6
52
3
virgievirgie
Lost in Dramaland
Good acting & interesting characters, but low production value & poor romance.
Subjective Rating - 8.0
Objective Rating - 8.5+
Usually, “Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty” is not really my go-to type of genre, but due to the rave reviews, and I haven’t seen Yang Xu Wen in a while, I figured I would give this a try. However, I think I picked the wrong time to watch this as my mood changed and I was sick and stressed out. Thus, I was unable to fully be invested in the drama and the investigations.
I was not immediately hooked on the drama. Initially I thought the drama started really slow and took me about 10 episodes to get into the story. But looking back, I actually quite enjoyed the first arc, compared to the next couple stories. Not all the strange tales were interesting to me. I find that I am more interested in the character development, friendships and the politics more than the actual strange tales and investigations. But this is of course a very subjective view and most watchers are probably watching this for the investigations.
The best part about this drama for me is the friendship between the two main leads. Lu Ling Feng is an intelligent, young general who follows and enforces all rules. Su Wu Ming is an experienced investigator and the bright disciple of the famous Detective Di. They clashed when first met as they have very different personalities and styles of investigation. Seeing how their friendship develops and how they complement each other is really fun. I also enjoy the character development of Lu Ling Feng, under the guidance and friendship of Su Wu Ming.
Another bright spot for me is the teacher/student relationship between Lu Ling Feng and Xue Huang. Once a reluctant teacher, Lu Ling Feng has come to care for Xue Huan as a teacher and big brother. Anson Shi, who played Xue Huan, is a promising young actor. I really enjoy all his scenes, including his fight scenes.
Unfortunately, my biggest criticism would be the romance storylines. As much as I love romances and I am not looking for it in this drama, the writers really shouldn’t have included them if they can’t do a great job writing. The romance between Pei Xi Jun and Lu Ling Feng was not developed well. They don’t have any chemistry and I don’t see how all of a sudden they became a couple. Then their romance disappeared like nothing happened until the very last couple episodes when it was mentioned again. The romance between Su Wu Ming and Ying Tao is just as awkwardly developed. Well, at least they have some fun banters. Having said all that, the romances took up very little screen time and can be ignored or fast forwarded.
The production value isn’t very high. The CGI is not good, especially with the animals and the fake-looking magic tricks in the last arc. It gives an even worse impression in the last arc when the story moved back to Chang’an. I can’t help but compare (unfairly, I know) the beautiful cinematography in “The Longest Day in Chang’An” to this drama, especially the night scenes and scenes of the tower. The fight scenes are not that great either. Not horrible, but not great. I know it’s another unfair comparison, but after just finished watching “Side Story of Fox Volant”, seeing these fight scenes is not a good experience. Yang Xu Wen couldn’t convince me that he was a great fighter or an actor that is good with fight scenes. Again, he’s not bad but he’s not Leo Wu or Qin Jun Jie. Although the main characters all use their own voices (thank goodness), the dubbing wasn’t done well. Sometimes, the voices and the mouths don’t match.
To end on a positive note, I do enjoy seeing many smart people in this drama. There isn’t anyone annoying. The main leads, Lu Ling Feng, Su Wu Ming, Pei Xi Jun, Ying Tao, young Xue Huan and funny Fei Ji Shi are all smart people making smart choices. There is no damsel in distress and the female characters contribute in their own ways. The acting is pretty good, even for the guest roles and supporting cast.
Other Random Observations:
1. There’s something about the way Su Wu Ming speaks that bugs me. Not the dubbing, but the rhythm of his speech and the pauses. I know I am weird.
2. The Crown Prince does not look very princely. I can’t picture him being the emperor next. On the other hand, the princess looks like she could be the next empress.
3. I was very impressed by the way Lu Ling Feng stopped the disaster from happening in the last arc. He couldn’t fix the issue, but found a workaround! Smart!
4. FL’s introduction is annoying, but I am glad she got so much better.
Completed: 10/23/2022
Objective Rating - 8.5+
Usually, “Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty” is not really my go-to type of genre, but due to the rave reviews, and I haven’t seen Yang Xu Wen in a while, I figured I would give this a try. However, I think I picked the wrong time to watch this as my mood changed and I was sick and stressed out. Thus, I was unable to fully be invested in the drama and the investigations.
I was not immediately hooked on the drama. Initially I thought the drama started really slow and took me about 10 episodes to get into the story. But looking back, I actually quite enjoyed the first arc, compared to the next couple stories. Not all the strange tales were interesting to me. I find that I am more interested in the character development, friendships and the politics more than the actual strange tales and investigations. But this is of course a very subjective view and most watchers are probably watching this for the investigations.
The best part about this drama for me is the friendship between the two main leads. Lu Ling Feng is an intelligent, young general who follows and enforces all rules. Su Wu Ming is an experienced investigator and the bright disciple of the famous Detective Di. They clashed when first met as they have very different personalities and styles of investigation. Seeing how their friendship develops and how they complement each other is really fun. I also enjoy the character development of Lu Ling Feng, under the guidance and friendship of Su Wu Ming.
Another bright spot for me is the teacher/student relationship between Lu Ling Feng and Xue Huang. Once a reluctant teacher, Lu Ling Feng has come to care for Xue Huan as a teacher and big brother. Anson Shi, who played Xue Huan, is a promising young actor. I really enjoy all his scenes, including his fight scenes.
Unfortunately, my biggest criticism would be the romance storylines. As much as I love romances and I am not looking for it in this drama, the writers really shouldn’t have included them if they can’t do a great job writing. The romance between Pei Xi Jun and Lu Ling Feng was not developed well. They don’t have any chemistry and I don’t see how all of a sudden they became a couple. Then their romance disappeared like nothing happened until the very last couple episodes when it was mentioned again. The romance between Su Wu Ming and Ying Tao is just as awkwardly developed. Well, at least they have some fun banters. Having said all that, the romances took up very little screen time and can be ignored or fast forwarded.
The production value isn’t very high. The CGI is not good, especially with the animals and the fake-looking magic tricks in the last arc. It gives an even worse impression in the last arc when the story moved back to Chang’an. I can’t help but compare (unfairly, I know) the beautiful cinematography in “The Longest Day in Chang’An” to this drama, especially the night scenes and scenes of the tower. The fight scenes are not that great either. Not horrible, but not great. I know it’s another unfair comparison, but after just finished watching “Side Story of Fox Volant”, seeing these fight scenes is not a good experience. Yang Xu Wen couldn’t convince me that he was a great fighter or an actor that is good with fight scenes. Again, he’s not bad but he’s not Leo Wu or Qin Jun Jie. Although the main characters all use their own voices (thank goodness), the dubbing wasn’t done well. Sometimes, the voices and the mouths don’t match.
To end on a positive note, I do enjoy seeing many smart people in this drama. There isn’t anyone annoying. The main leads, Lu Ling Feng, Su Wu Ming, Pei Xi Jun, Ying Tao, young Xue Huan and funny Fei Ji Shi are all smart people making smart choices. There is no damsel in distress and the female characters contribute in their own ways. The acting is pretty good, even for the guest roles and supporting cast.
Other Random Observations:
1. There’s something about the way Su Wu Ming speaks that bugs me. Not the dubbing, but the rhythm of his speech and the pauses. I know I am weird.
2. The Crown Prince does not look very princely. I can’t picture him being the emperor next. On the other hand, the princess looks like she could be the next empress.
3. I was very impressed by the way Lu Ling Feng stopped the disaster from happening in the last arc. He couldn’t fix the issue, but found a workaround! Smart!
4. FL’s introduction is annoying, but I am glad she got so much better.
Completed: 10/23/2022
Cet avis était-il utile?
