Decent reality TV with misogony issues
Loved to see all the different body types on the show, from slim track stars to SUPER beefy heavyweights! Female presenting were also on, and I was so excited until from the very first episode it is just constantly, deeply ingrained misogynistic attitudes. Matches with 1v1 were decent to see. I heard working through this show was dangerous and a few people got hurt, I noticed especially during a later episode it felt they were pushing themselves too hard. I got very worried for them!Im taking away points for not having precautions and better safety with over-working their bodies to the point of possible damage and the way the women were treated.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Physical & Mental Test That Felt Scripted
LIKES:For the most part production was good.
It was interesting to see the various occupations/sports that these fit people were part of.
The different body types did have a good range of people.
The competitions got better towards the end, especially for the last 5 standing.
The music was fitting for competitions and for the most part good.
I liked how even though only one person could win, that everyone encouraged each other to persevere.
DISLIKES:
Felt very scripted until the last two competitions.
The claim about gender and race equality, felt false due to: 1- the games themselves favouring certain body types and 2- because the other races that took part in it, felt thrown in to the mix and didn't have equal amounts of people as the obvious asian dominated participants.
I didn't like some of the competitions where it was done in teams that were chosen by participants. It would've been more interesting and fair, had they teams been picked randomly.
OVERALL:
If they bring a second season I would watch it, but can't be bothered to watch this one again. I did binge watch it. It was interesting and you could really feel the competition and emotion the players felt. If you ever want to know how a body builder would be able to compete against an athlete or military people, this is the show for you!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Super intense!! seneng deh nontonnya, walaupun adu kekuatan dengan berbagai jenis lomba -- dorong kapal 1 ton, gelantungan di tiang sampe angkat batu super gede tapi ngga ada drama-drama saling sindir khas reality show.
Justruuuuuuu, mereka ini saling support. Selalu bilang "gapapah, kamu udah berusaha" "kamu udah kerja keras hey!" Aren't we all to hear these words, huuh?
Suka banget beberapa peserta yang ngga cuma andelin fisik dan otot tapi juga otak alias strateginya manteeeep. Cho Sung Hoon bapaknya Sarang tetep favoritku!!
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
The Final Sucks
The final quest was really really disappointing because compared to the previous quests, it was very lacking. The previous quests all had a pretty hiqh budget and effort put into making it but the final one was just too boring. It was the episode that I skipped forward the most in the entire series.The final quest was also really unfair in terms of deciding the winner. It didnt felt like they were testing the participants for overall ability. Thats why I think the winner was not too fitting to become the last one to survive.
But other than that the contestants were pretty entertaining. It had a lot of people in different fields participating. That makes the interaction more interesting and fun overall to watch.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Good survival show! Though needs some improvements
Probably the best survival show I’ve seen Korea make yet! Winning was based on results, not by biased judges, predetermined results or judges wanting to see something “new” or “fresh” (looking at you dbo). There it was friendly competition, competitiveness but also encouragement.However there is a production bias of what the perfect/strongest body looks like and can achieve. Balance, speed,etc. (can’t recall all 5/6) were not represented nor did every contestant get tested in each category. Would watch a s2, but hopefully they’d make improvements.
“Finding the perfect body regardless of gender, age, race” my a**! They had 2 foreigners, 1 white and 1 black. Most of the people when looked up were in their 20s/30s. The oldest person, that we know of, was 48 Korean age. 23/100 (I think) were females and a lot of quests, especially those with instant elimination, catered toward bigger, bulkier build (AKA the guys). Body weight and teamwork that tests all aspects of the “perfect body” would be ideal.
A couple ideas of change: 1) It should be a ranking system, not elimination, if you want to find the most ideal body type because (sub)test could’ve had a different outcome if, for example, they did tile flipping and/or shuttle run before tug-of-war. If the producers want to keep a competitive edge then top #s get and advantage and/or bottom #s get a disadvantage. This way everyone has a chance to participate in an event and show their versatility, or lack of; 2) do the punishments rounds as round 1, letting people choose what they think they’d be best at, and therefore the best of each category moves on to the other quests; or 3) everything stays the same except no one is officially off the show right away- everyone gets 1-2 challenge cards that they can use at any point, before it’s down to top 3, where if they do better than someone in that event they swap places with the other competitor. Statues are smashed if you’ve used up all challenges or fail to get back into the competition before final 3; 4) either lower the prize money, be one gender, or if it’s going to be coed, any lifting (rock or statue) should be at least a % of average “strong” body weight for equity reasons - greed played a role in some people’s decisions, though it did give survival of the fittest at times, others it just didn’t make sense.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Interesting competition variety show, somehow felt like Squid Game minus the killing
It was interesting to watch 100 competing each other in terms of strengths. Although some parts felt repetitive, I really enjoyed the team games the most. The set is well-planned and it was very challenging even for me who's just an audience. I felt touched by some moments as well when I saw them persevere and go all in with their powers and energy even though it almost felt like against the odds.It was very inspiring and heartwarming to watch because they all have sportmanship which made it really meaningful to watch. I personally rooted for Choo SungHoon because I knew him from Return of Superman. He was indeed a Superman and despite his build, he's very softhearted, a good leader and a very strong man.
Overall vibes, I enjoyed watching it. The cliffhanger were the best because it made me binge-watch it overnight. I just felt like the hype already ended before the ending so it kind of felt meh. But still I recommend this show if you like watching survival shows. I learned a lot from them in terms of being mentally strong and not just being physically strong.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Disappointed on the quality of challanges
Top 100 contestants in Korea like pro mma fighters, olympic medalist, fitness influencers, bodybuilders, pro rugby players, real cop, real army and etc compete in simple games like run away with a ball and carry sandbags to a station for weight ins. Many flaws in the game, how can you put man vs women in a mud fight?? Are these only kind of games that the producers can think of? Low class. Are they're not embarrased to invite such a high level profile of contestant to compete such a simple games like this.?? Survivor or ninja warrior are way better, with just normal people competing. No need to invite high profile people in search for the top "physical" form crap. Very disappointed.Cet avis était-il utile?
