Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Amazingly cute, but a lot of missed potential
A story about a mysterious love interest found in a book, who is Enchanté? Side note; the actual identity of Enchanté completely surprised me tbh. Anyway here are my thoughts.The cast of Akk and Theo is brilliant, Force and Book did an amazing job and their chemistry is beautiful, they are friends since childhood after all. The characters are well-acted and believable. However, I did massively dislike that most of the love interests were liars and opportunists. It's a realistic scenario, but it's not super fun to watch and you just feel bad for Theo and Akk.
Akk is lovely and perfect. The series tells you he isn't but like... look at him! Always ready to help, super handsome, funny, serious, like there is literally no flaw. Theo is likable, but he is naive. There are times that I am surprised by his wariness however lol, he doesn't let someone take advantage of him so easily. Besides this, Theo makes some questionable decisions, especially in episodes 9 and 10, but he is a cutie at the end. Still should have treated Akk better throughout though.
The music is absolutely gorgeous, both "Je t'aime à la folie" as well as "Enchanté" are beautiful songs, some of the best I have heard in a BL ever. The music helps to bring the mood together and to feel invested.
I enjoyed this BL but compared to other GMM TV BLs such as Bad Buddy, 2gether, Fish upon the sky, 1000 stars etcetera, this one feels inferior. Perhaps because of the story and annoying plot points, as the scenes that focus on Akk and Theo are lovely. The parts involving the four Enchanté's are curious at times and boring or annoying at others. It would have been a better series if there was less Enchanté's and there was more of Akk and Theo. Not that there are few moments of theirs, but it feels too long until they take each other seriously. I am excited to see more of ForceBook, and hope that their next series is only great.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
QUE COISA MEDONHA
Meu Deus que pesadelo que é essa série.Comecei empolgada porque anteriormente eu tinha visto "A Boss and a Babe" e acabou sendo uma das minhas maiores decepções.
Ao longo da história você percebe como Theo é um personagem terrível, ele é manipulador e infantil num nível extremo, tudo gira envolta da vida do Theo e os problemas do Theo.
Ak é o seu melhor amigo de infância e o segundo protagonista da série mas ele só gira envolta do Theo.
Logo no começo somos apresentados a condição de vida difícil do Ak e desde que o Theo voltou a ser seu vizinho isso foi deixado completamente de lado, assim como apagaram qualquer conflito próprio ou complexidade do personagem.
O Ak é um personagem que poderia ter tantas camadas mas escolheram fazer dele o cachorrinho do Theo que faz tudo que ele quer e perdoa tudo que ele faz num piscar de olhos. e as escolhas que o Theo faz ao longo de absolutamente todos os episódios são tão terríveis que só vendo pra entender o tamanho do problema.
E eu nem vou me dar ao trabalho de falar sobre o último episódio de tão patético que é (eu vou ter que falar, mas não queria porque me da dor física só de lembrar). Sim o final é feliz, mas a que custo? Depois que eles estão bem o Theo decide ir embora do país, e pior, só comunica isso pra ele dias antes e ainda fica se fazendo de coitado, se não fosse pelo Ak que é um eterno cachorrinho dele (no mau sentido) eles nunca teriam um final feliz (e que final feliz mais patético).
Já estava ruim e meter uma separação com passagem de tempo de anos acabou com tudo (eu abomino passagens de tempo em absolutamente todos os dramas, perde toda a magia).
Eu estou até agora chocada com o tamanho da decepção que eu tive, sem contar que quase não tiveram cenas realmente românticas deles como casal, parecia até que eram só melhores amigos mesmo.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Entertaining watch
I honestly don't understand all the hate this series gets. It was highly entertaining and I thoroughly enjoyed the mystery aspect of it in the search for Enchanté's identity. It filled the time of the series really well (especially since we already know who Theo is going to end up with anyway) by creating the drama somewhere else rather than constantly throwing things at the MC like other dramas do. Yes there was a little bit of potential crushes looking to get with Theo but I personally liked how all the 4 Enchanté's had different reasons for claiming to be him.The fact that Akk was willing to help, despite his surfacing feelings for Theo, also made us wonder if perhaps Akk was in fact Enchanté and hoping to prove to Theo that he was there all along. It helps showcase the care and investment Theo and Akk have in each other while teaming up to solve the mystery while also realizing their feelings along the way. And, personally, I didn't see a hint of it coming when they finally revealed who the real Enchanté was. I was even going so far as to guess it could be his father trying to anonymously befriend him to sway his feelings on trying to keep the literature program going. (Spoiler alert: it's not the father.)
I thought the acting was well done, especially by the supporting cast. I felt like everyone bounced off each other really well and all the clashes of personalities and motives made for an entertaining watch. In truth, I think they probably could have gone on with the different stories from all 4 Enchanté's a little longer, which is rare for me. Normally, I'm thinking a series could have been a lot shorter because most of the "filler" is unnecessary or boring or repetitive or a combination thereof. But here, I was so curious in all of their reasons and would have been just as happy to see more of it explained. I feel like out of the 4, Saifa got the least amount of explanation but it kind of makes sense once you find out his involvement.
(Can you tell I'm trying really hard not to say who Enchanté is?)
Speaking of which, I would suggest, if possible, watch the series without finding out who Enchanté beforehand. I admit, normally I am one to check spoilers and such but with this series, I managed to hold myself off and I think that really lent itself to the enjoyment of the watch. That being said, I'm actually looking forward to watching this series again in the near future to see if I can spot extra hints, now knowing what I know.
Cet avis était-il utile?
I am slightly sad that many watchers find this series a waste of time.
But of course, people have their own opinions and I respect it so I’m not gonna argue.
For me, this series is wonderful and underrated.
The story was not interesting at first but it kept getting more better in each episode.
The actors did very well and I admit that their performance is great!
They acted out their character very well and worked hard.
Everyone did a good job filming the series.
Enchanté might be my new favorite.
Cet avis était-il utile?
EymiLaritzaJorgeCastillo
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Adorable... mas no la mas memorable...
Esta es la historia de dos mejores amigos de la infancia, uno que se fue a vivir a Francia y el otro quedo en Tailandia y su reencuentro. La historia gira en el regreso de a Tailandia de Theo y de encontrar un "admirador" secreto con el que esta compartiendo mensajes mediante un libro, y deberá averiguar quien es el verdadero entre 4 chicos que dicen ser Enchante. Junto a su amigo Akk, buscara quien es realmente el verdadero entre ellos.Me acabo de ver esta serie, en su momento cuando se estaba emitiendo no la vi, pero en estos días me dio ganas de verla.
La verdad es que la historia es simple, pero adorable, fue el primer trabajo de Fort y Book como ship, y yo que conozco su trabajo actual, debo decir que han mejorado muchísimo su actuación en los últimos años, ojo, no quiere decir que actuaron mal aquí, pero si se compara con otros trabajos de ellos, puedo decir que han mejorado.
La historia en si es simple, y en cierto punto pensé que era total mente predecible, no se si fui la única, que no espero quien era en realidad Enchante que tanto busca, al inicio pensé que sabia quien era, y pues me equivoque . Me reí a momentos y la verdad es una historia tierna que te la puedes tirar en un solo fin de semana (como hice yo) es linda y la musica me encanta, me enamore de este OST desde que lo escuche en el 2022, sin ver la serie, y ahora que la vi, la seguiré amando porque es muy buena.
Es una serie para ver si no quieres grandes dramas y la quieres pasar bien y relajarte un momento, al menos para mi fue adictiva, porque la verdad, me puse a verla un sábado y ya la había terminado el domingo. No creo que sea la serie mas memorable, pero solo el tiempo me dirá, si lo fue o no, ya que las series con las que no conecto se terminan olvidando, asi que solo el tiempo me dirá si fue memorable para mi.
Seguiré ansiando ver mas trabajo de este ship.
Cet avis était-il utile?
IslandGirlIslandLife
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Maybe the ONLY BL that doesn't deserve a happy ending.
I went into this with low expectations and I'm glad I did. Because seriously, what the fuck was this? It started out so great with the whole who is Enchante plot, then the reveal and episodes 8-10 ruined the entire drama for me,What I loved:
Akk.
NO ONE deserves this man. He was loyal, loving, cute, looked like he carried the entire weight of the world on his shoulders but still had time to be the best boyfriend in BL history. Just too bad he had to suffer with ending up with a terrible partner.
The funny moments.
I'll give this show a pass because its funny moments were great thanks to Akk. (see how it always circled back to him?)
And this is the end of what was likable about this drama.
What I hated:
That fucking soft toned filter.
Theo.
He's possibly the worse character. He never apologized to Akk. He blamed him for not telling him about his parents' divorce (which wasn't for him to tell), and then for ghosting him, then to freaking up and LEAVE him and then lastly not even introducing Akk as his boyfriend to Sun. And just overall treating him like shit even though he did nothing wrong. Then there's also him acting like a literal child and trying to force his parents back together. Akk told him to respect their decision and he didn't.
The Plot.
The entire premise of this drama was stupid. It's basically a story about a man who returned to Thailand, did the most elaborate plot to basically get a love confession out of his best friend, to then UP AND LEAVE HIM. Who does that??
The Harem
This was quite possibly the worst harem that had ever "harem-ed". Three out of the four guys were problematic as hell and only one, which was the singer, who had no ill intentions, got roped into joining forces with Theo to deceive Akk.
The Reveal
I mean, if you think about it, Natee told us who Enchante was from the very beginning with all the portraits he painted. What they SHOULD'VE done, was just make Akk as the reveal, even though we know it would be the obvious choice. Kinda like how Fish Upon A Sky went and scratch the entire lying thing OR just showed Theo coming back and courting the guy.
The Ending
Ain't no FUCKING WAY, the writers should've made Akk be the one to make the trip and apologize. THEO should have done that. Akk did NOTHING wrong but love this dumbass. Maybe the one time I wanted a sad ending for this drama.
In conclusion, this could've been better, but they ruined it by giving us a TERRIBLE male lead.
Cet avis était-il utile?
bad premise
Nothing spoils an otherwise good production more than a bad story or plot line. The premise on this series was not really believable. It needed a lot more work so that it looked like a reasonable plot. It is a little difficult to find fault in the other factors of the production because the much depends on the story.The acting was fine - the characters were very easily likeable. The musical score was fine - nothing uplifting; but it was generally okay. Even the sets and art direction were good. But the story was bad.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Fui ver com expectativas baixas e adorei!
Uma série de conforto, se é assim que posso definir em poucas palavras. Um enredo leve com algumas deixas no final, mas com personagens bem interessantes e com um desenvolvimento que é o carro-chefe da série. Depois de me traumatizar com "A boss and a babe", não esperava que fosse realmente gostar dessa história aqui e eu tô surpresa com o quão boa a atuação do Force está. Espero que voltem a dar papéis goofy para ele no futuro. Akk virou um dos meus personagens favoritos de BL!Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Started good, but disappointed at the end...
I really went from - Wanna know who is Enchante -To- Forget it, Akk & Theo just get together instead of that lowkey flirting -To- Theo, you don’t deserve Akk at all. Theo really needed to know that the world doesn’t always revolve around him. It would've been good if they ended at Episode 8 or atleast given Theo some character development. For the first time ever I felt like I would be happier with a sad ending. It's a one-time watch, bcoz their acting is fabulous. And you got Akk, one of the best boyfriend to ever exist...Cet avis était-il utile?
I don´t really understand the "hate" this series gets :/
I mean like was it the best BL? Deffinitely NOT. Was it the worst? NO.Actually overall it´s pretty nice, cute series but there were some parts when i wanted it to end. Like seriously after around 6th episode I wanted to skip some parts but I still was really into it. I did skip something but just a few moments and nothing important.
The story was okay i guess..?
It was just quiet weird to see 5 men "liking" the same man (I am not saying it´s impossible) and just doing what they were doing.
I also didn´t really like the thing that they mentioned France and Enchanté like 1000 times lmao. Ofc nothing against France, it was just cringe and weird for me to hear it all the time. Yes i get it, the main character basically grew up there but still...
Acting was the best thing about this series ngl. It wasn´t perfct but it was good enough for me to feel something towards the characters. But one thing that i´m not sure about is, if we were supposed to hate the other 4 guys or not. Well if we were supposed to kinda like hate them, then I failed cuz I actually kidna liked the one who likes drawing ( ops :> ) .
Agh the music... Usually I don´t really pay much attention to music so I also didn´t do it here but after a few episodes it felt like they just play the same music over and over again and it was pretty annoying. It´s not such a big deal tho
Rewatch value is 4 because I think if I was really bored, I would watch it just for fun and good looking men and the one teacher ( she was gorgeous! ) lol. What I want to say is that I would still rather rewatch this than Kissable Lips ( thats was killing my braincells lol sorry if anyone geniouly likes it )
So yeah, like I said before, overall pretty decent series ( bonus: good looking people :> )
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
la gente credo voglia tropo dalla vita.
allora, io mi chiedo, perché la gente vuole troppo da alcuni drama? (questa sarà una recensione trasversale, nel senso che essendo un comportamento che ho notato anche per altri drama citerò anche quelli) questa storia non si presuppone nulla di complesso: due amici di lunga data si rincontrano dopo che uno dei due per varie (e un po’ vaghe) ragioni si trasferisce in Francia e da questo incontro nascono sentimenti, si scoprono le vere ragioni dietro ad alcuni comportamenti e alla fine tutto finisce bene (con Kudos alla comparsa del mio dottore preferito Jummy). fine, non è la trama più ricercata del mondo, ma non pone i presupposti per esserlo, un po’ come Star in my Mind e Hidden Agenda, non vogliono definirsi le nuove pietre miliari della storia del BL tailandese, quindi non comprendo perché la gente debba lamentarsi quando una serie non fa più di quello che aveva anticipato. ovviamente non tutte le serie possono essere come Not Me o Never Let Me Go o The Eclipse (o chi più ne ha più ne metta) quindi perché cercare in altre serie le caratteristiche di altre? sopratutto quando nessuno ha detto che queste serie le devono avere. perché ci può essere la serie più easy, come la serie più impegnata, la serie più spinta e quella meno, i gusti delle persone sono differenti e come credo sia giusto che ci debbano essere cose che possono appagarli tutti. ripeto, non a tutti possono piacere storie ambientate nel mondo della mafia, come non a tutti possono piacere quelle universitarie, e va bene perché siamo persone differenti. bene finita la mia tirata andiamo a vedere un po’ la storia: allora, come ho detto la trama non è nulla di troppo speciale, devo dire che ho apprezzato molto la “ricerca di Enchanté” proprio perché si sviluppa attorno a 4 persone che di facciata sembrano perfetti, ma che in realtà non lo sono. l’unica cosa che non mi è piaciuta della trama è la parte sul divorzio, io capisco che Theo sia un personaggio naive e che vive in un mondo di libri però devo dire non sono fan delle scene cringe dove si cerca di far rimettere assieme i genitori, ma questa sono sempre io. avrei preferito che la fine della serie coincidesse con la graduation di Theo e lui che decide, per una ragione o per l’altra di andare in Francia. Theo non è un personaggio perfetto e va bene perché noi non siamo perfetti e come veniamo cresciuti credo influisca sul nostro modo di vedere le cose. poi quel cucciolo di Akk, partendo dal presuppposto che si va ad aggiungere al pullman di green flag che ho visto in questi ultimi BL, come puoi stupirti se Theo si arrabbia se tu non gli hai detto che i suoi stanno divorziando? ecco questa è l’unica cosa che ho da ridire su di lui perché per il resto è la tipica green flag, carina e bellina e che nel finale decide di trasferirsi in Francia per il suo Theo, ma non solo (e questa è una delle cose che ho più apprezzato di lui). lui va in Francia sia per stare con Theo sia per il suo master, per avere più opportunità nel futuro, un po’ come Palm che decide di seguire il suo “one and only”, non solo per stargli vicino, ma anche perché vuole migliorarsi e migliorare le sue prospettive future, per meritarsi di stare accanto a una persona “importante” come Theo o Nueng. poi praise a tutti gli attori, tra cui Force e Book che sono fra i pochi pair di attori che vedo molto validi anche come amici. e uno direbbe “grazie al cocomero”, infatti. però molte volte nei friends to lovers la parte friends non è sottolineata per avere sostanzialmente due persone che si orbitano intorno e che si mandano sex eyes ogni dieci minuti. ecco Force e Book, forti molto probabilmente del fatto che sono amici da 16 anni rendono valida anche la parte iniziale dove sono amici (perché si Theo sapeva dei suoi sentimenti per Akk, ma non il contrario). poi il colpo di scena, checché ne dicano i più è vero che è abbastanza palese, ma è fatto bene e viene rivelato all’unica persona che doveva scoprirlo.overall quindi una serie carina, leggera (con un Fluke quasi nudo che esce da una pesca e un Jimmy sporadico nelle ultime due puntate) che merita di avere una possibilità.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Sweet BL
I almost didn’t watch this show because of all the bad reviews.What this drama is just a sweet romance.
I liked it because I don’t really enjoy BL that seems to either be soft porn, toxic relationships or focused on the ‘but I don’t want to be attracted to a guy’ thing. It lacks the trope of the over the top comedy trans students which I find so annoying.
Normally I’m pretty good at seeing how the plot would go but I had a couple of pleasant surprises. While the story could easily have stopped after episode 8 the rest was still pretty good.
Cet avis était-il utile?