Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
story is kind of irritating...
First few episodes were fine, progression was also fine not until the first half of the episodes (ep. 4). The tropes were problematic because some of it wasn't addressed properly; Second leads were fine but needed more screentime 'cause wdym no one else were homophobic except the main cast (characters they play) themselves...? What irritated me the most is the last few episodes, there was this particular scene where it was sooo problematic that it made me lose my interest in watching it. That scene where Taeyi quite literally s**ually ass*ulted Se Heon was NOT addressed properly AT ALL. I expected a redemption arc even if it was just for ONE episode but there was nothing. They acted like nothing happened... LITERALLY. That was the last straw for me. this had potential but putting serious issues like those and just making it seem like nothing happened was not it.Cet avis était-il utile?
jazz for... idk who i'm watching for anymore
this series was a bit... confusing? i'd say, at first i thought the plot was peculiar and interesting, something maybe light as usual from kbls, but then it takes a turn, which i'm thankful for in some sort of way, because it'd have been way boring! my mind went from oh, to Oh, to oh...and the last oh is a bad one.
i don't like the way south korean kbls have been using the same tools thai bls were using back then (romanticizing abuse, non con behavior, or bullying), so i wasn't pleased towards the end.
anyway, the actors did a good job and the piano music is chef's kiss but do read warnings before watching!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
As a For X, I feel like I have an obligation to watch this drama. It's Hangyeom's acting debut after all! Plus this drama has a pretty good blurb that makes me want to see what's going to unravel.Overall, I really enjoy the story! There is of course some things that made me scratch my head and feel like it could be better than this, but I'm not disappointed in what I've watched.
What I like:
- Jungha! You see, I never read the manhwa before so I never expected Juha to be a hell of a character. Jungha has a rather gentle face so it's really surprising to learn that his characters is like... that.
- The story. As I said, I really enjoy it. I don't know the technicality, about the pacing or whatnot, but it's really better than what I thought it would be. I guess given the work has longer airing time (30-40 minutes per episode??) so I think some of the main points of the plot can be elaborated pretty well.
- The cast! I think aside of Jungha, the other cast feels so perfect to the characters. Jinkwon to Seheon, Hogeun to Taeyi, and Hangyeom to Doyoon. A special note to Hangyeom tho, I also think it doesn't stray too far from what Hangyeom is like as far as I know him as an idol.
- The reveal of Taeyi and Seheon's brothers' relationship! Did that count as plot twist? Because I never really expected it to be that way. It added spices imo, although the resolution might look too easy?? I thought Taeyi would be angrier about it. But I guess at that point, Taeyi only wanted closure about what happened to his brother and won't bother to point fingers and blame whoever made the event happened. Idk.
- The music theme! Although I'm not super familiar with jazz, but the piano playing is really pleasant in my ear. I especially love the ensemble performance and their fall festival performance! Jazz for Two do sound really good!
- While I don't think Doyoon and Juha's relationship change is the best out there, but I kinda like it! It makes me wait for a second season hoping it would explore their relationship.
What I don't really like:
- Juha. Just... I can't relate to him and why he needs to be that mean to Taeyi, Seheon, and Doyoon. Especially Doyoon cause like you can see how smitten Doyoon to Juha ever since their first eye contact. But after a thing that happened in the locker room, I started to be like, "OK, at least you're showing a bit of development!"
- Not that I don't really like but... it's too surprising how Taeyi and Seheon's relationship dynamics changed. Like, the day before, Taeyi was REALLY mean to Seheon, but the next day he's really mellow and suddenly being a simp??? I guess he actually liked Seheon a lot but he's afraid of something. Like his own feelings, maybe? Since after a tragedy, he's pretty much stuck in the past and his feelings for Seheon was something entirely new.
- I also don't really like Juhee in the first two episodes of the drama. But my impression changed afterwards, especially after the karaoke event. Hopefully Juhee can find a better man :)
I want to end it by saying good job everyone who's involved in this production! Thank you for bringing out a story that I enjoy a lot. Especially Hangyeom, good job on your acting debut!!!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
disappointing,SA,physical abuse,rushed
first of all i would like to say that acting cast and music was good.Second last 2 epi felt rushed specially epi 7 where seheon get SA but next he forgive taeyi like it was nothing?!?!??like how can you forgive someone easily who just bullied,SA, physical abuse you throughout whole series.toxicity in this series is really concerning.About the second to be couple which got flopped dont have much to say but yeah "meh".Tbh i liked the kiss at the end which is not a deadfish kiss.And people who gave 10 ratings for this series needs a reality check.Sometime it felt like series on its own screaming homophobic.And my review was based on only watching the series and not reading manhwa so yeah overall it was "meh" not bad and not good either.Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
bamboozled
So cute until ep7., damn he gave me the ICK, man turned full on harassment mode. like what do you mean ur gonna be stuck knee deep in de Nile and TWO seconds later it’s like nothing happened.Also we don’t talk about the thing with the brother enough. He likes main dude cuz he reminds him of his brother? do we ever talk about it again? nope
SO rushed towards the end. It just makes no sense why they would rush over the most important a part of the plot like that.
The acting is not bad but not good. This boy won’t stop inhaling every time he says something . Once you notice it you can never go back
Cet avis était-il utile?
Tão fraca que não teve forças pra contar tudo.
Fui assistir essa série despretensiosamente, mas os primeiros capítulos foram acima da expectativa; e eu realmente estava esperando que fosse se tornar muito boa. Mas conforme o desenvolvimento, parece que a história começou a se perder cada vez mais e mais.Mas antes, vou citar os pontos que eu achei positivos nela. A premissa é interessante: ela consegue te prender no início da história e atiçar sua curiosidade para saber o que vai acontecer dali em diante; a atuação é boa, e acho que os atores conseguiram trabalhar muito bem no que foi entregue a eles; a música e a fotografia são decentes, mas nada que chame tanto a atenção.
A história tem alguns furos e muitas falhas no desenvolvimento. O protagonista é um pianista apaixonado por jazz, mas que vive com um pai muito exigente, restrito, e que desaprova que ele pratique qualquer outra coisa que não seja música clássica. Isso não é spoiler. Tudo isso nos é apresentado nos primeiros minutos da série, e é por muitos episódios uma GRANDE parte da trama principal; mas assim que ela deixa de ser conveniente pros roteiristas, ela é simplesmente descartada sem qualquer conclusão.
E acredite, falta de conclusão é o que não falta nela toda. Constantemente você vai receber muitas informações que vão começar a ser desenvolvidas, jogadas pra debaixo do tapete e depois completamente esquecidas. E dá pra entender que isso pode ser pela falta de tempo, já que não é uma série muito longa, mas se você não tem tempo para desenvolver tantas coisas diferentes assim, você simplesmente NÃO introduz elas.
E isso sem falar da passada de pano que os tópicos mais sensíveis recebem. No fim todos eles se resolvem com um belo "desculpa" e acabou o problema. Desenvolvimento dos personagens? Não teve. Consequências pelas atitudes deles? Adivinha: também não teve. Coesão? UAU, que inesperado, TAMBÉM NÃO TEVE.
Por fim, é uma história que consegue te entreter e que tinha um bom potencial; mas que conseguiu falhar em quase tudo que ela se propôs.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
BL & Jazz FTW !
I just finished this short series with a happy contented smile on my face.There are some shows that go on and on and you wish they would have cut them in half, but not this one. If I have any gripe it would be that I wished it was longer with way more jazz music shown.
There was great chemistry between the main leads and it would have been great to see this develop more deeply, same for the second couple. I think this 8 episode series only allowed time to skim over the surface of everything that was happening, both past and present, but that being said, it was still very well done.
The story was engaging and interesting, and an unusual take on the usual "BL in high school" shows we get.
It would have been great to see Seheon come to terms with his Father and play him some jazz on that beautiful Baby Grand!
Overall I loved this show and hope for a second season :)
Cet avis était-il utile?
Such a good Show!
This show was so good! and the Bl was so good i was so surprised with how good it was , i wasn’t expecting to really enjoy this the way i did! i totally recommend this if you’re into bl!! overall 10/10 show!! i would also def rewatch! the story is so good and interesting it just claws you right in!Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
pushing & pulling
i have never written a review before; spare me, but i felt the need to for this series.i believe this show is only for people who can deal with heavier topics and are able to understand characters flaws on a higher level. every single character in this series is complicated & it's not for the weak of hearts.
there are some scenes i felt were just straight-up unnecessary, but that never deterred me away from the show or the characters themselves. especially taeyi or juha; who are indeed more flawed than the rest. they could've written taeyi much better (then again, i am not familiar with the original media this is adapted from, so he could be just right) - and i wished they did, considering he's a likable character if you look at him through a good and understanding lens - some of the parts felt incomplete and lackluster, but it's certainly not trashy for what they had. (i believe a solid 12 , maybe even 10, episodes could've done them some good).
seheon was a well-written character! i liked how even in the very first episodes, he found himself wondering what was wrong with taeyi instead of just entirely thinking he's a bully of some sort. he's been through a lot, they all have. doyoon and juha were perfectly awful. i didn't have much interest in them until later episodes, but their dynamic and relationship is extremely interesting if you take internalized homophobia into the equation, because that's certainly what it felt like to me. not much to note; the storyline was interesting and actually made sense in the end. i like how it was history repeating itself. the main leads' chemistry was good, despite what anyone says, and i think seheon and taeyi make a nice couple after everything they've been through with each other. there wasn't a large amount of the second couple, but i hope they're swell. (i would like to see the main leads in another series together, maybe a softer one, that seems more up their alley).
overall, would i recommend it? to the right person, yes. if you don't enjoy hurt/comfort, messy up & down and even toxic relationships: this isn't for you. but there are plenty not like this, so go watch! ^^
Cet avis était-il utile?
A real waste of time
While the acting is not too bad, all of the characters and the storyline in general have been pissing me off.I am not even sure how you can like one of the characters, as all of their behaviors are not making any sense. I thought it would get better with time but it's actually getting worse and worse. I didn't manage to empathize with any of them even though I tried.
I really don't recommend it
Cet avis était-il utile?
It doesn't show any realistic but they were playing like they are filming a series.
It would be a wow if they act more naturally. And the kiss! They don't have add kissing scen if they're gonna kiss like that. They kiss scene are Duh!
I love the side actors better. I'd obviously not gonna rewatch this.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Glad 2 Know Jazz For Two^^
MUST WATCHH❕_____________________________
The KBL series is the best, providing an interesting storyline that makes the audience curious about the plot of each episode. Opens and ends with an interesting plot, I like it when Han Tae Yi plays a strong man and meets Yoon Se Heon Which is cute and adorable. All the roles played very well, in fact I think 8 episodes is not enough, there should be more episodes even if there could be a season 2! Hahahahah🙏🏻🫶🏻
Since KBL is still hot, let's enliven it so that hopefully season 2 can be made!!! Amenn
Cet avis était-il utile?