Abandonné 20/24
Nelly
4 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
nov. 13, 2022
20 épisodes vus sur 24
Abandonné 0
Globalement 7.0
Histoire 7.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Musique 8.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 5.0

Frustrating

OVERALL
Now, I might be in the minority, but this drama felt like a waste of time to me. Watch it if 1) you like the impossible love trope, 2) you like the main actors, 3) you like slow and uneventful dramas. If that doesn't sound like you, then skip.

THE STORY
So. Let me just say that when I started this drama, I was really hyped. Female Lead was not my cup of tea (she's basically a waif), but I liked the aesthetics of the drama, I LOVED how Male Lead wasn't the typical mean, arrogant and misogynistic guy, and I saw potential between the two. Unfortunately, the drama failed to deliver. To me, it felt like the series was on hold for about 10-15 episodes. It's not like nothing REALLY happens. People come and go, there are wars and conflicts, conversations, confessions. But it's pretty clear that the drama is about Male Lead and Female Lead's romance, and the thing is, after they both realize their feelings for one another, nothing DOES happen between them for episodes on end. It's just them suffering in silence and reiterating again, and again, and AGAIN, how they can't be together. I'm sure it's some people's type of plot. I prefer mine to move along and not stagnate. After episode 20, I skipped ahead to see if it was worth continuing, saw that it wasn't, and gave up.

THE ACTING
Ok.

THE MUSIC
Pretty good!

REWATCH VALUE
Null.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Anonymouslawstudent
9 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
sept. 2, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 5.5
Histoire 7.0
Acting/Cast 7.0
Musique 4.0
Degrés de Re-visionnage 4.5
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

Did not satisfy the expectations I had.

Where to begin. As seen in the title, this drama just didn’t act to the expectations I had. This is my personal take on this show, If you disagree then feel free not to continue reading and let’s open an area of friendly discussion instead :)

I m here, for Bai lu. Of course? Don’t get me started. She was extremely talented. I usually see her acting in strong domineering brave characters that knows martial arts but in this case she was more docile innocent pure and gentle. She was adorable! Very pretty, really among the few actresses out there that can make historical outwear work.

But she has this unexplainable stance when she is with you. Like she looks like a badass heroine that is ready to take on the bad guys with her sword based on her look. But in this case there’s not so much of that.

She was brave and smart and devoted in a different way. Okok we know she’s great so let’s move on to the rest. The male lead, was rather decent. I have not seen him in much dramas yet but he really suits these historical dramas but not so much for modern drama.

The second male lead, Is only 19 but his acting and look are promising so I ll leave it as that.

The story is about love, politics, betrayal, deception, loyalty things like that. I mean the young girl growing up to be a beautiful lady and is actually in love with her so called mentor but forbidden to be together like swoon worthy? However, this potential of a love story didn’t really Shine through. There isn’t much steaminess and sauciness that makes us feel like we re on clouds.

So that’s why I wasn’t all the way supporting the main couple. Sure they love each other but it wasn’t truly shown? Like the dude should have fought for her and the fact that commuting suicide for love is apparent in this drama can be seen as appalling but I shall keep an open mind.

There’s no kiss, nothing like that. Which is disappointing because I mean a kiss kiss is something so basic to show the viewers that the love that they have for one another is now bound for forever. The note he gave because he dies didn’t even I love you or something like..... he just let her be married and act all sad about it on the outside.

During the last few episodes, feel like grabbing the collars of the director and writers to slap them. BECAUSE LIKE WHY???? I mean I am looking for something different of a plot twist in shows but my Gosh this is too much.

The casting is a little questioning I mean the male lead has a son and the second male is close to a minor. But no discrimination about age and married people. Just something to bear in mind.

So the acting sure was alright. Story has potential but actual overall disappointing didn’t meet my expectations. I did skimmed through because of this.

Please watch it for yourself if you disagree with whatever I am saying.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
En cours 24/24
Hovaxu
3 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
août 20, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
En cours 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 9.5
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 9.0
Degrés de Re-visionnage 9.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

A love story continues to living on.

I have been waiting for this drama for a while and once it is released, I’m so excited. I have to say that its quality did not fail me. Thanks to Allen Ren and Bailu, they portrait their characters so well and even though there are not much kinship but you can feel their chemistry is firing. Their eyes when they look at each other’s already tells everyone that they are deeply deeply in love.
The cinematography, the costumes are spot on.
This is a prequel to “Forever and Ever” which setting is in modern time. In the novel, their past story is really short and based on female lead memories but then when they made dramas, they made into two parts, past and modern time.
Please do not hesitate to watch it regardless of the ending because as it said, it’s not the ending yet.. their love continues on to modern time.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
random player
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
sept. 14, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

One of the best cdrama

i will make this short and simple, i'd been a cdrama addict since 2019, watching this drama even with sad ending still makes this drama in my top 3 best drama i ever watched. i hope it will be happy ending in the sequel. the cast, production, story, ost were all perfect. i know bai lu is so talented but this performance is superb specially the scene where she cried when she knew zsc died even in the bts of that scene i can feel the emotion she act. kudos to all the staff who work for this masterpiece drama.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Drama Addict
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
mai 23, 2022
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 8.0
Histoire 6.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 8.0
Degrés de Re-visionnage 6.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

It's a pretty dark ending

If you have depression, do not watch this drama. The ending is very dark: no couples are eventually happy, the country is thrown into chaos and yet another child emperor ascends the throne.

On a positive note, the support cast is good looking and does a very good job. There are some good music pieces.

I come across a lot of positive reviews of this drama but I think it is mainly because of Bai Lu and Ren Jia Lun, the current popular heartthrobs. The chemistry between the leads is excellent.

For most part of the drama, it is the romance between Cui ShiYi (Bai Lu) and Zhou ShengChen (Ren JiaLun), so there are a lot of building up of their romance and emotions. It is mainly all the lovey-dovey moment - loving each other and could not express and having to hold back, each with their constraints. If you are not into these, it is also very slow moving. Battle scenes are quite lacklustre as these are just secondary.

There are a lot of comments that the story is great but I differ in my opinion. I say the production and directing are great as it brings out a lot of emotions - if the ending is that dark, with good directing it is hard not for anyone to cry although I did not.

The story is rather strange and rather unrealistic. And here are why I say that:

1. Minister Cui Guang supported the child emperor to the throne expecting his niece Cui Shi Yi to become the next empress only to find to his horror that the new Empress Dowager has other plans - to keep her as crown princess by appointing the child emperor's elder cousin as crown prince. She has become the fiancee of the new crown prince instead. Unless this story is not of Chinese background but of some minority tribe - passing a fiancée to a cousin is hardly acceptable in Chinese culture much less appointing an elder to become a successor. But with a surname Liu, it is implying the Chinese Han dynasty. And why appoint an older successor - just to avoid marrying the mute Cui ShiYi?

2. Minister Cui then requests for Prince Zhou Sheng Chen to become his niece Shifu (teacher). Again very weird: pushing a young girl into the care of a bachelor prince although he might have vowed to stay single and not to have children. Perhaps for the protection of the Prince for the Cui family?

3. Prince Zhou stubbornly refuses to leave the entrapment when the conspirators uses the Liu royal family and court as hostages. Why would a general with a peerless track record of success on the battlefield be suddenly so stupidly bigoted. His military advisor arrives in time to save him. If his advisor is smart enough to come to the rescue, surely Zhou knows better to leave at the urge of his own team and his hostages. Eventually the hostages are massacred and he dies of torture. Why would a big 'killer' be so easily swayed especially since these hostages are not close to him? I expect him to be a better strategist.

4. When someone important jumps from the city tower, why do the soldiers not try to help but instead concentrate on driving helpers away.

These are all important turning points in the story. The development of the story is not naturally and is very obviously to dramatise. All movies and dramas dramatises, but there is a difference between doing it realistically or creating obvious conveniences, and this story sounds more like the latter - it needs great skills to do that realistically.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
VrindaAV
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
févr. 16, 2023
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 9.5
Histoire 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 9.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 9.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

Very beautiful tragic story

Oh how i love beautiful story where both know that the other person loves them so much without explicitly confessing to each other.. love which is not shown by affectionate words but shown by actions and their eyes speak louder than words that people surrounding feel it too.

What i liked
1.All characters and actors did a great job. ML and FL had such great chemistry without much physical affection.
2.ML character sticking to his traits till the end. He is not perfect. he could have done more for the palace and for himself instead of running away from it. But still he knows he is good at fighting and leading soldiers that way protecting people and does not waver from that responsibility. He is kind and cares for everyone around him. His love for FL you can see in his eyes.
I have seen too many shows where ML forgets his responsibility once he falls for FL and just shuns it at the end. For once i see ML decides to let go of his love for larger good. People might think he is spineless but that requires more guts than leaving his responsibility and run away. And Kudos to Allen for portraying a dignified person perfectly. I have seen so many actors who are either cold with arrogant face and then so soft as if the whole character changed but Allen shows just right amount of emotions required. Even small gestures are so in line with his character.
3. I loved FL character too although most people (Viki comments were filled with it ) thought she is useless.But considering the times where the story set in i found her character close to reality. I love rebellious FL once in a while in historic shows but able to fight with swords is not the only way of being brave or having strength. She was also kind and brave in her own way. If people are timid it doesnt mean they are useless!!
4. Ending I can say i am in peace with ending bcs they both die. I am fine if both die but i cannot handle if one of them have to live or one of them gets married to someone else and suffers. Atleast they both found peace together we can say.

What could be better
Show more on what exactly she learnt from her master. it was never clearly shown. she definitely didnt learn war tactics or fighting. Just mention of music and painting. If only they showed that equation between ML and FL it would resonate more with viewers
Some of the places it looked like some scenes were disconnected as such. Screenplay could have been better .
And Sheer injustice ML and FL till the end of their life. Justice was never served to them even if they united lifetimes after but thats LIFE so not much complain there

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
kittychasingdramas
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
sept. 12, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

The most tragic show I’ve committed to watching

I never (knowingly) watch shows with a sad ending. I did this time round, as I heard that this was just the prequel to their happy ending in “forever and ever” so I just had to bite my teeth and get through this…

2021 has really been serving us top titles, I wasn’t expecting one and only to make it to my “review list” but it hit me (or stabbed me) in the feels umpteen times, tragic feels like an understatement. I must pour my heart out in this review! Our lead’s relationship was destined from the start till end and the show saw us through that in 24 episodes which felt just about right since this isn’t really the main story.

SY was sent to be ZSC’s disciple and watching SY’s transformation over the years under his care was very gratifying. Of course, she also found a new family and they aided her journey towards healing. This show speaks volumes of loyalty — loyalty towards the country, family, comrades and even promises made.

ZSC and SY’s chemistry was one that could be felt even without skin ship - case in point, they barely touched each other but you can grasp their relationship through the screen. Props to both for a stellar performance! I gotta say, this is Bailu’s best work so far in my opinion. Unpopular opinion but I never found her acting to be particularly great, but this really proved me wrong. She translated her emotions without words (iykyk) and in a couple of heart wrenching scenes… her silence was deafening and my heart broke for her in that silence.

My only regret is watching this too soon. At this point of review, only 1/3 of “forever and always” has aired… now I will have to wait a full month for their happy ending :(

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Cas3innitrate
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
oct. 7, 2024
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 9.0
Histoire 9.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Musique 8.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 8.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

SHOULD HAVE STAYED CURIOUS.

I haven't cried this much in...ever.

I don't think I'll heal or move on from this.

This is what happens when you stumble across the sequel and then get lured into watching the first, I had no business watching this after watching Forever and Ever.

This is your only warning. STAY CURIOUS PEOPLE. I wouldn't rewatch it if you paid me, hence the less than perfect score.

My therapist will be hearing about this.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
mountwudang
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
mars 28, 2023
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 9.0
Histoire 8.0
Acting/Cast 8.5
Musique 8.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 8.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers

A slow burn romance that makes your heart tingle

This is one of those rare dramas that I re-watched despite the sad ending (already known beforehand because it's adapted from a famous Chinese novel).

I recommend it because:-
(1) The leads are a relief for tired souls. Who doesn't like eye candies in dramas? As usual, Allen Ren looks gorgeous in costume dramas. He makes a good CP with Bai Lu here.
(2) The cinematography and designs are outstanding, gives you a sense of "ancient" - the attention to details such as the furniture , books, costumes, surroundings, etc takes you out of daily life's troubles/headaches.
(3) The OST is enjoyable, some of the best for 2022.
(4) The romance is slow burn, but romantic. No passionate kisses or bed scenes, but the director presents it in such a way that you feel warmth and good about the love story. I always believe that you don't need idol-like romance if it is well-carried out i.e. the top acting. A longing glance here, a smile there, the intensity in the eyes, many stolen moments....aren't they more exciting than the usual "straight romance"? The leads did a very good job here.
(5) The plot is well-carried out - i.e. the palace machinations, irritating scheming and politics are kept to a minimum, just enough to give the background to the story. No overdose of second or third leads either. It's all about the ill-fated romance between the leads.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
odetodramas
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
oct. 10, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 7.0
Histoire 7.0
Acting/Cast 9.5
Musique 8.5
Degrés de Re-visionnage 3.0
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I was so intrigued by the idea of One and Only & Forever and Ever being a two-part drama with one set in historical times and one set in modern day. This review will only refer to One and Only on its own!

It took some time for me to warm up to this drama because of the pacing in the very beginning. Shi Yi (Bai Lu) becomes Zhousheng Chen's (Ren Jia Lun) student when she's in her teenage years, and from the beginning she has a moony-eyed crush on him. This is totally understandable because Zhousheng Chen is intelligent, poised, considerate, an excellent general, and of course, he's handsome. (Ren Jia Lun really looks great in this role!) The drama skims over these initial years so quickly and makes me wonder, what did Shi Yi even do during these years? Did she learn anything as his student?! Bai Lu does an excellent job conveying her adoration of Zhousheng Chen from the beginning, which is exactly what annoyed me because it never felt like a student-shifu relationship. It's more like she entered his manor and he took care of her...

Anyways, I didn't drop this after the first 3-4 episodes because of the crown prince Liu Zi Xing (played by Wang Xing Yue, who is only 19! I'll definitely be looking out for his future dramas). Liu Zi Xing is such an interesting character because he's trapped in the palace with little hope of actually becoming the future emperor. An engagement was long arranged for him and Shi Yi, and he falls in love with her just from gazing at her portrait--she's a light at the end of the tunnel for him, something precious to look forward to since he's treated poorly in the palace. But of course, Shi Yi isn't just a portrait, she's a human being with different feelings about their engagement. Although perhaps I wanted him to become a more likable character, his storyline is very fitting, because he's someone who gets in over his head.

It was around episode 9, when the battle takes place, that One and Only finally hooked me. Things escalated quickly, and it's the storylines of all the other characters that I found intriguing. There's Shi Yi's cousin and General Hong, which was honestly my favorite pairing of the series. Their scenes together were so memorable and heartwrenching. I loved the other generals under Zhousheng Chen, too--Feng Qiao, Xie Yun, Zhou Tian Xing. They were all so lovable! And of course, the runaway prince/monk was my favorite. I loved the scenes in which he gave Zhousheng Chen advice, and saw right through his true feelings. I also loved Shi Yi's mother and how brave and intelligent she was. It's because I loved these characters so much that I was motivated to keep watching and I'm sad that they don't return in Forever and Ever.

As for the villains and the political scheming, I don't always enjoy this part of historical dramas but I thought it was well-done here. There wasn't *too* much screentime for this aspect of the drama, but enough that it kept tension and suspense high. The Empress Dowager was a real piece of work, and I shook my head at her son.

I wasn't expecting to see Daisy Dai in this drama but I liked her character and wish she'd had a bigger role. (Why doesn't Daisy Dai get bigger roles?!) Another surprise was Han Cheng Yu, who I liked in Love and Redemption and really does a great job with characters that are a little quirky.

Thankfully this drama is only 24 episodes and the entire cast was excellent, or I would've dropped it!

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Crazy about Asian dramas
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
avril 18, 2022
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

Sad ending but story was so good and emotional

First time I like to write first about acting . Too good really too good . All disciples acting were too good .they acted so naturally that I cried . It looked like that something happening in real and I am helplessly watching it . Last few episodes were so touchy that I can't help to stop my tears . I never want to see somei bad happening to good people in real as well in reel life .
After doing so much ill what Liu Zi Xing got ,he himself knew that he will die in three years but his selfishness not only destroyed him but also the ones he loved . Power really makes people blind .
Empress just to have power killed her own son . By watching few episodes I felt that first time emperor had no jealousy towards his uncle or hatred that he one day take his throne insist this he blindly trust his uncle but the emperor's mother in greed of power killed her own son . And what she got in return a terrible death. She tangled in her trap .
Story was good though I was waiting to see their chemistry ,their love story to start ,waiting to see them together but nothing happened like that which disappointed me .
First time it had happened that I like the story which didn't have happy ending and love story .
Really story was good . I already written about the acting of supporting characters but the main leads are main lead ultimate acting both male and female lead.
Ren Jia Lun's acting was too amazing . I love to see his acting.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Complété
Ninja WK
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
sept. 21, 2021
24 épisodes vus sur 24
Complété 0
Globalement 10
Histoire 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musique 10
Degrés de Re-visionnage 10

Absolute Masterpiece

Everything is perfect. I'm not going to spoil it for you, but I'm definitely going to rewatch this series again after the end of "Forever and Ever".

The main leads' acting and chemistry - simply put it, MESMERIZING, absolutely believable.

Cinematography, sceneries, etc. made to perfection.

For those who understand Mandarin, the language used, is very formal, as compared to the sequel "Forever and Ever", which is a lot more casual. The sceneries and palace shots, etc are way better, more beautiful than in the sequel, too.

This drama is an instant classic, although I'd have hoped for a different ending, not to spoil it. I didn't cry/drown my eyes like many other viewers, but I really felt the love and the pain throughout the drama.

This is easily my top 3 favorite dramas of all time, possibly my all-time #1 too.

It's a must watch.

Lire davantage

Cet avis était-il utile?
Love Your Bones Forever 2 (2021) poster

Renseignements

Statistiques

  • Score: 8.6 (marqué par 8,699 utilisateurs)
  • Classé: #329
  • Popularité: #758
  • Téléspectateurs: 22,435

Top Contributeurs

68 éditions
61 éditions
47 éditions
47 éditions

Listes populaires

Listes apparentées d'autres utilisateurs
All Time Favorite Dramas
719 titles 1817 loves 35
Chinese Historical Drama
417 titles 600 loves 5
Causes Ugly Crying /Heartbreaking
343 titles 564 loves 40

Récemment vu par