Renseignements

  • Dernière connexion: sept. 28, 2024
  • Genre: Femme
  • Lieu: Ontario, Canada
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Rôles:
  • Date d'inscription: avril 25, 2020
Meteor Garden chinese drama review
Abandonné 18/50
Meteor Garden
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
by Mars
août 20, 2024
18 épisodes vus sur 50
Abandonné
Globalement 5.0
Histoire 4.0
Jeu d'acteur/Casting 5.0
Musique 4.0
Degrés de Re-visionnage 1.0

Disappointing Hanadan Adaptation!

As a manga purist and a huge fan of Meteor Garden (2001) and Hana Yori Dango (2005), I really tried giving this drama a chance since many people claimed it closely follows the manga. However, in addition to stripping away what made HanaDan a great story - a strong girl who withstands class issues and bullying and transforms the most violent and troubling guy into a human being - this adaptation was reduced to just a mediocre tale of an arrogant jerk and a normal girl who occasionally have unpleasant interactions.

Because these crucial elements were missing, neither the characters nor the love story were convincing to me. I understand China's censorship laws and all, but even with those constraints, the writing fails to build a coherent story that makes sense and lacks meaningful developments. Additionally, the acting and dubbing were major turn-offs. I tried skimming through a couple of episodes, but it didn’t get any better. This is like HanaDan for kids at best - if you prefer a good story, stick to the 2001 Taiwanese version or the Japanese version. Otherwise, skip this one.
Cet avis était-il utile?