What If (2022)

What If It Had An Actual Ending!?

Overall: I initially rated this short and sweet series an 8.5 and could have even rated it higher, but what was that non-ending??? Aired on WeTV.

Content Warnings: none

What I Liked
- young actors did a good job
- the transition/time jump was clear and well done at the end of the first episode
- cute and sweet moments
- I like that the hyper/younger one is more studious
- the subverted trope in ep 2 when they were celebrating and alcohol was present
- outro song (there isn't an intro)

Room For Improvement
- wish they didn't play other music when the guys are learning/playing guitar so we could hear the original sound on those scenes
- for the short run time they spent their time poorly, that whole jealousy thing could have been cut out and they could have actually had Peach confess/do something non-platonic...
- Peach and his friends are idiots, they really didn't know who that song was about???
- this almost seemed like an acting workshop instead of a series
- it's odd that the production company released this at the same time as My Only 12% as they have very similar plots

Lire davantage

Why is it that the Thai bls with potential end up being short?

Cute, ordinary, uncomplicated. Nothing significant is happening but it's still kind of refreshing in a way. I think I just like the simplicity it came with. The guy playing as Smart is adorable and his eyelids comes together when he smiles just like Jimin.?

Two things tho, number 1 - I found it weird that Peach was asking Smart who the song was for. Like dude come on, who did he eat, play and grow up with? You guys literally grew up together, did the "neighbor" thing not ring a bell? Or was he pretending not to know?

Secondly, what was that ending? It didn't even feel like an open ending, did they figure out they have feelings for each other? The show literally just ended ?

Overall, I don't regret watching this. It's a lot better than Coffee Melody so yeah it is not that bad.

PS : Why is it that the Thai BLS with potential are always the ones that are short? Tsk tsk....

Lire davantage

I wish there was a clear ending....

This story is very short, sweet and just breezes right through everything. There's virtually no character development or true story progression, and yet, I somehow still enjoyed the first 4 episodes. The characters were endearing and Smart was just adorable. I really enjoyed the song.

But there was no clear ending. It wasn't even really a cliffhanger, per se, it just ... stopped and credits rolled and I didn't know why it was over yet. It felt like it ended mid-conversation mid-scene with absolutely nothing to show for it. I had good feelings and good memories of the first 4 episodes, but that last one ... I can't even say it was a bad ending, it wasn't any kind of ending, except that it ended.

Lire davantage

If they returned to film a solid final episode this could be a wonderful series

I liked both the younger and older actors. The story was sweet but it hurt to see Peach blow off Smart for a whole year. Who can't speak to their friend once in a while and still study for exams? Why, even after she was told that Smart was Peach's close younger brother, did Smile still act so threatened-even before meeting Smart? It seemed to me (unlike some others here) that Peach did acknowledge that the song was written about him when he asked and teased him to the point that Smart asked "Why is your face so close?" Peach didn't respond by rejecting or accepting Smart's feelings which wasn't normal. How was Smart, so shy at freshy events he had trouble introducing himself, suddenly able to come out AND confess to Peach in front of their faculty? Do they get signed on as a Duo and also become lovers? Do they get signed but Peach rejects Smarts feelings creating awkwardness when dating others? Does only 1 get signed? What about their friends? If they returned to create 1 or more well-written episodes that addressed everything, it would be great. I know they were 2PLAYERZ but finishing the series would be nice.

Lire davantage

An unfinished cute Bl series

What if has no complicated plots so far. No thrilling or exciting event yet!

It's just the ordinary story of two very intimate friends, Peach and Smart. As I await ep 4 of this series there are somethings that I like about this show.

1, It's not boring, despite the fact that there's nothing happening that is supposed to be that eye catching it manages to avoid being dry.

2, It's short, unlike many Thai BL series What if is very short, there's no additional information except that which is needed to further the plot!

3, The actors are acting perfectly fine, that they're able to portray their feelings and emotions in a series that seems to be blanch is an achievement!


As it's only two episodes left,I just hope that the usual girlfriend-jealous act doesn't permeate this drama and that like the recently concluded Bl series " 21 days theory" that it's ending surpass its beginning!
Okay ? I gave it a 9.0 rating cause the ending was just like a film cut short but I personally like the series

Lire davantage

Clichê

Olha, não tenha grandes expectativas... é uma série com baixo orçamento, atores inexperientes e um roteiro bem clichê.
A história gira em torno de dois amigos de infância, Peach, que é muito estudioso, e Smart, que apesar de ser um ano mais velho não gosta de estudar. Peach dá tudo de si para ajudar Smart a entrar na faculdade, mas depois se sente sozinho, pois o outro está envolvido com as atividades acadêmicas e não tem tempo pra ele...o mais novo, apesar da idade, percebeu e aceitou primeiro seus sentimentos, mas optou por guardá-los. O segundo percebeu depois o que sentia, mas aí o roteiro me joga um final aberto!

A série tem seus encantos, é bem fofa. Os atores são medianos mas cantam uma ost linda. O clichê de quase sempre, mas que não pode faltar. Enfim, eu não pretendo assistir de novo, mas recomendo sim!

Lire davantage

Ok, ¿y entonces qué pasa después?

Honestamente, tengo que admitir que un poco me arrepiento de haberla visto. No fue una pérdida de tiempo porque no toma mucho el verla, pero sí fue algo pesada de ver, y no intentaría verla de nuevo.

El cast está bien, lo que no está bien es el desarrollo del guión y ese pésimo "final" que nos quisieron dar. ¿Lo vería si hacen una segunda temporada? Probablemente sí, solo para saber cómo es que termina realmente, pero espero que no la haya.

Hay muchos factores que pueden afectar a un cierre tan abrupto y un final tan meh, y espero que haya sido algo externo que afecta directamente a la serie, y no porque simplemente decidieron escribir la historia así. Es en parte confusa y en parte aburrida, no la recomendaría, a menos que solo quieras verla por los actores; en ese caso vale la pena (no son nada malos, y tienen una chispa que los hace interesantes).

PD: si le puse una estrella a la música y al rewatch value, es porque MDL me está obligando.

Lire davantage