Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Very good but alas the ending is a different story
* SPOILERS ALERT *Like I said this drama is pretty amazing… until the last ep. For starters, the cinematography is wonderful, especially the scenes at the beach in the flashbacks (I wish I could live in a environment like that lol). The documentary-like format didn’t bother me too much. It was original and added a little something to a story that would have been maybe a little too plain without it. The only downside was the confusion it made me feel at times. I didn’t really understand how they could communicate with each other : I guess the producer/spoke person each time relayed to the others what one of them said ? I think there was an app or something like that too but yeah it was definitively confusing especially in the first episodes. Also, there was a scene that perplexed me a little in which Jae Won spoke directly to the camera then the focus widens and we see Eun Oh with Jae Won still in the background but there’s no cameraman with him. It was like the crew etc were invisible the whole time lol. But despite these little oddities the format grows on you and you learn to appreciate it.
I was also agreeably surprised when I realized there was a good amount of humor mixed with the more “realistic” vision of life and romance because I thought it would be kinda depressing considering the synopsis but not at all fortunately. I absolutely loved the bond between the 3 childhood friends and their interaction with everyone else. In fact I liked every character in this drama. All 3 “couples” were great together but they weren’t defined entirely by their romantic relationships (but bear in mind that romance is at the center of the drama). All the actors did an fantastic job and their chemistry was off the charts! I don’t want to spoil too much because the journey is what makes it really special. But if you want to watch this, just keep in mind that all of these characters have flaws. Their decisions sometimes doesn’t make sense at all but hey I don’t think that us viewers always choose the most logical decision in our lives. So that’s why I could relate to their problems even if it was a little frustrating to watch. There’s also a little redundancy that sometimes alter the pacing of the story but the cinematography makes up for it. I was just so amazed by the beautiful shots and beautiful actors/actresses that I didn’t really care in the end. The OST is also a big factor in making all of this work, I simply loved all of the songs and they were perfectly chosen.
* BIG BIG SPOILERS FOR THE ENDING *
Now for the final ep… I just didn’t understand. Why was there a sudden focus on the cop and his (childhood ?) best friend turned actress ?? Even tho I liked his character, there was no reason to add a love interest for him in the last ep. Like yeah they were kinda cute but I felt absolutely nothing watching them together. In fact I just wished the focus would shift again to Kyung Joon and Rin I. So many questions are left unanswered between them ! What was the letter written by KJ’s grandpa (or uncle I don’t remember exactly) ?? Why was it important ?? And who was the man who answered when KJ called Rin I ?? Are they really done when it seemed like they were so madly in love with each other ? Why did the writers decide to keep these things a secret when we were even shown how Eun Oh and Jae Won met each other in the past ? I thought for a moment about a possible season 2 but it doesn’t seem likely… That’s why I’m a little frustrated with the ending, it just felt different than the rest. Although I’m of course very happy our main couple is endgame and reassured about the fact that there’s still hope for Gun and Sun Young in the future.
To conclude it was still very good and I will give this drama a 9/10 for ep1-ep16 and a 7/10 for ep17. So for the entire drama maybe an 8,5/10 ? It seems fair because I still enjoyed the ride and the quality (production, music, actors) was overall exceptional. So watch this if you like flawed and realistic characters, amazing chemistry, tales of friendships and overcoming hardships and a very good amount of cute and swoon worthy moments.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Awesome
Awesome❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cet avis était-il utile?
It may not be a must-watch, but fans of the actors might still find it enjoyable.
As a fan of Kim Ji-won, I was aware of this series but hesitated to start watching due to the negative reviews it received. After seeing a few clips, I finally mustered the courage to give it a try. Now that I've seen it, I can understand the criticisms expressed in the reviews. The series is set up like a documentary, exploring love stories between multiple couples.While our main couple showcases great chemistry, I found the overall plot somewhat dull in certain areas. The pacing and storytelling didn't quite hold my interest as much as I had hoped. Despite these issues, the acting was impressive. The cast delivered strong performances that added depth to their characters and made the show worth watching. Although the direction and narrative might not be for everyone, the talent and effort of the actors shone through.
Cet avis était-il utile?
why am i watching this....
sorry but in my opinion, the story in this drama was a little weird and dragged out of control, the main reason i kept watching this was because of the actors. I enjoyed the storyline until the last episode like why suddenly give rise to new characters and new story? sorry to say, but everything about the story to me was very weird except the acting and the actors who managed to make me watch till the end, I regret my decision to watch this until the end. everyone should be grateful and say thank you especially to Ji Chang WookCet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
El guión me decepcionó
Empece a ver este drama, por Ji Chang Wook, y porque estaba en Netflix, después del primer capitulo, me pregunte si era yo la que no le preste la suficiente atención o era el drama que era muy confuso. Al final, entendí que la forma de contar esta historia no fue la mejor manera, una pregunta con diferentes respuestas de los personajes, hacían que perdiera el hilo de quien dijo que. Me costo conocer a cada personaje, no entendía nada. Para mi lo más caótico fue el principio. Nunca entendí quien filmaba? a quien se lo mostraban? Eso era lo que mas me confundía ya que no podía entender si ellos veían los videos no, o cuando si y cuando no. Eso hizo que de verdad pensara en dejarla muchas veces.Y las dos imperdonables de esta historia son:
- La historia de Seo Rin Yi y Choi Kyung Joon, la dejaron a la mitad, sin explicación, para que esperáramos otra temporada? no es justo.
- Y que dejaran para el ultimo capitulo una historia extra de personajes que nunca contaron nada de nada, en serio? no me hubiera molestado si la ponen en el penúltimo o antepenúltimo. Muy mala decisión, solo quería ver que paso con los personajes principales ya que era el último capítulo.
Sigo creyendo que si la hubieran contado de otra manera la hubiera amado, le vi potencial a la historia, solo por eso puse el 7.
Me cae muy bien Ji Chang Wook, pero no vería esto de nuevo.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
dropped for 2 months
Started this drama cause I was charmed by JCW, but past 5 episodes it was really difficult to move forward. The story seemed all over the place with 3 couples from the city, who are doing a reality show interview.Well, the drama concept and cinematography in the interview manner were quite good but it was extremely slow-paced.
Then watched ep 8 and was so annoyed that I dropped it for 2 months. I was so angry over Lee Eun Oh, she was a messed up character and didn’t know what she was doing. And ultimately the joke she played in the past is the core of the whole story that annoyed me even more. all the characters are into some misunderstanding which leads them to break up, but they DON'T TALK. a relationship is healthy when you clear misunderstanding if any of the partners are uncomfortable or have any issues. they have a silent breakup and the other person keeps on wondering where is the problem. WHY can't they have a healthy breakup, they are not kids, they are working adults but their behavior is so mehh
I picked it up again to finish this off my CW, because of JCW and Choi Min Ho. Yeah CMH was a surprise and helped in getting this through. and I liked that he also got his share of the story in the last episode.
Overall it is an OK watch, but I won't recommend it, cause all the characters don’t have an answer to why they are doing it. They were all messed up.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Enjoyable story with great acting and an interesting look into relationships
Good story with range. Loved the emotional exploration of love, trust, identity, and relationships. Even more so just the character development that the two main characters had throughout the show. The two main characters grew tremendously throughout the show, although it becomes more apparent in the second half of the show once the introduction of the backstory is complete. The comedic timing and look into friendship just made it even more fun to watch.My only qualm is that most of the story was focused on the center couple and the short 30-40 minute episodes. This left the other 4 main characters as mainly plot devices (for at least the first half of the show) with hints of depth we saw from time to time. The last few episodes seemed to foreshadow that there would be more episodes/seasons, and I hope so, because if not those characters were really just not explored enough. Overall great acting from the two leads (who really contributed to the high score) and an interesting insight into relationships with all the expectations, joy, growth, and loss that they bring.
I would say if you are doubting it, just watch the first few episodes and try it. The episodes are short and easy to watch a couple to see how it feels for you.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Sixteen-Seventeenths of this show is brilliant
I am really not sure why this show has such low ratings, as it was really enjoyable to watch. The plot was simple, but still unique and very fun to watch. There are two timelines, as part of this show is a flashback of events, and those are some of the cutest scenes I have ever witnessed. A lot of this show makes you feel good and warm inside, so a big plus. The thing that makes this show stand out is it's format. It is a mockumentary, and some people do not seem to like it, but it was done well in my opinion. Characters were in a pretend documentary of their life, and it was good because it was a clever way to show each person's perspective on the events that happened. In reality, most of Lovestruck in the City was shot like any other show, and the interview parts were really only there when they needed to be there when it helped the show.This may sound weird but DO NOT WATCH EPISODE 17. Without any spoilers, that episode is not necessary one bit, and it was just infuriating to watch. Episode 16 is the real finale of this show, nothing else happens in episode 17. So if you do choose to watch episode 17, then just consider it a bonus episode after the finale, which was episode 16. This show was honestly perfect, and destined for a 10/10 (I have never given a show a 10 so I do not take this lightly), however the ending was just so frustrating, so a 9.5 is necessary.
This show was overall so great to watch, and I was addicted. The episodes are shorter (only half an hour), so it is perfect to binge. Some people say they got bored, but I was fully invested every minute so to each its own. I would say to give this show a shot, watch the first episode or two, they are short, and if you like it then stick with it. Also the music was great, both English and Korean songs were featured, so an overall great show with a fittingly great OST.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Apaixonada assistindo
Eu juro que estava esperando um drama super Clichê! Fiquei muito surpresa com atuação de todos e todo o formato do drama comum documentário ficou excepcional. No início mostrou toda a felicidade do casal e mais pra metade e pro final todo o desenrolar que dá até descobrir a real situação de ambos. Fiquei muito feliz com atuação de todos super convincentes tudo muito real. Hoje lemas da vida, as brigas, Os encontros e desencontros, e as traições, à procura de emprego: com decepções e sucesso, tudo isso em 17 episódios que ficam sempre com gosto de quero mais uma transição entre episódios realmente jamais vista. A fotografia é maravilhosa! A trilha sonora eletrizante! Não deixou o clichês! Indico que assista!!Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Loved it if there weren't secondary characters...
I like this kind of dramas. With flashbacks, different ways of approaching a theme ( the interviews, the thought that everyone could know what the others were saying, etc... Even if some parts of the plot weren't very coherent to me).I enjoy the relationship between the ML and FL. I know some people use always the thought " if it was me...". But the problem is that everyone is different and I don't judge anyone by their actions. There are always reasons for that.
In this drama I think that there are reasons for the way the ML and FL act. And when we talk about love, specially in a two wonderful months with beach, sand, surf, love and passion I think every stupid gesture is acceptable... At least, for me, even the most reasonable person can't act the same when love.
PLOT - the story makes sense and it is well tie together. The reasons she went to Yangyang, why she behaved like that, etc. The same with him. The relationship between the two, the "breakup", etc
But I think that some things are strange for me. But I am not Asian, I have an occidental way of thinking. That is why, for me, being in love for ages without saying, without kissing, etc makes me wondering how Koreans behave when in love! Or maybe K Dramas don't show what is really happening...
But I can understand how the writers constructed the FL and ML personalities, even if I think they are exaggerated. My BIGGEST PROBLEM is with the supporting cast. I like everyone of them but cannot understand the way the writers portrait their relationships.
Two interesting couples, 4 persons that can't speak with the partner and the breakup reasons seems so wrong. Specially the PE teacher and the writer... And because 3 of them were great friends... Can't a friend give support and some advise? I don't get why the writers didn't close their stories.
What was the purpose of the policeman and the actress?? Another unclosed story?!?!
ACTING - love all of them.
OST - Like some songs and it was well incorporated in the scenes
REWATCH - The main couple yes. I like happy endings and that was one. The others, ALL the others were unhappy and I don't get what was the reason...
I like the interaction of the main couple, of the friendship relation, but only the main couple make some sense. The others... Why they were part of the drama?? Just to support the main story? Don't get it.
Maybe tomorrow I would have writen something completely different ( almost like Monty python's) but the feelings will be the same...
And maybe, if English was my language, I could write a better review.
Summing up...
1 I Like the way they present the drama.
2 liked the main leads romance, if it was for them I would advise to watch it!!
3 didn't like none of the endings of the secondary characters
Cet avis était-il utile?
Never again interview drama. It was baaaaaad
YES I MADE IT! I made my husband to watch the k-drama with me 💙 pity that the drama was not so good as I was hoping for. There was so much hype in the Internet about Love struck in the city but now as I saw it, I can't imagine why.Drama is pretty chaotic and basicaly boring. The last episode is pulled from outer space and doesn't fit in with the rest of the show. 👎 I was really dissapointed in my choice because it took me quite a long time to convince my husband to see any Korean drama with me and when he finally decided to enter my world, this happens. I thought (and hoped) Love struck in the city will be something interesting to see .... 🙈 Little did I know ....
My main problem with the drama were the script. I totally hate how they executed it. The storyline was bearly progressing and it was tiring to go constantly back and forth with their history 😤 Jae Won and Eun O were the main characters but their story could have been said in maybe 6-8 episodes. All the rest should have been given to other 2 couples: Choi Kyeong-Jun & Suh Rin-I and Oh Seon-Yeong & Kang Geon.
The second problem was the characters. They drove me nuts! 😵 Jae Won spent most the drama as a complete mess and lunatic with alcohol problem. Eun O knew what to do but still she didn't do anything. These two dragged the show on forever with their complaining, and as much as I like Ji Chang-Wok as an actor, this show with him is BAD 😥 Rin Yi's character wasn't developed enough but the way they created her was odd. Gyung Joon was so blindly in love her that wasn't much supportive. Sun Young was my favourite character, she was purely searching for love and acceptance but in the same time was petrified of being hurt.
Third problem, and for me the biggest, the interview format. I don't know who thought that this format of drama would be something cool 😠 This is a fairly short review for a 17 episode drama which I did not like. Engaging synopsis fast changes into weird drama to which you gradually lose interest in 😐 Unfortunately, I can't recommend it to you because you will die of boredom.
Cet avis était-il utile?