Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Loved it more than i thought i would
I’ll start off by saying i’m not a big fan of body swap and i was one of those who was concerned when this was announced as EM’s next project. But surprisingly i loved the show more than i expected i would.STORY : My main concern was Win being in Lins body would limit the interaction and screentime between the 2 leads, hence why other people were afraid if this was a real BL. But they were able to make it work since majority of the time was just the 2 of them travelling and since Korn knows its Win, he and us viewers sees Win too (i’d say 90% it was still EarthMix/KornWin interacting). Lin mostly just appears when theres other people or if the scene required Lins body. I wasn’t too concern about Korn being confused of who he really likes because it was pretty obvious from the start. This was a story of them having to be brave and confront their feelings for each other because both of them are scared of losing whatever they have (friendship or more) if they confess.
As i’ve said before i would’ve preferred they didn’t add the kiss scene in episode 8 but watching the last 2 episode made sense. It was a built up for the arranged marriage plot which i thought they removed from the book. I suppose it was a creative/change decision by the team behind this. I think alot of people hating on the kiss and the marriage was those who read the book and was comparing it to the source material. But if you watch this as a standalone piece without any background from the book it all made sense, the story and flow. That’s why i’m not being so hard on this, as someone who have a brief idea on the source material. I have some things i would’ve preferred they didn’t change but i’m rating this based on the show alone and not in comparison with the source material. Although i do feel episode 9 was a bit draggy and slow but episode 10 redeemed it for me.
PRODUCTION: I’ve some issues with some color grading and sound choices for some scenes but nothing too major. This show had the rare chance of fixing some minor problems before the youtube premiere so i hope they take it.
ACTING : is on point from all three main leads, i felt bad for Mix in the beginning having to shout and being angry all the time and i agree that its the directors job to see if how he portrays the character is right. Mix wasn’t cringey or bad acting like a loud asshole, that was what they and his character asked of him and he was just doing his job. You can see he can act angry/sad without shouting in episode 9, something i was glad they changed from the trailer because he was shouting at that scene too originally. The switching between Mix and Jan was another highlight, both were good, acting as themselves or the other. Earth was good as well, balancing the sweet, patient but sometimes already at his limits Korn. White had so little screentime but still very likeable, he looks so cute with his hair btw.
MUSIC: I was already getting LSS from the OST played in the trailer so i know i’ll love it, although only 1 was just released i’m already playing it on repeat. The lyrics were specifically written for their characters so it made it more melancholic and gave you more feels. Can’t wait for the other OST to drop. I also love the song Just Being Friendly played in 1 scene, it was definitely an earworm.
REWATCH : I’ve already rewatched some scenes and i’ll definitely watch it again at GMMTV YOutube premiere on sunday.
OVERALL : I definitely recommend this for people who wants a lighthearted with a bit of heavy drama towards the end. Give it atleast 3-4 episode watch so you can decide if this might be it for you or not. This is definitely not perfect and has its flaws but it worked for me and it might work for you too.
Cet avis était-il utile?
A Tale of a Thousand Stars
4 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!
This is one of my all time fave by now. I don't know what else to say, most of the reviews here already listed everything nice about this show so, Here are some of my favorite thing about this show:Acting : You would never have guessed that this is Mix's first acting role, his subtle expression and change of emotion are really good. You can really see he's acting just with his eyes, for example the hornbill scene when chief asked "Romantic?" you see his expression changed from happy to shy/awkward just with his eyes. Same with Earth they both complimented and elevated each other here. CHEMISTRY IS TOP-NOTCHED.
Music : OST is really good, you can never get tired of it even with 3 versions of the same song. Other songs used are really chosen well, especially with the incorporation of WIND which makes it feel like they're all connected. I've listened to the shows track on repeat since it ended, every time you hear it it gives you that nostalgic feeling of the show.
Story: The heart transplant plot has definitely been done before but the show took a fresh take on it. Other viewers were afraid that they would fall in love because of Torfun's heart (maybe chief liked Torfun before she died) but they pretty much made it clear that it wasn't the case. The heart transplant was used mostly to progress Tians character development, to make him a better person.
Rewatch Value: I've been rewatching this since it ended since i've been missing the characters. Still gives me all the feels.
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Cet avis était-il utile?