Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Up until now, I just cant decide whether the ending was good, bad, or null.But one that Im sure is that I DONT Like it.
Why bother to build up such storyline and characters on part 1 just to kill them off in such an out of context (from the story) way? just for a shake of darker story? well, guess what, its not! its a LAZY WRITING!
It just doesnt make sense how they turn young soo to a great villain of all Kdrama history in a blink of an eye. If they want to do that, do it in the right way with a proper build up story.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Warning for US Viewers
**Episode 9 deals with S.A. against one of the girls.**The ending of episode 10 involves situations that U.S. students and family deal with all too often... 😰
Overall, these last four episodes veer away from the previous six and not for the better. This feels like a completely different drama that rushed itself and didn't know how to end.
If I could, I wouldn't have watched these episodes at all. It had so much potential but fell flat. The resolution to the Alien problem gets resolved in a voice over. So, all these kids trauma & deaths were pointless in retrospect.
If you want to feel better - jump to the end of episode 10 for the happy stuff.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
AVOID WATCHING!!!
i think we all expected a really nice happy ,conclusitory ending but spoiler alert that never happened. This story didn't deserve this. We all expected the answers to our curiosities like "what were really the spheres", "where did they come from", "what do they want" etc. Season 1 was fantastic it was too good, i expected atleast a happy ending where atleast 5-7 of them survive, but that didn't happen.The sad thing is they could've made it better but didn't even try. The cast was too perfect and we all loved it. The ending was illogical and it was unsatisfying at most. I wish i never saw it because now i have a shitty mindset towards this amazing show. I wish they atleast showed how the cleanup process or where the parents were. If you really loved season 1 i would never recommend season 2 . I wish someone told me this.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
The Enraging Conclusion of Duty after school Part 2
I never thought I would find myself writing a review, but I just have to get this off my chest – the ending was absolutely infuriating! After witnessing the promising character development of each individual, it felt like a complete betrayal to have them all meet their demise at the hands of a psycho obsessed with CSAT. Part 1 started off so well; I'm left wondering why the writers decided to take such a dark turn. In the novel, I heard that many students survived, yet in the series, only four managed to make it out alive. While I'm relieved that my two favorite characters survived, it was completely unexpected and left me with mixed emotions. Despite my frustration with the ending, I must admit it was still a good watch overall.Cet avis était-il utile?
if you see negative reviews for part 2, it's only because of the sad and unreasonable ending.
I honestly don't know how to write a review, so obviously the reason I'm writing this is because this drama was SOO good I had to let my feelings out. The plot was well-rounded and the relationship the students had with each other was very admirable and just overall nice to see. There was never a moment where I felt bored watching this show. Like most captivating dramas, each episode would normally end with a cliff hanger to force the viewer to watch the next episode immediately - this drama didn't even need to this to be binge-worthy. Saying this, the show was split into 2 parts and both parts were equally good. This is quite literally because the show wasn't even near finished after part1, hence the part 2. It's almost like getting half way through Strong Women Bong-soon (or any kdrama lol) and not bothering to finish the rest. I must say, the ending was not the best (sad ending), but even with a bad ending, it wasn't enough to drag this show down in any way. SUCH A GOOD SHOW!!!!Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Im glad i watched it despite the unsatisfactory ending
I really enjoyed watching part 1. Part 2 was good until the ending. All the actors did really well! I especially liked how each character developed and became a team player. Despite the unsatisfactory ending the whole drama was great. Although i wished the writers /producers could have explained what happened to the sergeant wonbin since he clearly looked alive in part 1 ending and why didn't the monitor thingy detect anything at the hospital.Also i enjoyed the funny music video clip at then end that was really funny but sad at the same time.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
sometimes a predictable ending is better
part 1 (ep 1-6)i went in knowing nothing and finished ep 6 with very high expectations for any other drama in this same genre. its very stupid to make highschoolers train for war but its fiction so whatever. everything was really cool, the story line was unique and the acting was perfect. some characters were annoying throughout every episode but i had to cut them slack because yk a war, high school kids, a lot of fear and stress. when i finished it i had very high hopes that a certain someone would come back to life magically but i still didnt think it would affect too much the next episodes whether it happened or not.
part 2 (ep 7-10)
honestly i think the writers just didnt know how to wrap it up nicely. i feel like they lost track of the actual story line from part1 because suddenly the spheres werent the main issue anymore. the end was understandable but at the same time it didnt make sense??. in my opinion if they just wanted to kill everyone they shouldve let the spheres do it instead of turning it into the mess that mass killing was. i know it is a realistic consequence of giving kids gun and the stress and trauma of being part of something apocalyptic but bro if i wanted to see that i could just turn on the news because sadly theres a lot of news like that in my tv. and then the drama ended and we still dont know why the spheres were there, where they came from or anything. really disappointed but i got too attached to the characters to say harsh things
i would recommend it because it was really something good and different and i think everyone can make their own opinions and thoughts on their own. dont know if everyone would like it tho
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
It would have been my favorite drama if it wasn't for the ending ..
I actually really liked the first part that is why I watched this part , I was hoping for a great ending but unfortunately in my opinion they just ruined the show at the end1) I totally hated that they just removed KIM WON BIN from the show without saying a word we didn't even know what happened to him , cause his photo wasn't with the ones that died I thought that he might've gone back to the military camp but why not telling us beforehand ??? also why none of the students mentioned him again ??? even if he would have had a scene that was a flashback of someone it still would have been better , but him disappearing without a word was a big NO for me and because something like that I don't like time skips in shows ..
2) I knew that psycho YOUNG SOO was fishy from the start and I did expect him to do something bad , but him just turning into a monster just because some extra points in a day was so bad and rushed .
3) I really hated that ending , it is not because I hate sad endings , there are so many dramas I like that have sad endings but I hated the fact that they all died for nothing , like all of those build ups to make us love the characters just for them to die in the hand of psychopath that they treated as a friend ??? I would have accepted the ending if they would have died because of spheres cause it would have been more believable , after all that was what they were fighting .
that is why I like the 1st part so much more than the 2nd and I think they rushed it so much ..
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
the show was great but ending spoiled it.
i started watching thgis drama because my favourite genres are thriller typw dramas like of zombies and all so then part 1 was very nice but there also i didn't expect the ending to be cruel but then i thought part 2 would be having a better ending of the whole drama but all expections dropped down when i saw the last episode i didn't expect the writer to give such a dreadful ending to the soldiers . but afterall its just a drama i appreciate the hardwork of everyone in the drama only if they had made the ending different i would i have given a 10 but other then that it was good it includes thrill,suspense. so if you all can handle the pain you should really watch it but right now *i need a therapy*Cet avis était-il utile?
What the heck just happened ? so frigging unpredictable. very realistic apart from aliens aprt
This kdrama is the biggest plot twister show ever made. it caught me by complete surprise. I was SSOOO made at how everyone died but then I thought about it and understood. this is what war really does. Although they were fighting aliens its so bloody realistic. Like if aliens were to invade this is what will happen... except the part where the military magically got a weapon and destroyed all the spheres. that part was pure rubbish. But they way some of the characters and their emotions would get absolutely flopped and shattered was crazy realistic. the way many of the main characters were killed by their comrade and friend was perfectly portrayed. It traumatised me for a few minutes but this is what happens to selfish people who are weak in a situation like this... they get "subdued" under the situation their in. It reminds me of the shootings in the schools in the USA... I think the guy who shot all of his classmates was feeling like the a** ho*** who shoot up schools in the US. This show has a very good message hidden in it... Don't push adults business into children's lives and pressure them. Many parts of this drama part 1 and 2 pissed me off well, like the ending of part 1 where their captain stood smiling at the walls waiting to die in read of trying to find a way to stay alive... but overall its a good show that can relate to reality and weak a** morons like the guy who killed his mates at the end. So I don't know if I would recommend this to any1 becuz it's not for evry1. Few people will like it. But if u read this review to see if u shud watch it then know this... 100% unpredictable, and if u watch it then try to relate the show to reality and wat will really happen if aliens invaded. Then you might enjoy this show. But also know that some scenes are very bloody sad but they're worth it. SO IF UR LOOKING FOR SUNSHINE AND DAISYS THEN DONT WATCH THIS. THIS SHOW IS FOR PEOPLE WHO UNDERSTAND HOW WEAK, IDIOTIC AND BLIND PEOPLE ACT IN THE REAL WORLD.g'luck and happy binging✌️🖖
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I do not post reviews, however I just want to point out that from the POV of someone who has read the manhwa (the source material), the ending of part 2 is a little faithful to the ending in the manhwa with a few changes. In a sense, it is very understandable why the series ended that way. Moreover, most of the character deaths in the series is also faithful to he manhwa. Although the ending for the story is a little disappointing for me, I can't blame the writers since it is what happened in the manhwa. The only plotline I would've wanted the writers to explore and create new scenes in is about the subdued romantic storylines because I am a sucker for subtle romance in the middle of an action/fantasy setting.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Que fim foi este????
Alguém me explica porque é que tivemos todo um plot em volta das esferas para no final eles morrerem pelas mãos de um psicopata louco pelo CSAT? Eu queria mesmo compreender ele, mas passou dos limites no último ep.Para mim não fez sentido nenhum esta segunda parte, eu apercebi-me como foi tudo uma enrolação para nada. No final não nos explicaram porque é que as esferas apareceram, o Sargento Woon Bin desaparece e ninguém o menciona, parece que ele nunca existiu. A história cansativa de romance do Kim Chi que quer se confessar e no final das contas nunca o faz.
Quatro sobreviventes para no fim desaparecerem com eles também e nos deixarem num final vago, sem a porra de uma explicação e a fazer A PORRA DO CSAT !
Revoltou-me tanto que além deles terem passado por belas e boas durante a guerra, terem crescido como pessoas, quase na reta final são assassinados por um deles e não por uma esfera. O Il Ha teve uma morte patética! Foi uma das mortes que mais me irritou pois ele evoluiu como pessoa e eu agora gostava dele, para no final morrer assim.
A primeira parte frustrou-me em muitos aspetos pela teimosia e infantilidade dos alunos, mas estava aceitável e boa, mas esta segunda parte?? Assistimos 5 episódios em que várias partes era enrolação e conversa fiada, para ter este final...
Cet avis était-il utile?
