Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Let's compare the Thai version...
Finally watch this after I can't keep my curiosity anymore for this re-make. Quite happy to watch this...If I draw 1 conclusion between Thai & Japan version, for me the Thai is more like down to earth or more connected with me. I don't know is it because my country is closer to Thai than Japan, so I can relate more with this version. Or maybe because it just have more episodes, so they have more duration to explain some stuff. I'll try to explain it as much as possible...
The more 'down to earth' or what i more like:
+ The growth relationship between Achi & Karan better than Adachi Kiyoshi & Kurosawa Yuichi. I can't really explain how, maybe i just more like it....
+ The way Karan look into Achi is more obvious than Kurosawa to Adachi. The Thai version is kinda have broke 4th wall rule, we can see several times when Karan smile behind Achi, the smile that have obvious meaning....
+ The viewfinder of Karan toward Achi. We see how much care Karan of Achi. This proven by the speech Karan give about Achi in company gathering or the little gesture that Karan did for Achi everyday. I don’t remember such things from Japan version, maybe I'm wrong, or it just not too deep imprint in my mind...
+ The cuter Jinta than Tsuge Masato. And that's make the relationship between Jinta & Min is cuter too.... But at the same time Jinta is really one stereotypes characteristics of Gay man.
+ The strong Pai. I really like the strong & quirky Pai. The way she burst out to her ex is really fun to watch....
+ The 'dumb' Rock. Although Rokkaku Yuta is also a little 'dumb'. But I feel Rock is more innocent vibe than Rokkaku & that's make him cuter too...
+ The relationship between Pai & Rock. I really like & happy Thai version make the relationship between Pai & Rock happen.
+ A little Japanese touch. Yeah this one specifically for this version. I like they still make the boss be an expatriate that comes from japan, we can hear from his accent.
+ The growth in Achi. In here we can see Achi want to grow in his career. He consider quiting cause he feel his career is go nowhere, so instead allowing Achi to quit,his boss offer him new position. In japan we see no such, Adachi quite comfortable with his position in the firm. Yeah I know, this much have connection with Japan office culture.
The minus from this version is maybe that Karan put too much effort for Achi, so it seem imbalance for their relationship. I mean when Achi want to move city & they decided to separated beforehand.
Overall both series is good in their own way... I quite happy to watch both version.
Cet avis était-il utile?
As sweet as cherries.
I am full of love right now.This series gave me everything I was looking for in a Thai adaptation and more.
Sure, lots of people kept comparing it to the Japanese drama, which was also perfect, but this one just gave me more emotions than I thought it could.
It starts with a lonely insecure Achi and a resigned Karan and it makes them bloom, come out of their shells, and try for the unknown. The growth of each character in this story is something so satisfying to see and to cheer for throughout.
The side characters are absolutely lovely as well, and I appreciated all of them from beginning to end. Jinta was definitely an improvement from his Japanese drama counterpart, or even the manga: I was delighted every time he was on the screen.
Karan and Achi's love is equal, selfless, generous, mature and understanding. It's cute. It's what I love about romance stories. I wish there were 100 episodes, I'm sure I would just keep smiling at the screen and get emotional and fall in love a little bit too during each and every one of them.
I'm proud of how Tay and New matured in their roles from their latest series together. I hope I can see them working together again in the future, because their chemistry can just become stronger.
Overall, it's definitely become an instant comfort series and I am surely going to rewatch it in the future.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
MAGICAL COMEBACK: it would be a mistake if they didn't make more projects with TayNew !!
I have come to a conclusion that Cherry magic made in any form, any language, any country would always be my favourite. There is just something about this story that makes my heart flutter, punch air, smile like an idiot every time I watch it. Its Just MAGICAL!!!So if you ask me what is special about the Thai Cherry Magic?.. Offcourse its TayNew.. their chemistry is top-notch. They are both handsome, look good with each other and are phenomenal actors. Therefore, I say they would be doing a huge mistake if they don't make more BL projects with TayNew....!!!
Except for this there are also other factors to watch this for:
1. The side couples are also adorable.
2. Acting of the whole cast is just as good
3. Good production value.
4. Good character development.
5. Music is also great... all songs are good.
6. And of course, Passionate kisses
OVERALL: I am just Wipped for this show. If you haven't watched it, you are missing out on something great.
SPECIAL: My favorite Dialogue and moment is when *Rock(Sing) says "WTF".. upon figuring out KaranAchi are a couple... It was ICONIC!!*
Cet avis était-il utile?
Another adorable adaption!!
Cherry magic, one of the most adorable bl story out there and being a fan of the japanese adaptation, I waited until the very last episode to binge watch it and I do not regret. In the first few episodes I saw many people saying shit bout the cast and the story. But personally i cannot think of anyone other than Taynew who could've done justice to these roles in thai version. They were way too adorable?. 10/10 recommendation.Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I like it soooo much!
TayNew chemistry is off the roof! I didn't get to watch them as I didn't really like the previous series they were on, but I'm glad I've a chance to appreciate their amazing chemistry and acting here! I want to see more of them!Karan's inner voice is so funny, especially when he sings off-key, The 1st half of the show are so funny that I laughed out loud almost at every episodes, the 2nd half is funny too but it starts to get more romantic
Best part? Wedding!!!! After TharnType, I don't remember seeing any wedding I like, and I'm so happy to get this wedding . I also love how they proposed to each other, that's super cool, why didn't I ever think of that?
I also love other characters in the show, they are what makes the entire series came alive. Really well-balanced and well-made show. I actually wish to see Mark as a main lead next time
My heart is so full after watching this, it's really worth every episode spent!!
Also, I am now a new TayNew fan, anyone else?!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Pillar of BL
TayNew proved to all of us how BL should be, their undeniable chemistry is timeless, indeed they are the pillar of BL series.Cherry magic is a cinema, they have incredible shots on this series, cinematography is serving! This is what TayNew deserves, a series like no other, I know that this is just an adaptation but to be honest, their exceeding beyond everyone’s expectations, from their actings, expressions they’re both killing it!
IINGATAN, PAGSISILBIHAN, LULUHURAN, AALAGAAN, JOJOWAIN, AASAWAHIN, MAMAHALIN HABANG BUHAY, I TAKE THEE TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, IN SICKNESS AND IN HEALTH, FOR RICHER OR FOR POORER, TO LOVE AND CHERISH FROM THIS DAY FORWARD UNTIL DEATH DO US PART, YES PO FATHER I DO.???
Cet avis était-il utile?
i like it, really recommend it.
This series is really good, I really like it and really enjoy every second, minute and every episode, basically this is a really recommended series,In fact, almost every romantic moment I kept screaming so enthusiastically, that I thought my family at home was crazy, hahaha
Well, it can't be helped, this series is that good,
That's all from me, basically
"very good" and a recommendation too.
i love you ???????
i like it.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
A show to be cherished, though it could have used more tension
When I heard there was going to be a Thai adaptation of Cherry Magic, I was wary. The Japanese drama is very dear to my heart.I have to say I loved the first half of the show up to, and including, the airport episode. There was clearly an importance in contextualizing the overall themes of the show into Thai culture. The visuals were gorgeous, the pacing was excellent. The airport episode is, to me, an act of genius.
I was somewhat disappointed in the second half. To me, personally, it lacked tension. Everything was resolved too neatly, I think. There's a difference between overwrought drama and the lack of it.
The meeting with the parents lacked, to me, some tension, some friction. I know I'm comparing it in my mind to the Japanese version, and to me the movie is excellent at portraying the trials of accepting someone with their truth. That's the epitome of love, and I think the Japanese version did it better.
I do commend the series for going where the Japanese version didn't (or couldn't?): the overt signs of affection, the kisses, the love scene. Cherry Magic seems to be a type of series that doesn't rely on that - but it also doesn't avoid it. So good work on that.
Jinta and Min seemed to have been somewhat sidelined in these later episodes - but I loved their moment at the hotel in the finale. Very special and touching. I could see a special or a short spinoff with these two.
I loved Pai particularly. Rock was lovely, as well as Dujdao. They really nailed it on the casting.
All in all, this was a delight to watch. Kudos to everyone involved. Despite what seemed to me a disappointing second half, this was clearly done with heart and attention, and deserves much praise and needs to be cherished.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
loved this much better than the original
I was super excited to see that there was going to be a remake of Cherry Magic, because unfortunately the original didn't really live up to the hype for me. I hoped that this remake would fix at least some of my issues with the original, and thankfully, it did!I absolutely love the additions and changes made to the story. The last few episodes especially were so, so sweet--and truly indicate how much this show, and this couple of Karan and Achi, care about communication. The main couple are so tender and kind with each other; their many hugs and moments of hand-holding were genuinely nice to see. Of course I'm glad they kissed as well (one way they deviated from the Japanese LA), but the way they clung to each other was one of my favorite aspects of their relationship. My only complaint I suppose is that sometimes Achi felt a bit too stiff; I couldn't always feel the same level of care and emotion in him that I felt in Karan.
For the second ship, well. I hated Tsuge lmao so I was very pleasantly surprised that Jinta was one of my favorite characters! While I did like Jinta and Min together a lot, I feel like Jinta really shone. He had a lot of character growth and was consistently really funny, really crazy, and a pretty good friend and boyfriend. I was really happy for Min by the end, they seem like a great couple who actually have something to bond over and it was fun to see!
And finally, for Rock and Pai. While their relationship was really cute, I honestly wish it would have stayed just a friendship. However, what we did get with them was adorable so I'm not too mad. I really enjoyed how it seemed like they truly got along well and made each other happy.
Fuck Tanaka though, terrible boss.
Anyway, this show was super fun and sweet, I would definitely suggest giving it a try!
Cet avis était-il utile?
so freaking adorable
there is something to be said about just a cute, sweet, romantic series without much angst.I loved Cherry Magic Japan I don’t think a series has never made me laugh as hard as that did so I was hesitant about the Thai version. but here is the thing they are completely different. yes the premise is the same, but the Thai version has so much depth in it.
it was the slowest of slow burns but dang was it good. this is probably my favorite TayNew series now.
also Karan is the greenest of green flags.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Taynew comeback
The story was amazing and the acting was making it more amazing because it is Taynew, making the whole series questiong are they Karan and Achi or Tay and New. The proposing was making me tear because it is show that it doesn’t have to be the top propose to the bottom because when you have love, it does not matter. What unexpectingly was the tear of Achi (New) was not in the plot, which make it more emotional and a new level of acting.Cet avis était-il utile?
Cherry Magic TH
Saya pribadi sangat excited waktu pertama kali tau kalo taynew yg akan memaikan peran ini. Series ini sangat layak untuk di tonton karena chemistry mereka dan side cp nya yg tak kalah menarik, cerita nya ringan tetapi membuat yg menonton malu. Untuk taynew sendiri mereka layak memerankan series ini dalam comeback mereka ke dunia bl. Seperti penantian polca selama ini sangat amat terbayar dengan adanya series ini. Untuk kalian yang ingin menonton series nya JANGAN RAGU Krn sangat seru aku jamin itu.Cet avis était-il utile?
