and Nuer:
They had good chemistry and a healthy relationship, but I feel like they could pull it off better if they had more screen time. I hope they get to act in a different series together with more screen time.
MUSIC-
2 birds with 1 stone. Thats what it was. NuNew is a singer and an actor he is also good looking. They made him sing the opening song (which I didn't like). He also sang a lot of other songs in the show, but I only liked 1 of them. I feel like they could've just made him the singer and have a different actor for Kuea.
PRODUCTION-
Production quality was definitely great.
TROPES/OVERUSAGE-
The childhood friend trope is definitely an overused one to be honest. Also, Kuea is in university and does engineering which is obviously overused and anyone would know this if you've seen university based bl's. Like they could've made Kuea be in computer engineering and that would honestly make me feel better about this.
OVERALL-
This series is a waste of budget and a waste of your time. This show makes people think being controlled and manipulated is "hot" when it isn't.
P.S.-
Why is an 18+ rated drama on YouTube? that makes no sense whatsoever. If I could give this show a lower rating I would.
If you actually read all my nonsense then thanks. (This is my 3rd review, so I bet it's really shitty)
Cet avis était-il utile?
cute bl but not the best
I've seen many BL's so an office romance drama doesn't feel like anything new. However, the show offered a lot of cute moments with the two characters and made this a great short bl.pros:
-age gap that doesn't feel unnatural
-good beginning
-the emotional scenes were really good
-good acting and camera angles
cons:
-uses a popular trop
-uses the same audio over and over again (but i still like the audio)
-only 5 episodes so they probably cut off a lot from the original story
-slightly rushed but it's not really anything to worry about
I hope for a season 2 cause I loved the characters. Also, this is a good bl if you want a quick watch.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
My opinions on the show and other reviews (very few spoilers)
Okay so I'll try to keep this as short as I can, but I do have a lot to say about this drama. First of all, it's a really amazing series I honestly really loved everything about it; the chemistry between all the actors (both romantically and friendship wise), the music in the show (I listen to their cover of "just being friendly" so much), the cinematography (especially when they went to the beach), and the story itself was really simple and easy to follow along with. This show is honestly going to be one of my favorites! I read some reviews before writing this and I got a lot of different viewpoints and opinions, some saying the show "has a lot of cliches and tropes" or "they aren't middle schoolers, having more psychicality isn't inappropriate for their age" or something along those lines. I understand but not all BL's have to have NC scenes and honestly, I prefer it if they don't. Those type of scenes aren't for every BL and maybe the actors weren't comfortable doing those things. Also, I don't understand the "tropes" part. It would have been nicer if the reviews elaborated more on that topic so I would understand better since I didn't recognize many tropes in the series but maybe that might've been because I don't read or watch as much BL as lots of others do. The story actually felt different to me compared to other BL's where the pair slowly develops feelings for each other unlike in this drama, there was already existing feelings. Though that is probably more common than I think it made me more into the story as it was something I could relate to (having a one-sided crush on someone). That's all I have to say and as I expected it turned out to be quite long but unlike my review on cutie pie the series (I had A LOT to say about it) this is actually relatively calmer. Thanks to whoever is reading this out of the 155 other reviews. I hope you decide to watch this series even if you have some doubts. Also, it would be great to get some feedback on my review so I can do better when reviewing other shows in the future. As for the rewatch value I just have trouble rewatching shows in general so that's just a me problem lol.Cet avis était-il utile?
boring and a waste of time
I think I might be late to the hype hahaha. I took a long 1-year break from bls so I might be a bit late for this review, but this is what I think of it. First off If anyone's seen my reviews you can probably tell that I put rewatch value pretty low and that's mainly because I don't like to rewatch series but this one was rather short so I put it especially low because I can easily remember such a short series so there is no need for me to rewatch it. As for the music it was pretty basic and doesn't really have a great impact on the series itself thus the 3.0 rating. I took a look at the other reviews, and I completely understand the low rating that one of the reviews gave the show. It certainly wasn't anything new or unique which is what I agree with, but I honestly do not care if it's nothing new I am purely rating this series by itself and not the other series that might resemble this type of sequence of events. as another review said,"Episodes 1-4 convoluted beginning and storyline
Episode 5-6 they find love
Episode 7 the angst ridden episode with problem/break up
Episode 8 they remember how to communicate, and it all ends happy."
You get the idea, pretty basic. On its own I think it is good concept which could have been made better with a better storyline and longer episodes but there isn't really much to expect from Korean bls since they are usually 15 minutes long per episode. This was a really quick watch and honestly, I was expecting more but it was decent. the acting was actually pretty good, and their chemistry was pretty nice since they looked like they were very comfortable with one another. Honestly all of the other reviews are overexaggerating saying it's the "best Korean bl of 2023" which I can't agree with at all because we're not even halfway through 2023 and there are definitely going to be more upcoming bls from Korea. I think this is a good watch for when someone is bored and has nothing else to watch but if you have other series lined up I suggest watching those first. Overall, 6.5/10 for me because of the acting and chemistry between the 2 actors.
Cet avis était-il utile?
The drama is so much better
I'm going to be honest the drama was much better. People might say that the movie is better because it's not romanticizing Kitou Aya's story but I believe that even if it is romanticized I think the drama is so much better. The drama talks more about her story than the movie and the acting is much much better. The movie was low budget and very rushed compared to the drama. So, I think that the movie deserves a 6. If they had gotten a better cast and had a higher budget, I think that it could be a 10. However, we already have a drama to which I think is a 10.Cet avis était-il utile?