Okay
Oh look it's Kim Tae Hee that every other drama keep referencing her as the beauty standard which to this day I don't understand why they keep drawing parallels to her specifically. Anyway, when it comes to inevitable death in drama I mostly prefer stories that take the terminal illness route over the "49 days" scam. Terminal illness stories can bring more raw emotions meanwhile 49-days stories lack in that regard, mainly because their death is an unchangeable fact regardless if the people associated with them moved on/still in pain/still mourning/still have regrets or not.It's still a "decent" drama, just like most of the other sad ones. They always work because we're silly little humans who like to sympathize. It's a lighter and more casual drama compared to others like it. Which is why there was less investment than usual in the characters and less focus on the characters that matter in general. This is clearly shown by how they attempted to prolong the drama, one example being the female lead started helping/observing other ghosts/spirits. Was that really needed? The lack of directional focus is its biggest problem. The concept of 49-days is a bit loose here, the concept itself seems to vague to the characters until it was told to them blatantly which is weird because isn't it part of Korean culture/tradition in funerals? Overall, not that good not that bad, just okay.
Cet avis était-il utile?
The ending, I should say is a really beautiful and realistic one. It never promises a happy go lucky ending since the beginning. It stays true and honest. A fantasy with a realistic take, how amazing and rare.
All of the casts’ are amazing and they have such an amazing chemistry!
What makes me rate this 1point short of the full star, is that we have different values on the concept of death. So at some moments, it felt overly romanticized.
Beautiful OST! The back sound was not really exceptional aside the OST, but it was befitting. Also, some scenes was so beautiful.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Masterful ...
What a lovely drama. I was not at all familiar with the FL or the ML, but I did recognize so many secondary characters. Yet, it was the actors who were new to me and who were the Main Leads who just blew me away in this drama. I just can't get over how unbelievably good they were.This drama had me crying every episode. The reviews I've read suggest I'm not alone in this. The longing and emotional intensity was so real, so evocative that it demanded that level of engagement.
(This is me nitpicking, but I really wish the FL had chosen the fact that her daughter loved her step mother immensely as the reason why she couldn't continue living as Seo-Woo's mom. I appreciate the whole "she'll keep seeing ghosts" angle, but it pales in comparison to how much her daughter had grown to love her stepmother and how much she would have suffered if Yu-ri had chose to be selfish and stay. MINOR POINT though)
So glad I watched this. It was so nice to watch a drama without a physical antagonist force (other than the exorcist I suppose). Not an evil force to be found. Lovely.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I knew from the very first time this drama would be a tearful-kind of drama, so I kept on avoiding watching this drama so I wouldn’t cry (since I’m such a crybaby ^^) But since my mom couldn’t stop nagging about the drama, so I watched it together with her. AND YES, I CRIED MY EYES OUT :’(I was able to hold in my tears on the first ten episodes, but couldn’t as soon as everybody knew Yu-ri was going to leave them again ㅠㅠ I’m bawling... This drama truly is inspiring and motivating, this drama taught me a lot of things: one, to never be selfish; two, to always cherish moments with your loved ones because you don’t know when would be the last time you see them; three, to always be grateful in life.
Their acting was spot on! The writers also did well, as well as the production team. Kudos to this wonderful and heartwarming drama. I’ll just pretend I didn’t see the negative feedbacks on this drama, because this drama was truly the most heartwarming, most inspiring, and most beautiful I’ve seen ❤️
9.5/10!⭐️
Cet avis était-il utile?
Brilliant series
Such a super good series with super excellent acting skills, they delivered all their emotions to me and made me feel every single tear drop came down their eyes , they were true in portraying the feeling of loss .Such a super good series with super excellent acting skills, they delivered all their emotions to me and made me feel every single tear drop came down their eyes , they were true in portraying the feeling of loss .
Such a super good series with super excellent acting skills, they delivered all their emotions to me and made me feel every single tear drop came down their eyes , they were true in portraying the feeling of loss .
Cet avis était-il utile?
First of all, the story is just so touching and heartbreaking at the same time. I didn't expect to cry so much while watcjing it but there I was, crying at every episode. After a couple episodes, I learned my lesson and brought tissues with me because I just knew I was going to cry a river at some point.
Although the story was really good ad the plot was a great idea, I found myself losing interest in the last couple episodes, I have a feeling they could of maybe made it into a 12 episodes instead of 16.
Every character just gives off different vibes, and they're all so important. Min Jung ... Her character is so gloomy and grey, I felt a lot of pity for her. Also I just found out the child was played by a little boy ? Impressive !
I'm going to be honest, I didn't really pay attention to the music, sure sometimes it set the mood but it's honestly not the most important thing I want to review haha
As for the rewatch value, I personally DO NOT want to rewatch it, the heartbreak I felt while watching it was enough one time, two times is going to legitimately kill me.
Do not forget, this is my opinion, and mine only, you cannot judge me for it and please do not attack me !
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Tears will be involved
I do not know if I'm in a part of my cycle that is making me emotional but actual tears started rolling down my cheeks from the halfway point of the drama (I'm not a crier while watching the drama btw)From the very begining you know that this will not end with happiness. The story made me constantly think of the people I love and the thought of what would happen to us in this situation is really what got me.
I have to commend the actors especially to the ones who playes yuri, gwang ha, and minjeong. They really carried the show and made me root for each of them.
A major theme of the show is clearly motherhood and I really liked that it was Yuri's mother's wish that brought her back.
That being said there was a lot that I had to skip, the side stories drag a little bit and there's an overabundance of side characters that you really don't care for.
All in all I'm glad I watched it.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Hard-hitting! Emotional! Relatable!
Hi Bye, Mama! completely made me doubt human nature, from having regrets, greed to forgiveness. the annoying part of the story is that all the characters appear to be nice. they are all written nice that throughout the watch, I don't know who to side with. Which also made me doubt my beliefs and understanding. And also with the point taken, I realized a very good excellent thing on Hi Bye Mama, and it was being the main character of your own life. Love that the drama, characters, are well-written imposing that everyone's story is important.One point is that it tackles a lot of stereotypes... in a very nice and acceptable way. Not all stepmoms are bad and they are also one's mothers as they can also love their children unconditionally, and about underdeveloped kids discriminated, and many more.
Realization hits hard when the title is Hi Bye Mama, knowing throughout the watch that it was supposed to mean with her daughter but in the finale... it was a message for her mother. That is so exceptional and I did not expect that to come. To quote this remarkable dialogue from ms midong.
"A woman who lost her husband is called a widow. A man who lost his wife is called a widower. A kid who lost his parents is called an orphan. But there's no word for a parent who lost their kid. Know why? It's because no word can describe it. There is no word in this world that can describe the excruciating pain" that is so hard-hitting and I remember this dialogue after realizing the other deeper meaning of the title, Hi Bye, Mama!
Overall i would def recommend watching this! as I know everyone can realize, can learn, a thing or two from how thoughtful the script, dialogues, and plots it brings
Cet avis était-il utile?
Sweet
It really deserves a higher rating,I love Cha Yu-ri personality in this drama. She want that her ex-husband is happy, even if she will be alone. Seo-woo is sugar-sweet too.
The story is really heartwarming. You really cry all the time in this drama. Right from the start, you are drawn into the world of Cha Yu-ri. There are numerous sad as well as funny incidents.
The quality of the drama is really good again, as you can see from the many locations that have been used.
In summary, a very good series, with a great cast and a great story.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Every mom should watch and enjoy this drama. My most favourite character is Yuri's mom. Though the ending is realistic it would be even better Min jong met someone who loves her and Yuri staying alive. Anyways I felt worth watching this emotional roller coaster.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Eu ignorei esse drama por algumas semanas depois de seu lançamento pensando que se tratava de mais um drama de romance com fantasmas. Eu nem consigo explicar o quão errada eu estava."Hi Bye, Mama" é aquele tipo de história que faz você se sentir com vontade de abraçar todas as pessoas que você se importa e dizer que as ama muito, e isso porque ele nos faz pensar como nós vivemos nossas vidas pensando que o nosso amanhã é garantido, mas isso infelizmente não é verdade.
Em uma visão geral e resumida em relação à produção, o elenco foi muito bem escolhido (com destaques para a Kim Tae Hee e Go Bo Gyeol que atuaram lindamente) e os personagens foram muito bem abordados, com algumas exceções, mas nada que tenha impacto suficiente para prejudicar na obra como um todo. A trilha sonora foi bem colocada e produzida e se encaixa perfeitamente nas cenas, porém, como uma pessoa que adora ouvir as OST's dos dramas para relembrar deles, eu não me apeguei à nenhuma em particular. Em relação ao enredo, o fluxo da história foi natural o suficiente, na minha opinião, para abordar tanto as cenas de comédia quanto as mais dramáticas e tristes e isso resultou em uma trama que te deixa mais familiarizado com os personagens abordados, que vão dos principais aos outros fantasmas (personagens mais secundários).
Mesmo abordando um tema extremamente delicado, a morte e como as pessoas lidam com ela, o drama foi perspicaz e, ao mesmo tempo, cauteloso na sua abordagem, nós mostrando o lado de quem fica e também de quem vai. Eu provavelmente estou tão apaixonada com essa historia, por ela extrair tão magnificamente a minha parte preferida das obras asiáticas, que é a visão de que amar não é lutar com tudo que tem para que seja correspondido e então feliz, e sim perceber que mesmo que tenha que fazer sacrifícios e se machucar no processo, você faria isso pela pessoa que ama, mesmo que isso signifique que você não possa mais ficar com ela.
(Essa foi a minha primeira resenha no MDL e eu peço desculpa por qualquer erro e se por acaso você não concordar com algo que foi dito, deixe um comentário, eu realmente adoro ouvir opiniões diferentes e entender como elas foram formuladas).
Muito obrigada pela leitura e até à próxima! o/
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
