Cet avis était-il utile?
This drama is one of the best dramas I have ever seen. It is best recommended for who likes melodrama and an emotional drama.
Finally, about the music, it's amazingly superb. It is one of the heart touching romantic drama that attracts every age group.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Well portrayed feels without words. Joon hee made me go all the way towards end.
Screenplay was superb, that sometimes even without dialogues you could not fast forward and watch the scenes(first 7-8 episodes). The storyline is about a woman in her late 30s who have dated many men and couldn't find true love. Though FL faces many issues related to family, work and bestfriend her performance was also a bit off towards the end. And I can't just bring myself up to justify the FL's action in last 2 episodes,.. FL's mom is definitely a mood breaker but her acting was good. FL's bestfriend (ML's sister) was real, no dramas and understandable..FL's character was like a little off at times, you can't really feel the truth in it.. Times when she can date other person within a short period of three months (portrayed without any explanation), how she handles her bestfriends misunderstanding, her work issue.. Though knowing all these, a man(Joon hee) who is completely head over heels at her is an ideal man appears only in dramaland :(..
ML's character is just wholesome and his acting was just awesome. And I personally think he is the only reason most of the viewers watched till the final scene.
I finally feel that the theme is not portrayed properly. What exactly is the drama trying to convey? love beyond everything? true love always ends happy? I m sure they'll breakup again after the final episode patch up considering the FL's character. And I really got no happiness in the ending though they both ended together. Felt bad for Joon hee :(
Cet avis était-il utile?
Same goes here...main lead girl was trying too hard to feel love and then she found love in a guy who was not only way too younger but a rare relationship...
I must say she was far more better than personal taste in acting terms but something was missing... I think the spontaneity that we enjoy in personal taste was lacking here...of course our oppa was amazing as always and he is getting better day by day... You will smile, cry and sometimes get irritated as they went through a lot and made many decisions that are not acceptable at first by our hearts...why guilty when its love? Why parting when you want to be together? Many whys and each why will keep you connected to characters and plot...
Plot is very good and executed well...though you will feel a drag sometimes but still a good story overall...
Music is good and quiet heart touching...
Overall a very good drama with some intense love and social issues...
Cet avis était-il utile?
SHOULD'VE BEEN A MOVIE
Something in the rain came to me as a really fresh drama and watching the teasers i was very much intrigued by it. The whole concept really got me interested and drew me in immediately.The initial episodes i will definitely say had me kind of wanting to watch more and more. This actually portrayed a very realistic sort of romance.
It felt like the writers were in the minds of their viewers and they made everything happen as you,the viewer, would have done, but yes unfortunately only lasted for the initial half of the drama.
Initially let me tell you, the viewers would be taken into the chemistry of the leads, the romantic encounters( there are a lottttt) and all of the little tit bit will make you continue watching it, but by the end of the initial half everything would start feeling irrelevant and repetitive.
I personally felt as if the writers were just dragging on the story line way more than they should have by creating unnecessary scenarios and fights that weren't even showed as properly resolved.
The whole plot of the second half basically revolved around crying, unnecessary arguments, lying to the other half, and miscommunication.
I would never say that SITR was a bad drama, not it wasn't. It just couldn't hold ones interest as the storyline deteriorated as the episodes passed and towards the end just too many plot holes were left open.
The ending was a underdeveloped, and yet again i repeat too many plotholes were left as it is. It was too abrupt and made it seem like after the whole reason of things not going right for them they just went back to square one. No conclusion, no proper communication NOTHING. They just kiss and make up? like i was so disappointed to see that the whole potential of the drama was wasted just for the sake of making it 16 episodes long.
Honestly it would have been perfect as a 2 hour movie, and believe me it would have been PERFECT, with nothing being missed out and all the faults in the drama being dragged out:/
OST-
I initially found the whole western songs playing in the background thing really beautiful during the starting episodes but by the time i came into episode 7 i was just bored, with the same songs playing every now and then that even not during the perfect timing it was just annoying.
I would conclude this by saying that Something in the rain would come in my category of an okayish drama which actually had a lot of potential but wasn't upto the mark and ended up disappointing me a bit.
If you are a sucker for romance and are really free i think you should check this one out, but if you are a bit tight on time and everything believe me there are some better options out there:)
Cet avis était-il utile?
But all good things must come to an end apparently. The "we can't tell anyone" thing just dragged on a little too long until they are found out. Then everyone freaks out and I stopped being able to relate. I know it's maybe a cultural thing for a grown woman to still have to get permission for things from her parents but as a westerner I couldn't relate and it started to grate on my nerves. I'm sorry if that is offensive, it's not meant to be.
The main couple's relationship seems built on a house of cards that crumbled with the slightest wind. There just wasn't much between them save a physical attraction. Perhaps I would have stuck with it if there was more I could relate to. Alas, there wasn't so I bailed around episode 12.
PS. the music gets REALLY repetitive.
Cet avis était-il utile?
This is a story about Jin-ah's journey, but I wish she had a bit more growth. Joon Hee is as great as they come, and I would love nothing more than to have my own Jung Hae In (seriously, this character warped my expectations for love like crazy!).
Perhaps I don't fully understand all the cultural implications and taboos here, although I suppose I could put in some proxies. I wish Jin-ah stood up to her parents more, and communicated better during crucial times, but I suppose this story was heartbreaking because of its realism (especially re: the workplace resolution). The ending was lukewarm though, and that was the unsatisfying part. If it were more definitive in either direction (happy or sad, forever or never), I would've possibly come around to the message that the writer was trying to convey. Instead, I'm left wondering: does love really conquer all, or do we have to come to accept the consequences of our actions? To be honest, it makes me feel a little empty inside. I'll surely come to revisit some of the cute scenes from episodes 3-6 sometime though. Episode 5 was probably the most deliriously happy episode I've ever seen in a kdrdama.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Brownsugar_milktea
2 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
If you don't want to read all of that, here's the key takeaway. It gets disappointing after like episodes 9.....so prepared yourself to find finishing this drama a chore
If you've ever watched the notebook, or any Nicolas Sparks book turn into movie adaptations, this drama does the same.
This drama starts promissing, even with the jump from them meeting again after ML has been in the state for 3 years, maybe more, I gloss over that confusing jump that had no establishment of their past relationship and if they ever liked each other in the past, so romance started off strong, it was bittersweet and so freaking cute to the front it became cringe and I wanted to barf. It was like I was eavesdropping on a married couple.
But honestly you can clearly see a decline in the drama. Them, mostly the female lead hiding their relationships from everyone was a flag to begin with. But I shrug it off because I was lured by the chemistry.
BUT ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
Reactions of their relationship was so toxic and unacceptable that I got angry, especially the mother who needs serious therapy. Like I understand the age gap, but they are two consensual adult in a relationships. She was judgemental and had such high standard that even if her own kids weren't perfect. When she slapped the ML in the face, I seriously almost threw my phone at the wall. How dare she. I understand different culture have different ways of working things. But even my overprotective hatian parents have a limit.
Everyone is acting as if they killed someone and not just dating.
But honestly what frustrated me even more was the FL wishy washy behaviour towards the ML.
1. Going on a blind date, even if it's to have something to hold agaisnt your mother or to even please your mother, was so so wrong and to expect the ML and sister to be okay with that was so insulting.
2. This girl really needed to grow up and have a thought for herself.
3. The constant lie and meddling and expect him to be okay with it. And she gets to validate her anger, like huh why did she get to be angry when she force the father on the ML when he wasn't ready. She again and again proves to be a serial liar. Lying to him easily like that.
4. their so much plot hole and weird way they went about to concluding storylines that it annoyed me. The sexual harrassment plotline resolution was so disappointing and shouldn't have been mentioned if that was the result.
The ending, nahhhh. I would much rather for the ML to end up single and her in that loveless mother's ideal type relationship. Bc even till the end she never stood up for herself and was held accountable just like everyone in this show.
Were we suppose to aww at their laugh, lift up girl in arm and rain ending, cause that wasn't it. How come he's always the one fighting and showing initiative. I would have much rather that the FL would have chased after him instead. Or let them go their separate ways.
Sorry for errors. I was angry and tired to read it over
Cet avis était-il utile?
The cast was really good (minus the mom, i will talk about this later) and the chemistry between the leads was really (really!) good. They did a great job of portraying their love and making it seem real and nerve-wracking. However this was SO stretched out. Someone else said this could have easily been a 2 hour movie. I 100% agree. They wasted so many minutes with just non moving shots of characters walking or sitting or looking sad. Every time a character got angry and would go to a bar I knew that there would be at least 5 minutes of them angrily opening ad drinking multiple bottles of alcohol. With ZERO talking in between. It got to be that every time I would see a character get mad and go to a restaurant I would just start skipping forward because I knew there were multiple minutes of useless footage in between the next dialogue.
NEXT:
The music. So so bad. The songs themselves aren't horrible.(They aren't good either). But the sheer amount of times I had to hear that dumb "sometimes it's hard to be a woman". I wanted to strangle someone. This was probably my LEAST favorite part of the drama. Their music choices were so poor, I can't even explain.
NEXT (possible spoliers):
They created a few good characters. However, the mother is INSANE. Clinically. No person would ever act like that, especially if they love their kids. It is nonsensical that Jin-ah would forgive her mother after everything that she did. If my mom acted even half as horribly rude and psychotic as her mother I would seriously consider not speaking to her again. That is how horrible her mother is.
Another, less important point: Jin-ah's ex-boyfriend's characterization also makes no sense. He cheats on her, but then can't stop stalking her and following her? He truly makes no sense and was not needed in the show.
Cet avis était-il utile?
After episode eight this drama falls apart because of its lack of growth. The plot stagnates. Conflicts that could have been resolved quickly or easily are instead left to fester and come to unsatisfying conclusions. For me, the worst illustration of this was JinA's indecision surrounding her mother's disapproval. JinA disregarded JunHui's feelings regularly. The sheer amount of times he was made to apologize when it should have been her apologizing to him were too numerous to count. It was so disheartening to see how she was treating him in the later episodes after the care she showed him in the first half of the show. JinA's mother is undoubtedly the antagonist of the show but in a much more real way, JinA is just as bad. By the final episode, I was no longer rooting for our main couple. They lacked basic communication skills and the disparity between JunHui's depth of feeling for JinA and her relatively shallow feelings for him were hurdles I felt they couldn't overcome. I thought JunHui deserved better.
Overall Something in the Rain is a classic case of failed potential. The writer and director use unique camera work and emotional storytelling to mask the relative lack of plot development. By the second half of the show, this becomes obvious and the show's stagnation gets boring. There was so much more this drama could have accomplished. If you're thinking of giving it a try I suggest watching My Mister first as they have very similar moods but My Mister succeeds where Something in the Rain fails.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Between East and West: A Deep Dive into Cultural and Personal Struggles of women
The story is about the difficult life of a women in Korea (East) and their attempt to break free and become independent (West).The struggles FL trap her and other women in an endless cycle of helplessness and suffering, with the ending highlighting just how miserable she remains. What began as a romantic fantasy (Western) explodes into a patriarchal, chauvinistic, and restrictive reality. The treatment of women in Korean society evokes revulsion throughout the series.
When she tries to "escape" (To escape the pressures of society and family, to escape the harassment of employers, to escape her partner) she encounters resistance and feels guilty (. There is a selfishness that is not accepted in Korean society, and we witness the injustice within the systems (Although she complains about the employers' assaults, they become the victims.)
The "Western" woman of the fantasies is independent, wants to do everything alone, and refuses to flee with her lover to the USA to maintain her independence. However, by doing so, she remains miserable within the family and societal systems.
Her partner tries to help her, but without success, making him feel miserable and useless, creating an irreconcilable dissonance between East and West. He wants to take charge and be the man, but she refuses to accept the help and be the nurturing woman.
The subplot at work takes a central place and adds depth to the main story. It's hard to side with the woman throughout the series because she acts foolishly and puts herself in no-win situations, but it's understandable that society created her immaturity and confusion. The frustration follows viewers to the end. Why doesn't she choose to escape with the man who offers her happiness and freedom? She prefers to confront forces she has no chance of defeating (work harassment, family pressures, etc.).
The series reflects the spirit of the times and the changes in Korean society with depth and daring. It raises questions about maintaining family and group values while striving to be free and happy.
Music:
99% of the music is truly awful. It's unclear what goes through this director's mind, but this is already the second series where he chooses unbearable American music. This time it's old country music, which is really bad and annoying, overshadowing the viewing experience.
Actors:
All the actors, without exception, are truly excellent. The main couple is wonderful and very talented. I loved both of them and fell in love with the ML actor after this series, even though I've seen him in other series before. He has a baby face, which isn't the typical masculine type, but he is captivating and talented.
Rewatchability:
You can watch this at least twice. at least for the first half. The love between the couple is very moving and feels real.
Overall
A beautiful, critical, and courageous series, different from all other SKorean dramas. However, it leaves you with questions and complete confusion in a very miserable and detached ending, without a real resolution or sense of fulfillment. As SKorea searches for its new identity, between East and West, the screenwriter is also ultimately confused.
You could write an entire research book about this series. This happens because humanity still hasn't found its identity in the world, identities are blurring, and it's unclear who is the man and who is the woman, and what each one wants to be.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Disappointing. So so disappointing.
Ah. God I really wanted to give this 10/10 with watching just the first couple of episodes. But the ending and last episodes were so disappointing. It should have ended in episode 9 or 10. It had no plot so the rest of the episodes were dragging.First of all let me just say, the cast did a really good job. I felt their emotions very well. For me it's 10/10.
Best friends would never do that to each other. I hated how kyung sun handled the situation with her best friend dating her younger brother. The family drama was too extended. I am an Asian too and believe me Asian parents do behave like that but it was still too much. The way Jin-A's mom acted was despicable. And the way they handled sexual harassment was very very wrong too. The drama should have encouraged people to speak up against sexual harrasment but in reality it did the opposite.
So many people were complaining about Joon Hee's possessiveness but I did not mind it. And actually kind of understood. He was younger than her so the insecurity was justified. But hated how controlling he was sometimes and how Jin-A always lied about things. The characters did not have a good impression when the drama ended.
After watching a couple of episodes I think my expectations were too high. I was severely disappointed by this drama. At first I couldn't figure out why this amazing drama would have such low ranking. Now I get it. I learned it the hard way.
Cet avis était-il utile?
