dragynfaerie
USA
Chou no Rikigaku is the 4th (perhaps last) installment of the Murder Analysis Squad series. It's been 4 years and detective Kisaragi Toko is no longer the wide eyed naive rookie she was in series one. She's still a bull dog though.
The MAS series began with Ishi no Mayu. I did a full review of it so I won't go into detail Needless to say, it was very good and worth a watch. Next came Suishou no Kodou, which takes place 1 year after the end of ishi no Mayu. Metro Police Dept Division 11 is on the scene with all but 1 familiar face. Kisaragi is trying to overcome the psychological trauma she experienced in Ishi by jumping head first into cases. She also makes several trips to the prison to visit the serial killer from Ishi, who refuses to see her. I found SnK to be more of a character analysis than murder analysis. Yes, there were gruesome murders, but the suspense and tension that was is in Ishi was lacking. As in Ishi the cast was very good as was the production. The music did it's job. I don't remember there being any particular song. The rewatch value is fairly high as it's only 5 episodes long. 8.5
The third installment is actually a hen (part of the story usually not involving a main character) and takes place prior to series 1. Aku no Hado revolves around Yuginuma Masato, an important character in Ishi and shows the events that led him to cross paths with Kisaragi. If Kodou is a possible character study, Aku no Hado most definitely is one It revolves around the Hanging Oneself murderer. However, at it's core Aku shows the awakening of a psychopath if one can go from sociopath to psychopath that is. There is very little in the form of investigation. The suspense comes mostly at the end of the last episode. There's also the added tension of waiting for the psychological break that you know will happen. It was a little lacklustre, but sufficient. Hado is not thrilling at all, but it is good. It starts slow and builds to a crescendo which is the beginning of Ishi. The cast is good. This was my first time seeing Ikeda Tetsuhiro (Det. Iguchi) in such a meaty role. I'm used to him as the bungling sidekick to Yabe Kenzou. I have respect for his acting skills now. I'm glad I watched this one, but I wouldn't want to watch it again. 8.0
As I stated Chou no Rikigaku takes place 4 years after the beginning of Ishi no Mayu. Kisaragi has come into her own as a police detective. I still was not fond of her. I had a lot of questions on Rikigaku's pecking order. It made no sense to me why a detective with only 4 years experience essentially becomes the team leader over more seasoned detectives. I kept thinking 'who is she to give them orders' and 'why are they listening to her without push back.' It was just too unrealistic, especially given that female detectives still aren't taken very seriously in Japan. A fact which they make all too clear in the 2nd series. Otherwise, I enjoyed CnR. The murder toll and murders were amped up. It also marks the end of the team as we know it since there is a transfer looming. I enjoyed Rikigaku. I liked the intertwining story/stories and how they come together. Rikigaku has the the same core cast as Kodou and they are equally as good. The production is solid as is the background music. Re-watch is fairly high as the drama (and Murder Squad series) is short and I feel like there may be clues I missed this first go 'round. 8.5
The Murder Squad series is led by Kimura Fumino. Personally, she's not my cup of tea. I don't know what it is about her, but she annoys me. Perhaps it's just the type of characters she plays (they usually have some kind of personality flaw), or it could just be the actress herself. I'm not sure. I do acknowledge that she does play her characters well. In the first 2 series I wanted to shake her several times. In Rikigaku I just wanted to punch her... just. The veteran cast does a very good job as her supports. However, the stars of the series and the fun ones to watch are the psychopaths in series 1 and 3. Both actors were great.
The writing and production for the series is solid. Hado is a little below the other 3. Some quality was cut as if the budget was lower. Overall, the music was good as it conveyed the emotions necessary. If I could score the series in it's entirety, I'd give it a 9. Yeah it takes some leaps, but they're entertaining leaps.
The MAS series began with Ishi no Mayu. I did a full review of it so I won't go into detail Needless to say, it was very good and worth a watch. Next came Suishou no Kodou, which takes place 1 year after the end of ishi no Mayu. Metro Police Dept Division 11 is on the scene with all but 1 familiar face. Kisaragi is trying to overcome the psychological trauma she experienced in Ishi by jumping head first into cases. She also makes several trips to the prison to visit the serial killer from Ishi, who refuses to see her. I found SnK to be more of a character analysis than murder analysis. Yes, there were gruesome murders, but the suspense and tension that was is in Ishi was lacking. As in Ishi the cast was very good as was the production. The music did it's job. I don't remember there being any particular song. The rewatch value is fairly high as it's only 5 episodes long. 8.5
The third installment is actually a hen (part of the story usually not involving a main character) and takes place prior to series 1. Aku no Hado revolves around Yuginuma Masato, an important character in Ishi and shows the events that led him to cross paths with Kisaragi. If Kodou is a possible character study, Aku no Hado most definitely is one It revolves around the Hanging Oneself murderer. However, at it's core Aku shows the awakening of a psychopath if one can go from sociopath to psychopath that is. There is very little in the form of investigation. The suspense comes mostly at the end of the last episode. There's also the added tension of waiting for the psychological break that you know will happen. It was a little lacklustre, but sufficient. Hado is not thrilling at all, but it is good. It starts slow and builds to a crescendo which is the beginning of Ishi. The cast is good. This was my first time seeing Ikeda Tetsuhiro (Det. Iguchi) in such a meaty role. I'm used to him as the bungling sidekick to Yabe Kenzou. I have respect for his acting skills now. I'm glad I watched this one, but I wouldn't want to watch it again. 8.0
As I stated Chou no Rikigaku takes place 4 years after the beginning of Ishi no Mayu. Kisaragi has come into her own as a police detective. I still was not fond of her. I had a lot of questions on Rikigaku's pecking order. It made no sense to me why a detective with only 4 years experience essentially becomes the team leader over more seasoned detectives. I kept thinking 'who is she to give them orders' and 'why are they listening to her without push back.' It was just too unrealistic, especially given that female detectives still aren't taken very seriously in Japan. A fact which they make all too clear in the 2nd series. Otherwise, I enjoyed CnR. The murder toll and murders were amped up. It also marks the end of the team as we know it since there is a transfer looming. I enjoyed Rikigaku. I liked the intertwining story/stories and how they come together. Rikigaku has the the same core cast as Kodou and they are equally as good. The production is solid as is the background music. Re-watch is fairly high as the drama (and Murder Squad series) is short and I feel like there may be clues I missed this first go 'round. 8.5
The Murder Squad series is led by Kimura Fumino. Personally, she's not my cup of tea. I don't know what it is about her, but she annoys me. Perhaps it's just the type of characters she plays (they usually have some kind of personality flaw), or it could just be the actress herself. I'm not sure. I do acknowledge that she does play her characters well. In the first 2 series I wanted to shake her several times. In Rikigaku I just wanted to punch her... just. The veteran cast does a very good job as her supports. However, the stars of the series and the fun ones to watch are the psychopaths in series 1 and 3. Both actors were great.
The writing and production for the series is solid. Hado is a little below the other 3. Some quality was cut as if the budget was lower. Overall, the music was good as it conveyed the emotions necessary. If I could score the series in it's entirety, I'd give it a 9. Yeah it takes some leaps, but they're entertaining leaps.
Cet avis était-il utile?
